Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

debm55

(60,612 posts)
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 01:57 PM Jun 2023

What group would you have liked to have sung in or played an instrument in?

Last edited Fri Jun 2, 2023, 04:54 PM - Edit history (2)

You would be just as good as the person you are replacing once your in the band.
60 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What group would you have liked to have sung in or played an instrument in? (Original Post) debm55 Jun 2023 OP
Rush. Drummer! Might as well go for legend. :) n/t brewens Jun 2023 #1
The Chieftains. Fiddle NoRethugFriends Jun 2023 #2
Van Halen WalkerinSC Jun 2023 #3
I wanted to *be* Linda Ronstadt! Diamond_Dog Jun 2023 #4
Does this mean I'm also badass enough at singing/playing Hugh_Lebowski Jun 2023 #5
LOL , no it simply means you be be as good as the person you are replacing. You wouldn't mess up debm55 Jun 2023 #6
You didn't link to that thread showing how well you sing Copperhead Road. Here: highplainsdem Jun 2023 #14
Well thanks, m'lady ... Hugh_Lebowski Jun 2023 #16
Hugh, that's very good. You are very talented. Why didn't you go into the music field professionally debm55 Jun 2023 #19
Sly and the Family Stone GenXer47 Jun 2023 #7
Nope-Hot Fun in the Summertime, Oh yeah debm55 Jun 2023 #8
They even posted an ad for a drummer: GreenWave Jun 2023 #11
LOL That was summertime groove debm55 Jun 2023 #20
Pretenders, if I could sing like Chrissie Hynde: highplainsdem Jun 2023 #9
Chrissie is a Goddess and back then there definitely were not many ... Hugh_Lebowski Jun 2023 #17
I've heard some of them, but I haven't heard any I thought were highplainsdem Jun 2023 #22
Absolutely beautiful. Thank you highplainsdem. debm55 Jun 2023 #26
Wouldn't that be wonderful for be in the Pretenders and Golden Earring? What a great choice of . debm55 Jun 2023 #28
Milli Vanilli GreenWave Jun 2023 #10
Anyone could do Milli Vanilli. Shit even they didn't do Milli Vanilli debm55 Jun 2023 #21
I gotta start somewhere! GreenWave Jun 2023 #31
Pedal steel guitar for Creedence Clearwater Revival, Baby! Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #12
I like the pedal steel guitar. I think you would have been great playing it on their earlier songs. debm55 Jun 2023 #23
Perhaps I should go with a simple lap steel guitar Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #27
Clarence White VGNonly Jun 2023 #30
Marty Stuart has it now Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #32
A nice video VGNonly Jun 2023 #33
I've studied the drawing closely Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #34
B Benders Are Hard To Use ProfessorGAC Jun 2023 #44
Clarence White sure had the skill set, and then some Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #50
I'd Have To Hear That ProfessorGAC Jun 2023 #54
Listen. It's genuinely viable because the wizard, Gene Parson, made it work Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #58
The cannon guy in whatever orchestra played the 1812 Overture! Floyd R. Turbo Jun 2023 #13
Well get ready for July 4th, Very original reply debm55 Jun 2023 #45
Tower of Power calikid Jun 2023 #15
Good choice. debm55 Jun 2023 #24
Bass with either the Youngbloods or the Doors DFW Jun 2023 #18
Had a Youngbloods song sung at my wedding, and the Doors--cried when Jim died. You should try and debm55 Jun 2023 #25
WHICH country did you have in mind? DFW Jun 2023 #36
Sorry I misread part of your comment. debm55 Jun 2023 #38
I always though it intresting the Doors didn't have a conventional bass player Brother Buzz Jun 2023 #39
I played both DFW Jun 2023 #53
Bangles. Didn't they do "Walk Like an Egyptian"? CTyankee Jun 2023 #29
Yes the did. debm55 Jun 2023 #46
we used to dance to it in Jazzercise. I always enjoyed all the hand gestures... CTyankee Jun 2023 #59
I would like to have taken Mr.Bill Jun 2023 #35
The good ol Grateful Dead Axelrods_Typewriter Jun 2023 #37
Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band lpbk2713 Jun 2023 #40
The Metropolitan Opera. Ocelot II Jun 2023 #41
Wonderful and so you. i have come to love your appreciation of classical music and the opera. debm55 Jun 2023 #47
Nobody will care. Aristus Jun 2023 #42
Keyboards & Vocals - Yes ProfessorGAC Jun 2023 #43
What and take Rick Wakeman's place with his robes?? you would do well, my friend debm55 Jun 2023 #48
Yeah, I'd Wear The Robes/Capes ProfessorGAC Jun 2023 #49
Allman Brothers Band, UFO, or Pink Floyd. Iggo Jun 2023 #51
very good choices,Iggo debm55 Jun 2023 #52
I just realized I could "happy medium" the whole thing... Iggo Jun 2023 #60
I'd have loved to be a guitar player in Frank Zappa's 1973 band. Elessar Zappa Jun 2023 #55
debm55............... Upthevibe Jun 2023 #56
Yep, love Stevie. Can't believe she is 75. debm55 Jun 2023 #57
 

Hugh_Lebowski

(33,643 posts)
5. Does this mean I'm also badass enough at singing/playing
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 02:20 PM
Jun 2023

That I wouldn't completely mess up the band by my presence, like I'm as good as the person I'm replacing?

If that's the case ... I pick Prince. With either the Revolution or the NPG

If I have to be at my own level of skill (or at least what it was in my prime) first pick would be to guest on vocals at a Pink Floyd show for a few songs. I used to be able to do really good impressions of both Waters and Gilmour.

EDIT: I was also told by a few DU'ers that I do a pretty mean Steve Earle impression when I posted my cover of Copperhead Road, so ... getting up and singing a song or two of his with him and The Dukes would also be pretty freaking killer.

debm55

(60,612 posts)
6. LOL , no it simply means you be be as good as the person you are replacing. You wouldn't mess up
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 02:25 PM
Jun 2023

group.

 

Hugh_Lebowski

(33,643 posts)
16. Well thanks, m'lady ...
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 03:24 PM
Jun 2023

I figure I come off a bit self-centered most of the time so ... I thought I'd leave that one be and if someone ASKED ... well ... you know, okay

debm55

(60,612 posts)
19. Hugh, that's very good. You are very talented. Why didn't you go into the music field professionally
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 03:55 PM
Jun 2023
Thanks

highplainsdem

(62,143 posts)
9. Pretenders, if I could sing like Chrissie Hynde:
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 02:41 PM
Jun 2023



Not that many women fronting rock bands.


Oh, and I'd probably have enjoyed playing rhythm guitar with Golden Earring in the mid-'70s, just to watch a group of very fine musicians who were also very watchable.

 

Hugh_Lebowski

(33,643 posts)
17. Chrissie is a Goddess and back then there definitely were not many ...
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 03:36 PM
Jun 2023

Nowadays I'm into all kinds of female artists, both solo and fronting bands.

Ladies have been killing it the past 10 years or so if you're into the indie and/or americana scene.

highplainsdem

(62,143 posts)
22. I've heard some of them, but I haven't heard any I thought were
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 04:54 PM
Jun 2023

better than Chrissie.

And she still sounds amazing...



debm55

(60,612 posts)
28. Wouldn't that be wonderful for be in the Pretenders and Golden Earring? What a great choice of .
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 05:08 PM
Jun 2023

groups.

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
12. Pedal steel guitar for Creedence Clearwater Revival, Baby!
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 02:46 PM
Jun 2023

Creedence Clearwater Revival was so successful without it, but I guarantee the pedal steel guitar would have filled in and added texture to a lot of their material.

Curiously, John Fogerty started playing the pedal steel guitar on some of his later recordings (I like to think John listened to a lot of 'Bakersfield Sound' on his AM radio late at night, and was mesmerized by Ralph Mooney's magical pedal steel guitar)

debm55

(60,612 posts)
23. I like the pedal steel guitar. I think you would have been great playing it on their earlier songs.
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 04:56 PM
Jun 2023

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
27. Perhaps I should go with a simple lap steel guitar
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 05:05 PM
Jun 2023

I can't walk and chew gum at the same time.

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
32. Marty Stuart has it now
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 06:12 PM
Jun 2023

Last edited Sun Jun 4, 2023, 01:34 PM - Edit history (1)

It's been a long learning curve, and he's starting to get the hang of it, but he's never gonna be a Clarence White.

Couriously, I was just watching filmmaker/documentarian extraordinaire, David Hoffman's 1971 film on Earl Scruggs trying to reinvent himself. One segment had Earl Scruggs playing with the Byrds, and there he was, Clarence White playing the fabled Parsons/White B-Bender.






ProfessorGAC

(76,703 posts)
44. B Benders Are Hard To Use
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 09:41 PM
Jun 2023

Got one chance to play a Telecaster with that mod in a music store in Northridge CA, about 20 years ago.
The tension you have to add without affecting the softness of the forearms is not an easy task.
Get too much tension in the forearms and it affects accuracy at speed.
It's a skill unto itself.

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
50. Clarence White sure had the skill set, and then some
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 10:20 PM
Jun 2023

His death closed the door, but I want to believe he might have dived back into his flat-picking, and made a mark in the Blue Grass world.

In my perfect world, Clarence White would be listed on one of the Will the Circle Be Unbroken albums. Hell, Gene Parsons is even installing the B Benders inside acoustic guitars, so Clarence would be good to go

ProfessorGAC

(76,703 posts)
54. I'd Have To Hear That
Sat Jun 3, 2023, 06:43 AM
Jun 2023

I have a hard time believing that added mass of metal wouldn't change the sound of an acoustic guitar.
The Tele makes sense. Putting one on acoustic seems counterintuitive.

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
58. Listen. It's genuinely viable because the wizard, Gene Parson, made it work
Sat Jun 3, 2023, 02:07 PM
Jun 2023

Pared down to 8 oz





Here's Gene in his super double secret workshop up around Fort Bragg, Calif.

DFW

(60,186 posts)
18. Bass with either the Youngbloods or the Doors
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 03:36 PM
Jun 2023

I know Perry (Jesse) liked playing guitar as much (if not more so) than bass, and I always loved playing bass--and I loved their music. Earth Music is one of my favorite albums of all time.

I was also a huge Doors fan, and played the same musical set-up that Ray Manzarek played, when not playing a four string bass. I handled the left-hand bass leyboard through the bass amp, and played the organ parts with my right hand through another amp. We were known in Northern Virginia and DC as one of the few bands who, already in 1967, could play the long version of Light My Fire note for note.

Later on, when I was deeply into the 12 string guitar, I would have liked to have joined the Byrds, but by then, they had lost Crosby and had gone heavily toward country--something this Southern boy never really got into. If Leo Kottke had kept a long-term four or five piece band, I would have given anything to have been part of THAT.

Actually, my current project, The Freedom Toast, has received written requests asking when and where we can be seen live. Oh, man I would LOVE to do that, but getting us all together in one country, let alone the same city, at once would be a monumental logistics task. Considering the nature of our material, I think our biggest expense would be security! Once they listen to us, Republicans tend to get very hostile. Plus, these days, they're all armed, and we're not.

I almost never sing, though. Assault with a deadly weapon is still a criminal offense in most states.

debm55

(60,612 posts)
25. Had a Youngbloods song sung at my wedding, and the Doors--cried when Jim died. You should try and
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 05:01 PM
Jun 2023

get the band together--maybe in blue areas of the country. You may never get the chance again and you can't miss the opportunity to do it.

DFW

(60,186 posts)
36. WHICH country did you have in mind?
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 07:20 PM
Jun 2023

We don‘t even all live on the same continent!

Brother Buzz

(39,899 posts)
39. I always though it intresting the Doors didn't have a conventional bass player
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 08:10 PM
Jun 2023

But Manzarek's thing certainly did the job

I did not know about that Fender Rhodes Piano Bass for many decades. Like, fifty years!

DFW

(60,186 posts)
53. I played both
Sat Jun 3, 2023, 12:37 AM
Jun 2023

Not a Fender Rhodes, but it served the same purpose. But I also played a conventional electric bass guitar. Those were the days! We called ourselves The Clockwork Orange. Two years after we went our separate ways, the film came out. If we only could have waited…..

Mr.Bill

(24,906 posts)
35. I would like to have taken
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 07:06 PM
Jun 2023

Brian Jones' place in the Rolling Stones. I even have blonde hair.

debm55

(60,612 posts)
47. Wonderful and so you. i have come to love your appreciation of classical music and the opera.
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 09:46 PM
Jun 2023

Aristus

(72,187 posts)
42. Nobody will care.
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 09:36 PM
Jun 2023

But I would have loved to be in Chris de Burgh’s stage band.

I know all his songs. And getting to travel all over Europe and Canada playing to devoted four generations of fans would be an incredible kick. There probably wouldn’t be the backstage debauchery of, say, a Mötley Crüe tour.

But still: All of Europe and Canada…

ProfessorGAC

(76,703 posts)
49. Yeah, I'd Wear The Robes/Capes
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 09:52 PM
Jun 2023

Why not? Even prog rock is still part of the entertainment business!
I never dressed as a chemist on-stage. Well, I didn't dress like a chemist when I was in the lab either!

Iggo

(49,927 posts)
51. Allman Brothers Band, UFO, or Pink Floyd.
Fri Jun 2, 2023, 10:37 PM
Jun 2023

Alternatively, one of those bands with many singers, like Crosby Stills & Nash, or The Hollies.

Iggo

(49,927 posts)
60. I just realized I could "happy medium" the whole thing...
Sat Jun 3, 2023, 05:29 PM
Jun 2023

Last edited Sat Jun 3, 2023, 06:57 PM - Edit history (1)

…by being a member of The Eagles on the Hotel California tour.

Yep, I’m changing my answer to that….lol.

Upthevibe

(10,180 posts)
56. debm55...............
Sat Jun 3, 2023, 12:39 PM
Jun 2023

Stevie Nicks but without the cocaine problem....

&list=RDEMU07SP2WWHg5vIcUdFcWU1Q&index=11

For my 40th birthday a friend of mine took me to see them at The Hollywood Bowl. It was one of the thrills of my entire life.....
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What group would you have...