Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Aristus

(66,328 posts)
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 12:22 PM Mar 2022

When I was studying to be a Physician Assistant, I never dreamed I would have to spend so much time

explaining the principle of cause-and-effect.

I can't count how many patients I have had complaining of coughing and shortness of breath. I ask them if they smoke, and when they say 'yes', I ask them how they could possibly be surprised at the resulting symptoms, or so confused about how to make them go away.

I tell you, the Big 7 have to be the greatest salespeople in history: "Hey! We would like you to pay us to poison you to death. But before you die, you, your breath, your car, your home, and your clothes will smell bad, your lips and fingers will turn yellow, and most people won't want to be around you. How does that sound?"

29 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
When I was studying to be a Physician Assistant, I never dreamed I would have to spend so much time (Original Post) Aristus Mar 2022 OP
It ain't just you Jilly_in_VA Mar 2022 #1
I respect nurses so much. Aristus Mar 2022 #18
And I thought about becoming a PA! Jilly_in_VA Mar 2022 #24
My mother died of lung cancer Mme. Defarge Mar 2022 #2
Selling addiction is crazy-easy. zaj Mar 2022 #3
I remember talking to someone who complained bitterly about how many medications Tadpole Raisin Mar 2022 #4
My uncle died of diabeties I_UndergroundPanther Mar 2022 #20
You forgot the part about how cool you look with a cigarette- at least when you're not coughing. hay rick Mar 2022 #5
Adding vanity....sallow skin and extra wrinkles around the mouth MLAA Mar 2022 #6
there is also the fact that people can get hooked on tobacco through second hand smoke. demigoddess Mar 2022 #7
More anti-smoking limp dick ads should be created summer_in_TX Mar 2022 #8
Way back in the day, they would say smoking was good for your health IronLionZion Mar 2022 #9
K and R x 1000 Ferrets are Cool Mar 2022 #10
This message was self-deleted by its author jfz9580m Mar 2022 #11
As an ex smoker of over 50 years appleannie1 Mar 2022 #12
I remember reading that it is more addictive than heroin. Native Mar 2022 #13
Patches just gave me big blisters where I put them. appleannie1 Mar 2022 #26
Thanks! Man, this is such a good issue. It's a big and costly issue that has to be solved ancianita Mar 2022 #14
My chain-smoking 70 year-old sister-in-law Mr.Bill Mar 2022 #15
I'm 67 and have never smoked (I mean aside from trying a cigarette as a teenager just deurbano Mar 2022 #16
You are so right wendyb-NC Mar 2022 #17
Never smoked I_UndergroundPanther Mar 2022 #19
I quit heroin, cocaine, methadone (damn near 13 years of maintenance), and alcohol happybird Mar 2022 #21
It's amazing how addictive tobacco is. It took me almost 40 years to Emile Mar 2022 #22
Patient education is a big part of medical practice, but not emphasized in training programs. Irish_Dem Mar 2022 #23
I love that my doctor isn't judgmental. zanana1 Mar 2022 #25
Eating is a natural act; a life-sustaining act. Aristus Mar 2022 #27
You catch more flies with honey. zanana1 Mar 2022 #28
I quit smoking for the final time in the Carter Administration... Wounded Bear Mar 2022 #29

Jilly_in_VA

(9,966 posts)
1. It ain't just you
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 12:29 PM
Mar 2022

I spent approximately the same amount of time doing the same thing as a nurse, especially in home health. It's endemic to the profession.

Jilly_in_VA

(9,966 posts)
24. And I thought about becoming a PA!
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 10:03 AM
Mar 2022

A guy I worked with in one ICU was accepted to PA school and we all were in awe. But his school was in ND and there wasn't anyplace close. It was the same issue I'd had with midwifery training earlier. So I stayed in critical care, where I'd bounced back to after home health (loooooong story).

Mme. Defarge

(8,028 posts)
2. My mother died of lung cancer
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 12:43 PM
Mar 2022

as a result of her longtime exposure to second hand smoke. Several years before that her husband - a chain smoker - died from smoking related causes.

Tadpole Raisin

(972 posts)
4. I remember talking to someone who complained bitterly about how many medications
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 01:57 PM
Mar 2022

they were on and that all the doctors did was pump pills. In a conversation lasting about 10 minutes I made a few suggestions for changes in their lifestyle or diet that might help them get off those drugs.

Very gently I said they could just slowly change one thing at a time, work with the doctor, and over months they would start seeing the benefits and that it would help them feel like they were getting back control of their life and reduce some specific symptoms they were concerned about.

The response? “Well my doctor gives me something to take for that.”

People complain about taking pills but drugs are just too easy. It’s the quick fix they know is not a fix but denial and blame are also quick and easy.

I_UndergroundPanther

(12,463 posts)
20. My uncle died of diabeties
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 12:58 AM
Mar 2022

So in my later years I got it too.

Did a crash course on how to manage diabeties
Lost a ton of weight,watch what I eat and my blood sugar is around 91 to 112.

hay rick

(7,608 posts)
5. You forgot the part about how cool you look with a cigarette- at least when you're not coughing.
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:02 PM
Mar 2022

I'm thinking that must be why I smoked for fifteen+ years before I gave it up when the idea of self-destructive addiction triggered a critical mass of revulsion.

demigoddess

(6,640 posts)
7. there is also the fact that people can get hooked on tobacco through second hand smoke.
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:07 PM
Mar 2022

Most parents should be told they are making their kids hooked on tobacco and they will probably start smoking in their teens.
I got addicted to tabacco by having daily coffee with a neighbor. Anti smoking me actually bought a pack of cigarettes and started to smoke them. Then realized what I was doing and stopped it.

summer_in_TX

(2,738 posts)
8. More anti-smoking limp dick ads should be created
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:10 PM
Mar 2022

Too many smokers have no idea about the connection between smoking and becoming impotent.

IronLionZion

(45,434 posts)
9. Way back in the day, they would say smoking was good for your health
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:13 PM
Mar 2022

and some developing countries still promote that myth.

Response to Aristus (Original post)

appleannie1

(5,067 posts)
12. As an ex smoker of over 50 years
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:42 PM
Mar 2022

I can assure you it is not easy to quit. I tried everything, cold turkey, cut back so many each day, chewing gum, nicotine gum, patches, hypnotism, and finally 10 days on Chantix and I have not smoked since. It has been over 10 years now and I still get an urge every once in a while.

Native

(5,942 posts)
13. I remember reading that it is more addictive than heroin.
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 02:55 PM
Mar 2022

I too tried everything. I finally quit with the help of patches back in the day when they were prescribed. I only smoked for about 10 years, and I was a light smoker, but I was 100% addicted. And I never enjoyed smoking. It always made me feel like crap, and I desperately wanted to quit, but man did I become a nasty human being whenever I tried to go cold turkey. Fortunately the patches worked like a charm for me.

appleannie1

(5,067 posts)
26. Patches just gave me big blisters where I put them.
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 10:27 AM
Mar 2022

My doctor told me he had a patient that quit cocaine but could not stop smoking. He too said nicotine was more addictive. I am super glad I was able to quit. I have no idea how I could afford to smoke at today's cost. I know people that can't afford to eat more than one cheap meal a day but buy a pack of butts every day. They can't afford anything else but manage to get that pack of cigarettes.

ancianita

(36,053 posts)
14. Thanks! Man, this is such a good issue. It's a big and costly issue that has to be solved
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 03:00 PM
Mar 2022

or we won't be able to help build a better future for our descendants.

This cause-effect problem hits the 30% who, even though well educated, don't
realize that 7 out of 10 people they meet didn't get past high school, nor do the 30% grasp how that education difference plays out in society over time. It hits them and society's wallet hardest.

Two reasons:
First, at least two generations of Americans have had it drilled into them, to the level of a cultural norm, that we don't need no college, because what America needs is innovation -- see Bill Gates, Zuckerberg, Jobs, Madden, etc, etc. -- and that cultural norm keeps 30 exceptions front and center, to get over 300 million to believe they can be like that, too. So corporations have campaigned for a culture of ignorant consumers. Having is being/Money is freedom -- a good size of 70% of Americans. College grads and 'some college' make up the other 30%. That's a lot of people walking around with a high school understanding of how things work.

Second, public schools must put more consistent planning, teaching and testing emphasis on thinking skills, and start that emphasis no later than 7th grade, so that kids understand cause-effect thinking and other logic strengths, as well as fallacies.

Also understand that the pupil-teacher ratio of 30:1 makes teaching logic and argument actually the hardest things to teach. My experience as a high school teacher of research and debate has been that it's not enough to have students point out when logic is faulty. That's typical of what they get, mostly, because flaws are easiest for teachers to point out and explain. The most constructive units teach what topics are arguable, what their experience with arguers and arguments has been, who benefits in arguments, when and why argument its supports are solid. ALL with plenty of example from both teacher and students.

It takes a few years to grasp examples of cause-effect across various areas of life, and so it should be systematically taught. What happens to people who read v those who don't read is one example. Or the simple example of a person slipping on a banana peel -- either of these get streams of issues opened up (induction/deduction, audience capacity, facts v opinion, time management, etc).
A commitment to openness and the whole truth are mandatory components of any units that teach argument.

I have to say that I learned this from students: they say previous teachers didn't teach something, just because they didn't learn it, and I could prove to them for a fact that I knew and saw those teachers' classes and lessons.
I've learned that poor learners with poor attitudes need logic repeated, and again later, and usually the hard way.

Which bring us around to why Republicans are generally stupid -- because they exemplify those who don't get cause-effect until it actually happens to them; e.g., covid and their behavior, school v no school...

And because they weren't taught, professionals like you have to make up for that during your entire career.

Ignorance, denial and addiction are expensive; capitalism prefers it that way.

Sorry for going on and on, but this sticks in my craw, too.







Mr.Bill

(24,284 posts)
15. My chain-smoking 70 year-old sister-in-law
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 03:01 PM
Mar 2022

who coughs every 30 seconds 24 hours a day calls it her "allergies".

After I heard that enough times I told her the only thing she is allergic to is Marlboro cigarettes.

deurbano

(2,895 posts)
16. I'm 67 and have never smoked (I mean aside from trying a cigarette as a teenager just
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 03:05 PM
Mar 2022

to see what it was like... and just a few puffs)... but sometimes I feel a craving for a cigarette! (Not enough to actually buy any... but still.) I think the intense advertising I experienced growing up.. plus the ubiquitous product placement in movies and on TV have definitely played a role... and maybe the second hand smoke from parents who smoked?

I really find it a triumph of the human spirit when people manage to quit smoking, especially given these cravings I experience, despite never having started!

wendyb-NC

(3,325 posts)
17. You are so right
Fri Mar 18, 2022, 04:01 PM
Mar 2022

Some people have brains that are unable to make the simplest connections, regarding their health, etc.

I_UndergroundPanther

(12,463 posts)
19. Never smoked
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 12:54 AM
Mar 2022

Grew up in a household with 4 smokers. I decided early on I was never going to smoke. So I never have. I remember walking into my livingroom as a kid and the smoke in the air formed layers of different densities.

Since I had no chair or place to sit on the couch I sat on the floor when we all gathered round to watch stuff like all in the family. I got home from school sat on the floor while watching cartoons too. It was less smoky and stinky on the floor.I think I may have gotten lung damage if I was up to the levels where the family was smoking like fiends and smoke was in thick layers in the air.

I think cigarettes are incredibly disgusting.

On a positive note both my sisters and my mom quit eventually.

happybird

(4,606 posts)
21. I quit heroin, cocaine, methadone (damn near 13 years of maintenance), and alcohol
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 04:18 AM
Mar 2022

I now feel no shame in admitting I was an IV drug user. It was intense and eventually utterly miserable, and I’m lucky to have survived the whole mess.

I haven’t been able to quit smoking cigarettes.

I’m watching my Mom die of COPD. My grandparents died from COPD. Her sister was recently diagnosed with it. I’ve tried and tried but have been unable to quit. I know what it is doing to me, I know I will likely also die from COPD. And they never smoked pot or crack for a couple decades, just cigarettes. I’m so fucked. Nicotine and caffeine seem to be the two things I cannot conquer.

Emile

(22,715 posts)
22. It's amazing how addictive tobacco is. It took me almost 40 years to
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 07:04 AM
Mar 2022

kick the habit. 30 years smoking and 10 years of smokeless tobacco.

Irish_Dem

(47,028 posts)
23. Patient education is a big part of medical practice, but not emphasized in training programs.
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 09:28 AM
Mar 2022

I think most of us in health care spend a lot of time explaining things.

zanana1

(6,112 posts)
25. I love that my doctor isn't judgmental.
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 10:26 AM
Mar 2022

She knows that I'm overweight and she knows that I know that. She also knows that a diet won't be successful if it's pushed on me..

Aristus

(66,328 posts)
27. Eating is a natural act; a life-sustaining act.
Sat Mar 19, 2022, 10:37 AM
Mar 2022

It’s natural to enjoy eating and to want to eat a lot if the food is good, or if we’re assuaging an emotional need.

Smoking is an unnatural, life-taking habit that we have to be coerced into adopting; (“It will make you a man” - “People will think you’re glamorous and sophisticated”) It absolutely shatters me that people are still doing it, and that it could kill my patients whom I love and care about.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»When I was studying to be...