Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumBjorn Lomborg (Apparently Still Alive) Has A New Book, Which Shouts "Fake News' A Lot
Ed. - Joseph Stiglitz applying the hammer here.
The thesis of Bjorn Lomborgs False Alarm is simple and simplistic: Activists have been sounding a false alarm about the dangers of climate change. If we listen to them, Lomborg says, we will waste trillions of dollars, achieve little and the poor will suffer the most. Science has provided a way to carefully balance costs and benefits, if we would only listen to its clarion call. And, of course, the villain in this false alarm, the boogeyman for all of societys ills, is the hyperventilating media. Lomborg doesnt use the term fake news, but its there if you read between the lines.
As with others in Lomborgs camp, theres the pretense in this book of balance and reference to careful studies. Yes, climate change is real. Yes, we should do something about it. But, goes his message, lets be real, there are other problems, too. Resources are scarce. The more money we spend on climate change, the less we have to grow the economy; and as we all know (or do we?) everybody benefits from growth, especially the poor. And besides, theres not much we can do about climate change.
Hes not completely fatalistic. He urges imposing a carbon tax and investing much more on innovation, both good ideas, although neither is a panacea, especially since the carbon price he suggests is far too low. Among the many contradictions within the book is that while he seems to say that innovation may be our savior, he also suggests that the model he relies on shows that weve invested all we wisely can in innovation. Weve done all we should. Evidently, were supposed to pray that nature be more forgiving as it bestows good fortune on our research efforts.
EDIT
As a matter of policy, I typically decline to review books that deserve to be panned. You only make enemies. Even a slight barb opens a wound the writer will seldom forget. In the case of this book, though, I felt compelled to forgo this policy. Written with an aim to convert anyone worried about the dangers of climate change, Lomborgs work would be downright dangerous were it to succeed in persuading anyone that there was merit in its arguments. This book proves the aphorism that a little knowledge is dangerous. Its nominally about air pollution. Its really about mind pollution.
EDIT/END
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/16/books/review/bjorn-lomborg-false-alarm-joseph-stiglitz.html
Bernardo de La Paz
(49,001 posts)CatLady78
(1,041 posts)Another Jackalope
(112 posts)"A Summa Cum Laude graduate of the Bjorn Lomborg School of Don't Worry, Be Happy"
Then I looked at the evidence. That was an embarrassing moment.