The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsKaradeniz
(24,746 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)Climate Crusader
(163 posts)Same.
Midnight Writer
(25,397 posts)SarahD
(1,732 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)JoseBalow
(9,467 posts)electric_blue68
(26,856 posts)quaint
(5,068 posts)SarahD
(1,732 posts)Several of the songs involve questions.
FirstLight
(15,771 posts)I thought of Culture Club, "do you really want to hurt me?"
And Eurhythmics, "who's that girl?"
Steve C
(27 posts)How about a band with a question and song thats a statement? 96 tears by question mark and the mysterians .
red dog 1
(33,059 posts)consider_this
(2,847 posts)and...
hlthe2b
(113,900 posts)Cartoonist
(7,579 posts)hlthe2b
(113,900 posts)JoseBalow
(9,467 posts)(2:23)
and a favorite BONUS question...
(6:11)
Mad_Dem_X
(10,192 posts)all the time!
JoseBalow
(9,467 posts)OldBaldy1701E
(11,114 posts)hlthe2b
(113,900 posts)I still miss Marvin... sigh
Niagara
(11,828 posts)ificandream
(11,836 posts)&pp=ygUfRG8gWW91IExvdmUgTWU_IGRhdmUgY2xhcmsgZml2ZQ%3D%3D
ificandream
(11,836 posts)ProfessorGAC
(76,673 posts)Especially since I actually perform a solo 12 string acoustic version of it.
Arne
(3,609 posts)ificandream
(11,836 posts)sl8
(17,109 posts)Keith Sousa
2023 Mar 29
"What Have They Done to My Song Ma" is a song written and performed by Melanie Safka. It was co-written by HM Saffer II, a notable American painter and musician who worked for Warner Brothers Productions.
It was released in 1970 as the B-side of Melanie's "Ruby Tuesday" single and included on the album Candles in the Rain. The single reached the number 39 in the United Kingdom and peaked within the top 20 in Norway and the Wallonia region of Belgium.
Other artists have recorded it as "Look What They've Done to My Song Ma", after the song's first line, and this title is used on the music page at Melanie's website.
[...]
ificandream
(11,836 posts)I have a pleasure of interviewing her and she was the sweetest interview I think I ever had. She was just a wonderful person.
sl8
(17,109 posts)It's great that you had that experience.
When I saw the question, that song instantly popped into my head, and in the next instant I realized that the title wasn't a question, because I "knew" the title was "Look What They've Done to My Song Ma".
Well one thing led to another and I decide to to read up on the song, out of pure curiousity, then, lo and behold, Wikipedia says that the original song title was "What Have They Done to My Song Ma", which happens to be a bonfide question. Well, who am I to disagree with Wikipedia when it says what I'd like it to say? And, hot dog, now I can post this song in red dog 1's thread, with a clear conscience!
Tikki
(15,138 posts)Tikki
surrealAmerican
(11,873 posts)Who'll be the next in line?
Shermann
(9,059 posts)TexasDem69
(2,317 posts)perfessor
(378 posts)Derek and the Dominoes.
Tikki
(15,138 posts)Everybody ...up.
Tikki
2naSalit
(102,714 posts)It's one of my favorites because I love Michael McDonald's voice and it's a cool jam.
Raven123
(7,788 posts)IA8IT
(6,421 posts)happybird
(5,393 posts)ms liberty
(11,229 posts)Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is? https://g.co/kgs/68k9KRa
ms liberty
(11,229 posts)Questions https://g.co/kgs/ZGNbcHT
Sneederbunk
(17,481 posts)Tikki
(15,138 posts)Marvelous..
Tikki
Walleye
(44,760 posts)Both written by John Sebastian
My relative who is going to be wed loves this song(as do I), having first heard it in a wonderful film by Jim Sheridan, In America. I was familiar with it years before he was born and liked it a lot. I told him about a song I loved from back in the day by the late Sandy Denny titled Who Knows Where the Time Goes . He commented that there sure isnt songs like these being composed these days.
red dog 1
(33,059 posts)mactire
(130 posts)I have a relative that has suggested this song for his wedding to the love of his life-How Long Will I Love You? by the Waterboys, who are known for Fishermans Blues and other nice songs. He also wants In Your Eyes by Peter Gabriel, which makes a statement rather than ask a question . Lucky young lady to be with a man like this, obviously not a right winger!
Harker
(17,774 posts)Sugar and spice is just a bluff
You can tell me, baby - what is that stuff?
Brother Buzz
(39,886 posts)Upthevibe
(10,173 posts)The great Peggy Lee....
wnylib
(25,956 posts)Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers - Why do Fools Fall in Love?
RazorbackExpat
(938 posts)When this song came out, I had been studying about Central America and thought she meant San Jose, Costa Rica
ificandream
(11,836 posts)I got sick of hearing it.
RazorbackExpat
(938 posts)in San Jose, Costa Rica?
Mad_Dem_X
(10,192 posts)Niagara
(11,828 posts)Doc_Technical
(3,762 posts)AZSkiffyGeek
(12,744 posts)And Johnny Marr is still cool AFAIK...
Coventina
(29,715 posts)I was at a teen club (I don't know if such things still exist) in Phoenix.
When it came on, it was like nothing I'd ever heard before (despite being familiar with the Smiths already) and the hairs stood up all over my body.
I ran out and bought "Meat is Murder" the next day. (The only way of getting it here in Phoenix at the time).
Doc_Technical
(3,762 posts)malthaussen
(18,564 posts)Alpeduez21
(2,050 posts)thucythucy
(9,097 posts)The Beatles
Climate Crusader
(163 posts)Absolutely Mutton!!! Say it again.......
AZSkiffyGeek
(12,744 posts)AZSkiffyGeek
(12,744 posts)livetohike
(24,272 posts)JoseBalow
(9,467 posts)(1:03)
applegrove
(132,149 posts)Different Drummer
(9,083 posts)Niagara
(11,828 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)Last edited Sun Jun 16, 2024, 02:44 PM - Edit history (1)
(I love The Doors and once saw them at the old Fillmore Auditorium)
Niagara
(11,828 posts)I never had a chance to see The Doors.
I love Jim's baritone voice. He could reach E2,B2, D5,Bb5, F6 notes that's practically impossible for most male baritones. I have ran across people who claim that Jim couldn't sing, these people absolutely have no clue what they're talking about.
I'm positive that I forgot to mention all the notes that Jim could reach, I'm just throwing a few notes out there.
Tikki
(15,138 posts)Tikki
Niagara
(11,828 posts)Originally released on the Kill 'Em All album and got moved to Garage Inc. album. Super annoying when a person has to replace an album.
Niagara
(11,828 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)kimbutgar
(27,241 posts)I had a terrible first marriage and when things got bad instead of fighting back i thought of this song in my mind.
happybird
(5,393 posts)Love this version from the Beacon Jams during quarantine. Its so relaxing and never fails to lift my spirits.
When I saw the band a couple summers ago, this song was one of the highlights for me. Since I had been out of the loop for so long that was my first time hearing it, a more rocking version with no string section, and then found the Beacon version while looking it up on YouTube.
With the band:
Has a kinda Black Sabbath-y feel to it.
red dog 1
(33,059 posts)IcyPeas
(25,471 posts)IcyPeas
(25,471 posts)IcyPeas
(25,471 posts)Jrose
(1,532 posts)and...
Where Have all the Flowers Gone? Pete Seeger
red dog 1
(33,059 posts)but couldn't find any actually showing them performing the song.
CTyankee
(68,179 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)Alpeduez21
(2,050 posts)Dulcinea
(10,075 posts)malthaussen
(18,564 posts)John has to make up his mind between the Mona Lisa Twins. The really funny part is that their father who admonishes him is probably younger than John.
-- Mal
red dog 1
(33,059 posts)sakabatou
(46,134 posts)Coventina
(29,715 posts)Coventina
(29,715 posts)Coventina
(29,715 posts)Coventina
(29,715 posts)This song makes me think of Trump:
Coventina
(29,715 posts)Was this not listed previously?
if..fish..had..wings
(880 posts)nocoincidences
(2,489 posts)JoseBalow
(9,467 posts)(7:07)
TlalocW
(15,674 posts)On His Television Show?
I hope it's a long way off still, but I'm compiling songs to be played at my funeral. This will be the only "religious" one.
surrealAmerican
(11,873 posts)doc03
(39,078 posts)What's New Pussycat?
thucythucy
(9,097 posts)red dog 1
(33,059 posts)Niagara
(11,828 posts)Tikki
(15,138 posts)?si=OqKNSoXmL9uVpmoX
Tikki
electric_blue68
(26,856 posts)DUUUUH 😄
I forgot how to embed vids
Ah I see it was there early on
BrazenlyLiberal
(7 posts)"...If you believe in magic don't bother to choose
If it's jug band music or rhythm and blues
Just go and listen it'll start with a smile
It won't wipe off your face no matter how hard you try
Your feet start tapping and you can't seem to find
How you got there, so just blow your mind..."
Tikki
(15,138 posts)..the tubeway army.
Tikki