Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The Polack MSgt

(13,797 posts)
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 11:19 PM Dec 2023

All else being equal, I will always prefer a woman's voice. That's not to say that all dudes suck-

just that I prefer a female vocalist...

Like Sarah Jarosz

?si=byyeGVz6OoR6LLFa

Ok, Nina Simone is a legend, so it may not be a fair comparison with her on one side of the equation
?si=DB3yUF7sDcyyd1X8

OF COURSE, ARETHA
?si=4XCtEpjs3osTi04i

Patsy as well, OBVIOUSLY
?si=7JM9nAbI8mm72y4r
17 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
All else being equal, I will always prefer a woman's voice. That's not to say that all dudes suck- (Original Post) The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 OP
Love me some Patsy Cline duckworth969 Dec 2023 #1
Agree My Friend BOSSHOG Dec 2023 #2
I'm an opera fan, and I much prefer the female opera stars. Jeebo Dec 2023 #3
bit of a sucker myself. fallen in love - WAY too many times ... stopdiggin Dec 2023 #4
I am a huge fan of her as well. The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #5
and a bit of a story there too stopdiggin Dec 2023 #7
Same here.. Permanut Dec 2023 #6
No reason to apologize for any of those women being on your list. All of them wail The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #8
Excellent choices.. Permanut Dec 2023 #9
Happy Birthday! The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #11
... Permanut Dec 2023 #14
I generally prefer female voices also. FuzzyRabbit Dec 2023 #10
Thank You for these songs! The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #12
We're very different. I prefer male vocalists. highplainsdem Dec 2023 #13
Not sure how much attraction played a part in setting my musical preferences - Although it has to be part of it The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #15
I think I went immediately from liking the Beatles to loving blues rock. :) highplainsdem Dec 2023 #17
This message was self-deleted by its author The Polack MSgt Dec 2023 #15

BOSSHOG

(44,738 posts)
2. Agree My Friend
Fri Dec 8, 2023, 11:34 PM
Dec 2023

Linda Ronstadt, Bonnie Raitt, Reba Mcentire, Dolly Parton, Tina Turner, Barbara Streisand, Bobby Gentry. All prove your point.

Jeebo

(2,560 posts)
3. I'm an opera fan, and I much prefer the female opera stars.
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 12:17 AM
Dec 2023

Carmen, La Traviata, Tosca, Aida, Madame Butterfly, Turandot, Die Valkyrie ... I could go on and on.

But if it's not opera, I'll vote for Linda Ronstadt, Karen Carpenter and Patsy Cline. I'm not a country and western fan at all, but Patsy Cline did have an incredible voice. And Linda Ronstadt could sing anything, she was so versatile. She actually did sing a little opera, in fact.

So I'm with you about the preferred gender, if not about the preferred style of music.

Watch this, one of my favorite flash mob performances. Think Elmer Fudd singing "Kill the Wabbit" except these women sound a lot better than Elmer Fudd does. Wow, I wish I had been there!

&t=6s

-- Ron

stopdiggin

(15,463 posts)
4. bit of a sucker myself. fallen in love - WAY too many times ...
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 12:33 AM
Dec 2023

Linda Ronstadt, Allison Krauss, k.d.lang

and here's an 'interesting' voice, that maybe everyone hasn't heard already ...

The Polack MSgt

(13,797 posts)
5. I am a huge fan of her as well.
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 12:45 AM
Dec 2023

Evert since Gems on VHS featured her doing Rosemary.

?si=7TwVbqQwlaZNC2gn

stopdiggin

(15,463 posts)
7. and a bit of a story there too
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 01:04 AM
Dec 2023

from busking street corners until relatively recent - to debuting the Grand Ole Opry just about a year ago. Quite the ride.

The Polack MSgt

(13,797 posts)
8. No reason to apologize for any of those women being on your list. All of them wail
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 01:12 AM
Dec 2023

Here's a couple more to consider:
Gloria Hardiman

?si=58HQv7_EOGNddfx8

?si=MAlMOvNeHZMUn-TQ

Daniele Nicole Schnebelen

?si=dpJf5W9J672573ac

Permanut

(8,391 posts)
9. Excellent choices..
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 01:22 AM
Dec 2023

Let's add Chic and Diana Ross.

Just a side note from another of your posts - I share a birthday with your wife. Gloating a little bit, I had a wonderful dinner with my wife.

FuzzyRabbit

(2,217 posts)
10. I generally prefer female voices also.
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 01:31 AM
Dec 2023

Jennifer Rush - The Power of Love

&list=FLGok_IXLPAu-B9mGbaUJrVQ&index=2

Jackie Evancho - Nessun Dorma
&list=FLGok_IXLPAu-B9mGbaUJrVQ&index=5

Judith Durham of The Seekers - The Carnival Is Over (1965)


The Seekers -The First Australian (2014)

highplainsdem

(62,143 posts)
13. We're very different. I prefer male vocalists.
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 02:25 AM
Dec 2023

There are a lot of great female vocalists out there and I do appreciate them.

But in terms of very favorite vocalists, records I'll buy, etc., I'd rather listen to men.

I don't know how much this sort of preference has to do with gender, since I don't know the gender of everyone posting here.

And as a straight female who once had a crush on Paul McCartney, I'm aware how that can factor in.

But it didn't factor into my thinking Eric Burdon was incredible in the Animals, for instance, when I was playing their music so much my parents were really sick of it.

I just prefer to listen to male singers. And have for as long as I can recall.

The Polack MSgt

(13,797 posts)
15. Not sure how much attraction played a part in setting my musical preferences - Although it has to be part of it
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 10:35 AM
Dec 2023

I assume.

It's not that I avoid male vocalists, if that were even possible, but out of my top 10 favorite vocal artists Rob Halford and Van Morrison are the only dudes to make the cut.

Also, Eric Burden was a monster vocalist for sure, I may have sold him short...

highplainsdem

(62,143 posts)
17. I think I went immediately from liking the Beatles to loving blues rock. :)
Sat Dec 9, 2023, 12:05 PM
Dec 2023

From "Aren't those moptops cute and isn't that a sweet little pop-rock song?" to "WOW! What was THAT?"

Btw, Eric Burdon isn't one of my all-time-fave rock vocalists, though he was definitely an early fave, like Steve Winwood.

My favorites are Paul Rodgers and Robert Plant, for rock. If we're talking about soul - Otis Redding (who I think was Paul Rodgers' idol).

I had never given much thought to how much I preferred male vocalists till people were listing favorite singers in the Lounge a while back and I looked at my list compared to others and thought, Hmmm. No women listed. Can't remember if I decided to add some.

And I love Chrissie Hynde. I love Tina Turner. And Susan Tedeschi, and Beth Hart, and other powerful women singers. Aretha, for soul.

I really admire female vocalists like Joni Mitchell, for instance, but I couldn't call myself a fan. Same for many other great female singers that I often see mentioned here. So while I'm happy to listen to occasional songs I hear by them, I don't listen to full albums.

As a feminist, I'm glad there are a lot of female singers doing well on the charts now - good for them - but I don't listen to them all that often.

I definitely don't like all male vocalists. Have never been a Rush fan, for instance, because of the vocals.

And there are a lot of great male vocalists like Bowie where I love some of the songs but don't listen to others at all because I simply don't think they sounded very good on those tracks.

Response to highplainsdem (Reply #13)

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Music Appreciation»All else being equal, I w...