Independence Is the Progressive Solution to US Colonialism in Puerto Rico

[Judi Lynn]

BY
Margaret Power, Truthout
PUBLISHED
January 23, 2021

In his August 2020 eulogy to John Lewis, Barack Obama characterized Puerto Rico and Washington, D.C.’s lack of political representation on the federal level as a civil rights issue. The Democratic Party and some progressives have since called for statehood for Washington and Puerto Rico.

José López is the executive director of the Puerto Rican Cultural Center in Chicago. A long-time supporter of Puerto Rican independence, he also worked to secure the release of successive generations of Puerto Rican political prisoners, including his brother, Oscar López Rivera. In this interview, López refutes the idea that the 2020 plebiscite indicates majority support for statehood and explains why the solution to U.S. colonialism in Puerto Rico is independence. He also argues Puerto Rico’s status is a human rights — not a civil rights — issue.

José López: There were some very interesting outcomes to the 2020 general local territorial elections on the island. But first, some background.

Local elections have been held in Puerto Rico since 1900, when the Foraker Act established a civilian government following the United States’ 1898 invasion of the archipelago. Since that time Puerto Rico has elected a resident commissioner to represent Puerto Rico in the U.S. Congress. However, the commissioner lacks voting rights. Although Puerto Ricans became U.S. citizens in 1917, they, too, lack voting rights as long as they live in Puerto Rico. They cannot vote for president, senator or congressman. If they move to the United States, they can vote in federal elections. In the November 2020 election, Puerto Ricans cast their ballot for local and municipal officials, in addition to a non-binding referendum on statehood (yes or no).

More:
https://truthout.org/articles/independence-is-the-progressive-solution-to-us-colonialism-in-puerto-rico/

[TexasTowelie]

1. While there are issues of civil rights for citizens of Puerto Rico,

I doubt that independence issue would be successful for Puerto Rico. The territory carried $74 billion in bonded debt and $49 billion in pension liability debt as of 2018. The sales tax rate is at 11%. All payments for Social Security and food stamps would end. The economy of Puerto Rico would resemble that of Haiti without the flow of U.S. dollars into the island.

If another binding referendum was held, I believe that the people of Puerto Rico would give priority to the economic issues over the civil rights issues since the civil rights issues would be addressed with statehood. It should be noted that the article from Truthout barely addressed the economic issues other than José López expects reparations from the United States for their time under colonialism. That idea has no traction among most Americans.

[msongs]

2. will independent puerto ricans renounce their us citizenship then nt