Cool whip, vanilla ice cream, or nothing on your pumpkin pie??

[a kennedy]

I forgot to buy cool whip for ours, so…..gonna be naked pumpkin pie for us.

[debm55]

1. Reddi -Whip

[a kennedy]

3. Right, forgot that......yummmm

[Mad_Dem_X]

10. Oh yeah!

We have two cans ready to go. My husband and I both love the stuff.

[debm55]

12. When you were a kid, did you take the stuff and squeeze it in your mouth???

[yellowdogintexas]

51. of course. still do, actually. nt

[Iggo]

2. Nada.

Cup of coffee on the side maybe, but that’s it.

Three cuts and fire for effect. Let’s do it!

[littlemissmartypants]

4. Sweet potato pie for me. ❤️

[a kennedy]

6. Ok, so what's the topping on your sweet potato pie?? Or naked??

[littlemissmartypants]

8. I'll try anything once. I've never thought about it until now. ❤️

[littlemissmartypants]

42. How do you think Vanilla ice cream with whipped cream drizzled with caramel would be?

Too much?

[a kennedy]

43. Damn, that absolutely sounds like the most delicious thing EVER!!!!!

[littlemissmartypants]

44. Thanks, a kennedy. Sorry it took me so long. ❤️

[leftieNanner]

5. Either vanilla ice cream

Or whipped cream with bourbon in it!

[a kennedy]

7. Yummmmm bourbon in whipped cream, sounds delish

[leftieNanner]

9. It is!

And I sometimes make the whipped cream with a little bit of gelatin so it keeps in the fridge for a few days without separating.

[niyad]

56. brandy works, too. as does rum.

[Polly Hennessey]

11. Pumpkin pie, naked or otherwise.

Love the pie and any add ons.

[a kennedy]

14. 👍🏻 Happy Thanksgiving......

[KarenS]

13. I don't like your choices,,,,

Whipped cream, for me

[a kennedy]

15. Hmmmmmmmm yup, should added that to the list.....

Does sound good.

[WmChris]

16. Any one of the 3

Favorite Whipped topping, however, is homemade; heavy cream, a little vanilla, a little sugar, and a good old-fashioned hand cranked egg beater. Whipped until thick enough to hold peaks when you lift the beater. MMMM

[a kennedy]

18. Oh, that sounds delish......yummmmmm

[Elessar Zappa]

17. Reddi whip!

[a kennedy]

19. Yup, others believe that as well.......

[thatcrowwoman]

20. Vanilla ice cream, but no pumpkin pie, thanks. 🍨

Rumor around here has it there may be blueberry pie tomorrow.
Excellent accompaniment for vanilla ice cream.
🕊thatcrowwoman

[a kennedy]

21. What no pumpkin pie??? and just boring vanilla ice cream 😀

Now, blueberry pie with vanilla ice cream……delish.

[sinkingfeeling]

22. I'll take the Cool Whip and ice cream; you can keep the pumpkin pie.

[a kennedy]

27. 🤣 😂 🤣

[Sogo]

23. Real, freshly made whipped cream....

Throw out that Cool Whip!

[a kennedy]

29. Yah, cool whip is just a cheap imitation of real whipped cream people say.....

[Sogo]

47. That's for sure.

It's non-dairy, meaning it's whipped veg oils.

Coop Whip Ingredients: Water, hydrogenated vegetable oil (including coconut and palm oils), high fructose corn syrup, corn syrup, skimmed milk, light cream, less than 2% sodium caseinate (a milk derivative), natural and artificial flavor, xanthan and guar gums, polysorbate 60, sorbitan monostearate, and beta carotene.

Appetizing, no???

[NewHendoLib]

25. I made a pie with Candy Roaster squash - best I've ever had.

Dash of molasses, lots of spices. Candy Roaster is an heirloom squash from the Cherokee Nation area of Georgia and NC - got it at a Farmers Market.

ALWAYS fresh whipped cream on pumpkin pie. Now for Pecan Pie, that's vanilla ice cream!

[a kennedy]

26. Yummmmmm, that squash sounds delicious.....

I’m not a pecan pie gal……sorry.

[Niagara]

28. I just want the pumpkin pie.

One year I stated that I was ready to enjoy some pumpkin pie. An in-law replied, "Alright, let me make some whipped cream real quick."

I patiently waited for her to make the unnecessary whipped cream and when she finished, she placed a dollop of whipped cream right on top of my pumpkin pie and handed it to me.

I scraped the junk off my piece of pie and dug into it with my fork. She looked horrified that I scraped the dollop of whipped cream off my pie.

"You don't like whipped cream?" she asked me.

"No. The stuff grosses me out. I don't like meringue either." I replied.


No one has ever offered vanilla ice cream on top of pumpkin pie however. That actually sounds delicious.

[a kennedy]

30. Oh my, you scraped it off right in front of her??? Wow......

and ya, give the ice cream a try…….let me know whatcha think.

[Niagara]

31. I wasn't attempting to be rude to the in-law.

She has always attempted to tell me what to eat since I've known her... she has control issues.


One year she looked at my plate and noticed that I didn't have gravy on my turkey and let me know that there was gravy right next to the turkey. I explained to her that I don't like the taste of gravy.


Another year she tried to tell me that I should put some of this or that on my plate and I calmly said, " I'm 4something years old, I can choose for myself what to put on my own plate."

Her own son knows she has control issues.


Yes, I'm going to try that for Christmas, thank you for the suggestion.

[a kennedy]

34. Ok, gotcha on her previous and on-going controlling issues, I completely understand.

[Niagara]

40. ...

They're also MAGA if that explains anything.

[a kennedy]

41. Yup......and ugh.

[Tree-Hugger]

32. Nothing

I hate pie. All pie.

I make pies for the rest of my household, though. I make homemade whipped cream for my pies.

[a kennedy]

35. So nice and considerate of you to make pies even tho you hate pies.

Hope there was love put into each one.

[Tree-Hugger]

48. I love making them

They are definitely filled with love. My family enjoys them, so I do like to bake them. I just wish my taste buds would enjoy pie. They always look and smell so good.

[CrispyQ]

53. Quiche? Pizza pie? Pi?

Years ago we went to a pizza joint with pi in the name. Great pizza.

[Tree-Hugger]

60. Pizza, sometimes

I'm allergic to math, so no pi for me.

I do love chicken pot pie.

[The Roux Comes First]

33. Actually It Was Apple This Year

And terrific with a little vanilla ice cream and a slice of cheddar.

[a kennedy]

36. Yup.....a slice of sharp cheddar cheese was ALWAYS eaten with apple pie.

My dad was the first person I ever saw have sharp, had to be sharp cheddar cheese, with apple pie.

[yellowdogintexas]

50. that is a good combination all right. I have a recipe which uses

shredded cheddar cheese in the pie crust.

[LisaM]

59. Apple pie without the cheese...

Is like a kiss without a squeeze!

We always quoted that and we always have slices of super sharp cheddar cheese (white cheddar if possible) with our apple pie.

[Floyd R. Turbo]

37. Either/or! 😋

[a kennedy]

38. Good answer.....😀

[Floyd R. Turbo]

39. 😁

[malthaussen]

45. Cool Whip is a petroleum byproduct.

I'll take whipped cream.

-- Mal

[a kennedy]

46. No way.....really?? Wow, I did not know that

no more cool whip for us.

[yellowdogintexas]

49. Real whipped cream, either Reddi-Whip or beaten in a bowl.

Nothing else will do.

[doc03]

52. Pumpkin Ice Cream nt

[multigraincracker]

54. Bought some Cool Whip this year.

First time in years, but I had a recipe for no bake pumpkin pie. My oven has been broken for years.
Turned out great. Made 2 pies from I can of pumpkin 3 packs of instant vanilla pudding, 6 oz of Cool Wip and the usual spices. Then I top it with real whip cream. I know it was real because they used real whips.
2 pies were gone in two days with only 3 of us.
Google “no bake pumpkin pie”.

[niyad]

55. Whipped cream with chocolate sauce. Cool whip is not

actual food.

[Bayard]

57. I just finished the last piece

With Cool-Whip wannabe.

[bullimiami]

58. Both.