Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ZERTErYNOthe

(199 posts)
Sun Oct 16, 2022, 10:25 PM Oct 2022

Bad Doctors experience

This happened quite a while ago to my partner. I thought I would share it with others, because it shows how the quality of doctors varies, and how a doctor simply listening to you makes a difference. A long read.

My wife and I had just moved in to a new rural property. Her coworker and friend said that he was getting ready to demolish an old wooden shed on his property (he was going to burn it down). Since we were in a new property with need of storage, we looked to see if we could salvage anything. Yes, we could! Actually, quite a bit. So we set about tearing down his old shed, which in some cases involved swinging a sledgehammer. With the last swing my wife made, she felt a pop and said 'I'm done'. She wasn't in pain or anything, she just knew that was enough. We finished up and went home.

The next morning started out OK, but after her shower while sitting on the bed, she tried to put on a sock. That's it. Instant agony, couldn't bend down. I helped, but it was obvious we weren't going to work that day. So, queue up the visit to the docs. We gave the whole story, including the suggestion that my wife knew exactly what happened and when (the swing of the sledge). Referred to the local hospital for an urgent sonogram thinking it was kidney stones (with less resistance from the radiology folks than when her appendix burst, by the way, but that's a different story). So they told her it was kidney stones, gave a painkiller, and told her to wait it out. Results read by the doc the next day said they saw no evidence of kidney stone. After another agonzing day, rinse and repeat. Bottom line for a few days, my wife was in agony, it was getting worse, and everyone said kidney stones.

So we did some calling around, got a referral/recommendation to another doctor, who specialized in sport and spinal injuries. You would think this is a good fit, considering what we said the source of the injury was, right? The referring docs thought so. After a cursory exam, he declared there was no injury, my wife didn't know what happened to her, and referred her to another specialist: A gastroenterologist oncologist. I literally almost fainted in the waiting room when I heard them tell her that. Yes, literally. One of the worst moments of our married life.

After recovering a few minutes, sitting in our car in the parking garage crying, and not really trusting the docs we had seen so far, I thought about one of our most trusted docs over the years - my wifes OBGYN. I called them, and as usual, their first appointment was 3 months away. I said this was extremely urgent, could we talk to Dr. X. The response wasn't hopeful, but we got a call back from him personally in less than an hour. He would see us immediately. We headed over and waited to see him.

He asked my wife to give a basic explanation of what was going on, and listened intently. Next step was an exam, really just basic exam, like what you would get in a physical. Palpitating, asking questions, nothing invasive. And then he asked us to go to the waiting room for a bit.

He called us in to his office, pulled out his medical books, and explained why he believed my wife had ruptured a particular disc, and even the side of the disc, based solely on listening to her and the basic exam. He had also arranged for a specialist to see her the next day (yes, he called him and asked for him to see my wife ASAP). Long story short, after several expensive tests, the specialist confirmed what my wifes OBGYN figured out just by listening to her.

He also followed up by sending a strongly worded letter to the spine injury specialist who told my wife she had cancer. We followed up with docs who assured us it was kidney stones.

Good news, my wife is doing well. A bit of PT and some meds, and she was back to work in a physically demanding job a few weeks later. We finished rebuilding the shed on our property, and it is still in use today over a decade later! (bad news: it is in dire need of reorganization and cleanup).

I'm not sure exactly why I am sharing this with you guys, except to say that be careful with doctors, make sure you trust them, and don't be afraid to stand up for yourself or your loved ones if something doesn't seem right. Don't be a Karen (I hate that term, I have some much loved actual Karens in my life), but do be willing to question those who literally hold your future in their hands. And sometimes you end up with a true genius, a true Hercule Poirot, like we did!

8 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Bayard

(22,119 posts)
3. There's still a lot of people who put doctors on a pedestal
Sun Oct 16, 2022, 11:58 PM
Oct 2022

Especially older folks.

They are, indeed, human and fallible.

niyad

(113,490 posts)
4. Far too many people believe that M.D. stands for "medical deity", in part
Mon Oct 17, 2022, 12:18 AM
Oct 2022

because so many drs.try to project that imge. Thank goodness that you and your wife know one of the good ones.

Historic NY

(37,452 posts)
5. I fell jumping off a wall on June 1
Mon Oct 17, 2022, 12:35 AM
Oct 2022

I saw that I was headed to the side of my truck and was able to turn and put my should out for the impact. Silly me, I rammed the bumper, I instantly heard a crunch and I knew something was wrong. Went to my chiropractor as I was going to go past it to the urgent care. He left around and said it seems like the shoulder is separated. They x-rayed and confirmed. I should have went to their surgeon, but I headed over to the supposed best guy. He told there was really nothing to do with this. I had limited motion and couldn't raise my arm fully, the collar bone was sticking up. Thinking that was there wasn't, nothing I could do about it I went on until I was in for an exam at the main facility at the urgent care. The nurse suggested I go see the shoulder specialist. Now after almost 5 weeks he repaired it with a plate and donor ligament. I see him on a followup the coming week, I still wear the special sling and hopefully Pt will take care of getting all the function back. He specializes in this and said its a common injury with football players, especially young kids. Its improving I hope by the end of Nov. like he said I'll never know it happened.

Aussie105

(5,412 posts)
6. Doctoring is pretty much a guessing game at the best of times.
Mon Oct 17, 2022, 01:03 AM
Oct 2022

Despite the fact they are portrayed as competent professionals, many aren't very good at the job, and others have biases that lead you nowhere.

Best not to get injured or catch something nasty. If you can.

But making the wife swing a sledge hammer? What were you thinking?
Mine complains if she has to carry shopping bags. Empty ones.

Chainfire

(17,576 posts)
7. A few years ago my wife almost died due to a ruptured appendix.
Mon Oct 17, 2022, 09:35 AM
Oct 2022

We knew we had to get a different opinion when her doctor was convinced that she had Malaria... As a result of the delay of the proper treatment, she had to have a full hysterotomy along with the appendectomy.

I have recently had a skin issue. My primary care doctor referred me to a specialist. So far, I have had three visits to the office, and I haven't seen a doctor yet....After nine months and a lot of guesswork, my condition has not improved. The nurse practitioner that I have been seeing is very young and pretty, which I guess is something.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Health»Bad Doctors experience