For those of you who buy mayonnaise

[Diamond_Dog]

Duke’s or Hellman’s?

[mobeau69]

1. Hellman's

[Duncanpup]

2. Both

[murielm99]

3. Hellman's.

For some people, this may depend on what part of the country they live in. Duke's may not be available everywhere.

[OLDMDDEM]

4. Dukes

[underpants]

5. My wife prefers Dukes

Mrs. Filberts is second I think that may be a regional thing.

[Autumn]

6. Duke's or nothing.

[claudette]

7. Hellmans

But the price has soared and now I buy Duke’s or other less expensive brands which have the same Ingredients

[mucifer]

8. I miss Just Mayo. But hellmans has a vegan mayo that's pretty good.

[MLAA]

25. Agree. But I also use veganaise. Still hoping for a vegan version of Miracle Whip.

Another recent find was vegan baby bel cheese rounds. Darn good!

[Phentex]

45. I think the veganaise has gotten better

like creamier than before but the taste isn't much of anything. Still, it works!

[Walleye]

9. Always been a Hellmann's fan but never tried Dukes. Grocery has it now, I'll give it a try

[Freddie]

30. Me too

Giant has started carrying Dukes so I have to try it.
Maybe my taste buds are not refined but I swear that Giant brand mayonnaise actually is Hellman’s, like many store brands are the “real thing” in a different package.

[Walleye]

33. Yes I think store brands the product is the same quality the packaging is just not quite as good

[El Supremo]

10. Best Food's

[soldierant]

42. Best Foods is Hellman's

west of the Rocjies. Same product, same manufacturer. That's been so as long as I can remember, and i'm 78.

[dameatball]

11. I am a longtime Hellman's guy who just bought Duke's on a Publix BOGO. Both are good.

Hellman's seems to offer more varieties, such as olive oil, light, etc. At least that is the case where I shop.

On the other hand, Mom raised us on Kraft Miracle Whip, so what do I know??

[LeftInTX]

55. LOL! MW is the spawn of satan!

[Glorfindel]

12. Hellman's. But Food Lion's store brand tastes just like it and costs much less.

[Maine Abu El Banat]

13. Veganaise

And I'm not even vegan!

[Ocelot II]

14. Both are fine. But never Miracle Whip.

[brush]

16. Absolutely. Words out of my mouth. Miracle Whip is gag-inducing.

[Diamond_Dog]

20. +++ agree about Miracle Whip, Ocelot

[Elessar Zappa]

40. I like the spices they use with miracle whip.

My main complaint with it is that it’s a tad too sweet.

[CrispyQ]

15. Vegenaise with the purple lid, but I can't find it anymore,

& the blue lid is just okay & the green lid sucks, so Hellman's. Never heard of Duke's. Best Foods is the other main brand here.

[soldierant]

44. You must be not too far from me.

I'm in the past of the countr where one can see both Best Foods and Hellman's West of us it's all Best Foods, east of us Hellman's. Same prudoct, same maker.

[CrispyQ]

47. Lol, they are the same!

I didn't know that. I think we also have Kraft. Colorado front range, here.

[soldierant]

59. Yup! CO Front Range here too.

And I think Kraft is a different recipe (unless it was bought up while I wasn't looking.)

[Native]

61. That's the Grapeseed Oil version. That's my favorite too!

[wnylib]

17. Never heard of Duke's.

I grew up on Miracle Whip. Used to buy Smart Balance mayo but sometimes it is hard to find in local grocery stores, so one time when I couldn't get it, I tried Hellman's olive oil mayo. Now it's the only one that I buy.

[sinkingfeeling]

18. Duke's.

[MiHale]

19. DUKE'S...it's in the "oath of life" ...

Only Duke’s.

[Polly Hennessey]

21. Hellman's is Best Foods out west. For us, it's Best Foods.

I have tried others and “no thank you”. Although Krafts is not bad.

[C_U_L8R]

22. We were liking Sir Kensington's.

But the quality has been slipping since they got bought out.
Curious to try Dukes.

[getagrip_already]

23. What's a dukes?

Seriously, never heard of it. Is it a regional thing?

[jimfields33]

24. I only buy miracle whip. I love it even if I'm the only one on earth.

[yonder]

27. Make that two. Or more.

Mayonnaise is as weird to me as Miracle Whip must be for them.

[debm55]

31. I only use Miracle Whip in tuna and egg salad

[yellowdogintexas]

43. my mother was Team Miracle Whip - she really hated mayo

I do not like Miracle Whip at all

[unc70]

26. Dukes and only Dukes

Will be having a tomato sandwich with Dukes for lunch. I find Hellmans to be too sweet. Miracle Whip is not even mayonnaise. (It has less vegetable oil than is legally required to be called Mayo, and it has added sugar.)

[brewens]

28. I've thought about looking into making my own. I would imagine it wouldn't keep

long, but if it's not hard, I would make really small batches.

[jmowreader]

48. If you have a stand mixer, it's not that bad

You will need:

1 pasteurized egg at room temperature
1 tablespoon lemon juice
1/2 teaspoon salt
1 cup light-flavored oil

Install your Whisk beater.

Step 1 is to put the egg, salt and lemon juice in the mixer. You MUST use the lemon juice as it stabilizes the emulsion.

Step 2 is to set the mixer to low and beat until the ingredients are thoroughly mixed.

Step 3 is most crucial: add the oil drop by drop until half of it's in, beating it in thoroughly after every drop. At halfway through add it in a very slow stream. Adding the oil too fast is a sure way of getting a mess rather than mayonnaise.

If you want to add pepper, mustard or whatever, do that in Step 1.

[SamKnause]

29. Hellmann's.

[Floyd R. Turbo]

32. Kroger olive oil mayo.

[debm55]

34. So you don't like the whip?

[Floyd R. Turbo]

39. Kinky! 😁

[Xoan]

35. Neither.

[Iggo]

36. Best Foods. (Hellman's, but West of The Rockies.)

[Hekate]

37. Best Foods. Just a tang of lemon.

The label has a footnote: “Known as Hellman’s East of the Rockies”

[beaglelover]

38. Hellmans or as its known out here Best Foods

[yellowdogintexas]

41. Hellman's I have never tried Duke's though nt

[Emile]

49. Which ever one is cheaper.

[Aristus]

50. Hellman's.

It has a nice vinegary tang to it.

If your mayonnaise is bland, you have the wrong mayonnaise.

[Rhiannon12866]

51. Hellman's

The only other choice here is the store brand. I've never heard of Duke's.

[LudwigPastorius]

52. Hellman's

[Solly Mack]

53. Hellmans.

Sometimes I make my own.

[Trueblue1968]

54. live on west coast ...... BEST FOODS !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[ailsagirl]

57. Same here--Best Foods!! 👍

[ailsagirl]

56. Best Foods (we don't have Hellman's here)

[jcgoldie]

58. Burmans

Thats cheap aldi brand its all the same to me. Homegrown tomatoes are essential for a BLT, type of mayo matters none.

[Nac Mac Feegle]

60. Kewpie

Uses whole eggs, so it tastes better.

You just have to find an Asian grocery store.

[flying_wahini]

62. Dukes has the edge here.

[Wolf Frankula]

63. Winco Store Brand

Maybe once every three months.

Wolf

[chrisjourney9876]

64. interesting

interesting

[MistakenLamb]

65. Dukes ftw

though i’m working through some vegan hellmans i got on the cheap right now