Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NNadir

(38,052 posts)
Sat Apr 1, 2023, 12:55 PM Apr 2023

A Compassionate Discussion of Caring for the Dying.

Recently my wife and I updated our wills, our revocable trusts, and including our living wills. The latter are about the burden of decisions to be made on my behalf - I selfishly hope my wife will outlive me - either by my wife or my sons.

I am thinking about the end of my life a great deal lately - I'm at that age where waking up is something of a pleasant surprise - and I'm thinking about the huge psychological (and sometimes physical and fiscal) difficulty that attending to my death will be for my survivors.

The most powerful emotional pain for me in attending those whose deaths in which I was a participant, either in a primary or secondary capacity as an attendant, was how to talk to the dying about what is happening.

This beautifully written article by a palliative care physician was published in the New York Times, and I found it moving.

As a Doctor, I Know Being Ready to Die Is an Illusion

Dr. Sunita Puri, NY Times Opinion, March 29, 2023

Some excerpts:

Nine years ago, near the end of my residency training, I sat opposite a patient, wondering whether he’d accepted that he was dying. He was in his 60s, an artist with sinewy arms and serene eyes, someone I’d come to know well over the past three years. Cancer had broken into his liver and bone marrow, robbing him of hunger and energy.

Each time I saw him, the hollows of his cheeks deepened. I wanted to tell him that he was dying, that I wanted to understand how he envisioned spending his remaining life. But he mostly spoke about his plans: a camping vacation in six months, a friend’s wedding after that.

I awaited some sort of arbitrary signal that it was safe to talk about dying. Maybe he’d tell me that he didn’t want more chemotherapy or that his affairs were in order. Like many physicians, I feared that by talking about death before he appeared ready, I might take away his hope, make him give up or send him into an unstoppable tailspin of anxiety and depression.

Whether he hadn’t accepted his fate or simply wished to avoid the subject, he didn’t appear to be ready to talk about his death. How could I reconcile what appeared to be our radically different interpretations of his condition? By waiting for him to act in ways that I understood as acceptance, I thought that I was being compassionate and sensitive...

...Nine years ago, I think my patient sensed both my urge to tell him something and my hesitance. “Are you OK?” he asked me one day.

“I’ve been meaning to talk to you about something,” I stammered, looking past him at the eye chart on the wall. “I’m worried about you, because every time I see you, you’re losing weight and seem less like yourself.”

“It’s because I’m dying.” He was matter-of-fact, as though he’d just said it was raining outside.

I was stunned, then relieved. Yet I still struggled to tell him what I wanted to say. “I am so sorry,” I whispered.

“It’s not your fault. My father died in my arms. So did my wife,” he said. “It’s just my turn now.”

“I feel bad that I didn’t talk to you about this sooner,” I said. “I thought I’d upset you or maybe you weren’t ready yet.”

He laughed. “Ready?” he said. “I’ve wrapped my head around being dead, certainly. Not sure if I’ll ever really be ready. It’s not like packing a bag and standing outside waiting for a taxi.”

He died in his sleep a month later, missing his vacation and his friend’s wedding. Even if he told me he was ready, nothing could have lessened the blunt force of losing him.


Physicians feel it too.

It's not easy.

Dr. Puri is the author of this book: That Good Night. It's an eloquent title. I think I'll read it.
4 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A Compassionate Discussion of Caring for the Dying. (Original Post) NNadir Apr 2023 OP
Timely. Thanks for this. cilla4progress Apr 2023 #1
My wife was a nurse for 30+ years. Mr.Bill Apr 2023 #2
I certainly understand what you are saying. Kudos to your wife. n/t. NNadir Apr 2023 #4
being at the age onethatcares Apr 2023 #3

cilla4progress

(26,525 posts)
1. Timely. Thanks for this.
Sat Apr 1, 2023, 01:29 PM
Apr 2023

We think husband's 95 yo mom has begun transitioning. Her lungs have been congested lately, and she fell and cracked 2 ribs at her assisted living home last week.

She's a hardy soul so perhaps she'll outrun this!

Mr.Bill

(24,906 posts)
2. My wife was a nurse for 30+ years.
Sat Apr 1, 2023, 09:17 PM
Apr 2023

I wish I could articulate some of the stories she has told me.

The short version is that she says there is pretty much nothing more meaninful that a nurse can do than to help someone die comfortably, at peace and not feeling alone. It's not troubling, rather it's a big part of why you love being a nurse.

I hope everyone understands what I have trouble explaining. It would be easy to take it wrong.

onethatcares

(16,992 posts)
3. being at the age
Sun Apr 2, 2023, 09:27 AM
Apr 2023

where there's a lot more days behind me than in front I think about dying or the end and just want to be remembered as someone that cared for others.

there's nights I lie in bed and before falling asleep I think of all the stupid stuff I did along the road and hope I caused no lasting harm.

I think it's fairly common for us all to think about it. It's not knowing when that scares the beejeeezzzuss out of us.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»A Compassionate Discussio...