Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

hatrack

(59,583 posts)
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 01:03 PM Sep 2014

"The Crop Is Dying As We Watch It": ND Farmers Trying To Cope With Fracking Waste, Toxic Dumping

EDIT

On Daryl’s land, also on the Wayne field, a few recent spills have left splotches of infertile land where he can still see the crystalized salt flecks on the soil surface. This year Daryl planted soybeans on areas of land where the wastewater was cleaned up and the land was remediated. But still, in some areas, nothing will grow. “There’s three feet of new dirt here, but the salt is working its way into the field through the capillaries,” he said. “The crop is dying as we watch it.”

On the Wiley oil field, which sits about three miles south of the Wayne field, wastewater contamination has caused not only crop failure, Larry said, but also the death of ash and cottonwood trees. “The cattle won’t even eat the grass here,” he said. On the Renville field, Christine Peterson pointed out where she discovered a spill in the winter of 2010 because the snow was streaked yellow. Nearby, the land around a 2011 wastewater spill at a disposal site operated by the company PetroHarvester still has a running generator pumping the contaminated water out of the field. As is the case with many incidents, the quantity of wastewater released in this spill is contested. The Oil and Gas Division’s follow-up report cites 300 barrels, but local residents say the state health department initially estimated the spill to have been closer to 50,000 barrels. Either way, it’s been an expensive cleanup; the Oil and Gas Division’s report estimated it would ultimately cost $2.5 million.

Mike Artz’s land is still showing high levels of contamination, despite an ongoing cleanup and remediation effort by Murex, the well operator responsible for the spill. But even more troubling to the Artz family and their neighbors is the perception that the process has been riddled with misreporting and a lack of regulatory enforcement by state agencies. The Oil and Gas Division’s reports say that the spillage lasted for only 24 hours and, impossibly, that it amounted to exactly zero barrels of liquid. (At a recent meeting, Helms, who worked for Texaco and Hess Corp. before becoming the head of the state’s oil regulatory agency, defended the division’s reporting, explaining that farmers shouldn’t expect “complete accuracy” in an initial spill report.) Artz and his neighbors had to file a Freedom of Information request just to get a record of the health department’s estimate that 16,800 to 25,200 gallons of wastewater had spilled.

EDIT

A third problem is tanker rollovers, which occur when a driver’s wheels catch the often icy edges of North Dakota’s narrow highways and flip over. “There are more wrecks and fatalities than I’ve ever seen,” said the owner of a small trucking company in Williston who previously worked as a driver for the oil industry in Alaska and Texas and spoke on the condition of anonymity. “In the winter there are two or three every day.” But not all of the tanker spills are accidental. Jerry Samuelson explained that some truck drivers illegally dump wastewater alongside the highway to avoid having to haul it all the way to the disposal sites. A huge fine levied against a driver in the city of Minot has helped curtailed the practice, he said. But it hasn’t stopped completely; as Samuelson spoke, his fellow emergency manager Karolin Rockvoy was out investigating a report of an illegal dump. “You can tell someone’s doing some illegal dumping,” she said when she returned a few hours later with photographs. “The thing is to catch them in the act, because otherwise they keep doing it.”

EDIT

http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/9/6/north-dakota-wastewaterlegacy.html

15 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
"The Crop Is Dying As We Watch It": ND Farmers Trying To Cope With Fracking Waste, Toxic Dumping (Original Post) hatrack Sep 2014 OP
It's only the beginning of the disasters to come montanacowboy Sep 2014 #1
Please Please Please -- This truly does NOT have to do truedelphi Sep 2014 #5
That's what I hear is happening also. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #10
... progressoid Sep 2014 #2
salting the earth phantom power Sep 2014 #3
Appreciate this Post hatrack..I grew up there. It is as red a state as they get. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #4
The change you describe in a single generation is heartbreaking BrotherIvan Sep 2014 #6
Sad isn't it. I guess stories will be told untill there are no more elders to speak. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #8
Yes BrotherIvan Sep 2014 #11
Me too WoodyD Sep 2014 #7
Hello neighbor! Then you know exactly what I speak of. We were blessed. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #9
"Sacrifice Zones" - coming soon to states near all of us . . . hatrack Sep 2014 #12
Aww the western Dakota badlands. Where the buffalo still roam. Thanks to preservationists. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #14
k and r and bookmarking to depress myself later. niyad Sep 2014 #13
Oh dear hatrack. Sorry. misterhighwasted Sep 2014 #15

montanacowboy

(6,081 posts)
1. It's only the beginning of the disasters to come
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 01:17 PM
Sep 2014

And they will continue their red state ways

My daughter & son-in-law were over there for a year and couldn't take it anymore. Both left good paying jobs to come back to Montana. They said even the air was like breathing toxic fumes. There are no trees and nothing green. It is a disaster area and they dump toxic waste in black plastic bags everywhere. We have so shit in our beds that nothing can fix it.

truedelphi

(32,324 posts)
5. Please Please Please -- This truly does NOT have to do
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 03:47 PM
Sep 2014

With red state mentality vs blue state mentality.


The ability of the Big Fracking Forces to go into an area and destroy the environment is due to two separate things:

One: that state and local governing officials simply tell "activists" that they themselves are powerless to stop it - that if something is a "legal activity" then it must go through.

That legal activity can be anything from a 40,000 pig industrialized pig farm, that destroys the air and the water and the land, to the fracking activities.

Two: The destruction of Science as we once knew it:

Science once involved having the most pre-eminent people in a field investigate a situation and determine, through careful modeling, data collection and analysis, whether an activity's benefit to risk situation is such that the benefit is more important than the risk.

Perhaps the last time that this nation experienced such a truly scientific investigation was back in 1998, when Gov Davis (D) of California appointed pre-eminent scientist and researcher John Froines to oversee a Blue Ribbon team of scientists and determine the fate of MTBE. As a result of that team's investigation, the gas additive MTBE was banned, and Californians saw that noxious substance reduced significantly in their gasoline's content, saving our aquifers and drinking water, and our health.

These days, any pre-eminent scientist in their field must have never ever dissed any product that is important to Big Huge Industrialized Corporations such as Big Oil and Energy, Big Pharma, Big Agriculture etc.

So any scientist who has ever hinted at the notion that fracking is not a good idea has already been purged from the Big Oil and Energy's "go to list" of researchers who will be chosen by them to research and "scientifically" determine the possibility of whether fracking is or is not harmful.

It is also important to note that our governmental agencies themselves are merely revolving doors by which industry has their people placed in governmental positions - a good example being what happened before and during the approval process of Aspartame. (Google Aspartame, Donald Rumsfeld, approval of Aspartame to read a compelling story of what goes really on when a substance is "examined" and "investigated" by our agencies.)

About the only way that I see that we can stop fracking is for Democrats, Republicans and Third Party people to all unite and utilize the process that The Community Rights movement is teaching people to take our communities back from the Fascistas now ruling over us.

I have already looked into my "Delphic" crystal ball, and I can tell you with total certainty that Big Corporate Science is going to spend the next fifty years telling us the "proven scientific" fact that many areas' water became undrinkable, its land became barren, its wildlife crippled and dying -- all that is merely coincidendental to the fact that these things happened immediately after fracking began in those areas.

misterhighwasted

(9,148 posts)
10. That's what I hear is happening also.
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 05:38 PM
Sep 2014

I visited family there 4 years ago. I don't care to go back. Its just another oil boom town.



Hope your family is better where they are now. Smart decision to leave the "promise of riches" for a home that hasn't been bulldozed over by Big Greedy Oil.
Thanks for posting.

misterhighwasted

(9,148 posts)
4. Appreciate this Post hatrack..I grew up there. It is as red a state as they get.
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 02:56 PM
Sep 2014

The excitement of oil development as the Bakken took hold, is suddenly met with staring directly at the reality of an out of control business. Their beautiful clean air & skies is clouding with the smell of 7 wells per section of land.
The beautiful fields & prairie that offered great hunting of pheasant, deer & water fowl is toxic by unreported & unregulated toxic spills & intentional dumps.
Their beautiful Lake Sakakwea & Missouri River is now fragile & vulnerable with a new maze of pipelines running under & around in all directions.
The recreation lovers in that State have their livelihood threatened for generations.
Winter ice fishing, & summertime tournaments on the Missouri, where the grand fish of them all, the Walleye exists in plenty, is not so certain as this State continues to drive their own shiny beautiful bus into a deep toxic sludge filled ditch.

Good Luck North Dakota.
Glad I knew you when you were clean & green in the summer & bright & white in the winter.
When your clear blue skies by day reflected back that star filled Milky Way by night.
Thanks for the memories & as many nights I watched the Northern Lights dance across the sky, from childhood to adult, a good 30 years worth, I delight in having never once seen you dance the same dance twice.

I'll stay away & remember the pure land as it was when I was there.
__________________________________________________




BrotherIvan

(9,126 posts)
6. The change you describe in a single generation is heartbreaking
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 03:49 PM
Sep 2014

I wonder if one day people will realize the riches beyond measure were the visions you describe, not the resources that could be stripped from the land.

misterhighwasted

(9,148 posts)
8. Sad isn't it. I guess stories will be told untill there are no more elders to speak.
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 05:12 PM
Sep 2014

The land has been changed forever.

WoodyD

(215 posts)
7. Me too
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 03:52 PM
Sep 2014

I grew up on a farm in northwestern North Dakota. Clear skies, clean air, endless fields of wheat, green pastures, the Milky Way and the gorgeous northern lights, Lake Sakakawea stretching out blue and sparkling to the horizon. It was beautiful then. Now, I stay away.

misterhighwasted

(9,148 posts)
9. Hello neighbor! Then you know exactly what I speak of. We were blessed.
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 05:28 PM
Sep 2014

State Law says there can be 7 wells pr section of land.
However, I am told that oil co's. are currently petitioning the State to allow for 12 per section.
That's a lot of wells flaring & a lot of oil to be moved out of state, and a lot of frack waste to be dumped in that small corner of the world.

My grandfather & his siblings all settled & farmed near Killdeer. They were Germans from Russia. They found that part of the USA most familiar to the home they left a world away.
Like your family, they took pride in their work, their days were long & their homes, churches, & towns were built to last generations.
They had music, laughter, & some pretty good home brew to unite the community, on the time off from working the land.
They were careful considerate stewards of the prairie land they claimed.
You & I also lived the best of that lovely peaceful place that barely anyone in the USA ever knew existed.

Nice to meet you.
Peace & happiness & good memories to you & yours.

misterhighwasted

(9,148 posts)
14. Aww the western Dakota badlands. Where the buffalo still roam. Thanks to preservationists.
Sat Sep 6, 2014, 07:46 PM
Sep 2014

There are conservation & environmental groups within the State that fight wholeheartedly for regulations & to hold companies employed in the Bakken, accountable.
They cannot kep up with the task at hand & fighting the State for justice is defeating most times.
I do donate to them. They are true to their cause.
Have to do what we can.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»"The Crop Is Dying A...