Bill would prevent transgender females from competing in girls, women sports

[keopeli]

Bill would prevent transgender females from competing in girls, women sports

SANTA FE, N.M. (KRQE) – Some New Mexico Republican lawmakers are pushing a bill to level the playing field for female athletes competing with transgender athletes born as males. One of the sponsors of the controversial bill says this legislation all comes down to safety.

“To allow men or boys compete against women is fundamentally unfair and it’s dangerous and it takes away lots of opportunities for these girls; scholarships. You compete to win because winning is good for you psychologically, it encourages you to do other things and to excel in other things in your life. So when you take that opportunity away from girls it’s devastating,” said Representative Zachary Cook (R-Ruidoso).

House Bill 304 is called the Women’s Sports Protection Act and would prevent female athletes from competing with transgender athletes born as males. The bill state that there are only two biological sexes and that biological sex is determined at fertilization or at birth. It goes on to say that men have higher natural levels of testosterone which results in higher speed and power during physical activity, which leads to a performance gap between males and females.

Right now, under the New Mexico Activities Association bylaws, a student must compete in the gender officially listed on their birth certificate. In New Mexico, you are now allowed to amend your sex on your birth certificate. If passed, this would apply to not only middle and high schools, but universities in New Mexico. Opponents say the bill could increase any stress transgender people already deal with which include sexual abuse, bullying, and suicide.


[link:https://www.krqe.com/news/politics-government/legislature/bill-would-prevent-transgender-athletes-born-as-males-from-competing-with-females/?utm_medium=referral&utm_source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=socialflow&fbclid=IwAR0ijLF2dO8GtL7rp0OPTjxNIrkmTljLJ00BDN77-T0BpAn6DEJDAZH6R1c|

[TexasTowelie]

1. I think that ALEC has to be behind this legislation.

There are too many states with similar legislation being proposed (and regrettably, passed) to be a coincidence.

[rainy]

2. This is the only part I don't get

How can a male compete in female sports period? It’s not about how you identify because in sports only two identities exist: those with vaginas and those with penises. That’s it. Wouldn’t we have to eliminate women’s sports altogether if men could compete as women?

The only exception is if the person has completed a medical change and has altered hormones.

[rampartc]

4. there is a lot of nuance on this issue

how many of these kids are there? hundreds? thousands? fewer?

maybe the only "fair" answer is to divide sports into " boys" "girls" and "trans?" maybe it should be a case by case?

the best girls will beat many boys but i might think that most trans girls would have an advantage over most biological girls.

at any rate, i don't think the legislature is the place to decide. there are like ncaa and state level sports assns that need to have a serious discussion without the legislative grand standing.

well, i guess i've said enough to get a bashing.

[XanaDUer2]

3. Interesting nt