The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsStar Trek Discovery: what's with all the crying?
Every 15 minutes, someone is getting teary eyed or outright crying, and no one is worse about this than the main character, Michael Burnham...who is a woman.
WTH?
tymorial
(3,433 posts)I could go on.
Honestly, I couldn't stand the show for many reasons though I really liked her character. She was interesting even if Spock never mentioned her, like ever.
I wished they didn't try to shoe horn that show into the main series universe. It left so many questions.
Sorry, I am a geek and stuff like this irks me.
targetpractice
(4,919 posts)... It's a TV show.
Good drama, in my opinion. I cried back. But, I understand some don't like it.
It seems like there are so many flavors of Star Trek, that fans can find their home.
Upon edit: I'm an old Star Trek fan, but my main beef with Discovery is the ship's design. I'm good with the rest.
Response to stopbush (Original post)
Freelancer This message was self-deleted by its author.
exboyfil
(17,862 posts)Kirk taking command of the Enterprise. At the end of the 2nd season, they went into the future for a completely ridiculous reason that I don't have the patience to explain. The 3rd season involves the galaxy after the fall of the Federation as I understand it (I haven't seen any episodes since season 2).
Response to exboyfil (Reply #5)
Freelancer This message was self-deleted by its author.
exboyfil
(17,862 posts)Watched the first two seasons. One part I liked was the actor who played Pike. I thought they destroyed Spock, and I find the Burnham character to be utterly ridiculous.
Needless to say they took canon and broke it with a sledgehammer. I would have been interested in a Star Trek series with Pike, but not after what I witnessed in the 2nd season. I dropped my CBS All Access.
I thought they handled the Talos IV story line very well though (except for the Spock situation).
I heard the premise for the fall of the Federation in the future. It is ridiculous and goes counter to a logical fall that has already been built into canon. The canon states that warp drive damages space. I could see a time in the future in which various solar systems are isolated because of that fact. I assumed that was the direction they were going.
Their scriptwriters know very little about Star Trek. They also know very little about science. I also think they miss the spirit of Star Trek .
The best Star Trek made since Star Trek went off television in the 1990s is the second episode of this season's Mandolorian. It felt more like a Star Trek episode than any of the Kelvin timeline movies or Discovery. The Orville also has some good Star Trek as well.