When the Facts Don't Matter
http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/politics/2012/03/gay_marriage_doesn_t_harm_children_but_the_facts_don_t_seem_to_matter_.html
Last month's news that the majority of births to American women under 30 now occur outside of marriage will likely confirm for social conservatives that marriage itself is becoming a relic, with major consequences for society. Its one of the main reasons they cite for opposing anything that might alter societys image of the institution, like calling a same-sex union a marriage. If marriage includes the union of two people of the same sex, they worry it will be unrecognizable to many Americans, who will stop taking it seriously enough to tie the knot.
Yet when you look at the new research from Child Trends, the group that released the latest data, you actually find evidence against the suggestion that same-sex marriage undermines the health of marriage more generally.
Heres why: The conservative argument against the freedom to marry, newly resonant in an election year, is primarily a norms argument. Maggie Gallagher, who many believe has done more than anyone to block the freedom to marry through her writing, fundraising, and founding of activist groups, says she is not anti-gay, just pro-marriageand concerned about child welfare. Children need a mom and a dad, she says whenever she can. To hear her tell it, marriage needs protecting not as some abstract moral principle but because marriage is a fragile but vital institution that society depends on to make adults more responsible to their biological children (and to each other). Government sanctions the institution as a unique, procreative bond in order to reinforce this norm, and those who identify as a husband or wife are more likely to honor their commitments. After gay marriage, she said in a recent interview, marriage will not be about that anymore. We will not have an institution dedicated to putting together mothers and fathers and children.
Advertisement
This argument is grossly imprecise at best. After all, infertile couples, post-menopausal women, and those who choose not to procreate can still wed, so long as theyre straight. The only way to make sense of the argument is to assume that its really saying this: Most straight people so dislike gay people that theyd choose not to marry rather than share the honor with gays.