Is Screen Time Bad for Kids' Brains?

[elleng]

A study featured on “60 Minutes” is sure to alarm parents. Here’s what scientists know, and don’t know, about the link between screens, behavior, and development.

'A generation ago, parents worried about the effects of TV; before that, it was radio. Now, the concern is “screen time,” a catchall term for the amount of time that children, especially preteens and teenagers, spend interacting with TVs, computers, smartphones, digital pads, and video games. This age group draws particular attention because screen immersion rises sharply during adolescence, and because brain development accelerates then, too, as neural networks are pruned and consolidated in the transition to adulthood.

On Sunday evening, CBS’s “60 Minutes” reported on early results from the A.B.C.D. Study (for Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development), a $300 million project financed by the National Institutes of Health. The study aims to reveal how brain development is affected by a range of experiences, including substance use, concussions, and screen time. As part of an exposé on screen time, “60 Minutes” reported that heavy screen use was associated with lower scores on some aptitude tests, and to accelerated “cortical thinning" — a natural process — in some children. But the data is preliminary, and it’s unclear whether the effects are lasting or even meaningful.

Does screen addiction change the brain?
Yes, but so does every other activity that children engage in: sleep, homework, playing soccer, arguing, growing up in poverty, reading, vaping behind the school. The adolescent brain continually changes, or “rewires” itself, in response to daily experience, and that adaptation continues into the early to mid 20s.

What scientists want to learn is whether screen time, at some threshold, causes any measurable differences in adolescent brain structure or function, and whether those differences are meaningful. Do they cause attention deficits, mood problems, or delays in reading or problem-solving ability?'

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/10/health/screen-time-kids-psychology.html?

[MontanaMama]

1. Bookmarked.

Screen time is a constant battle in this house. I don’t know when to be a hard ass and when to let it go.

[mopinko]

2. and before that- dime novels.

[elleng]

3. 'hidden in the corn shed,

I tell you we've got TROUBLE!!!'

[mopinko]

4. well played.

i wish we had a post reaction thingie here.

[LeftishBrit]

6. 200 years ago, Jane Austen wrote in 'Northanger Abbey' about the bad effects that the then-popular

'Gothic novels were having on young Catherine.

[LeftishBrit]

5. I don't think there's any evidence that screen time as such is particularly harmful to children's

brains.

As with everything else, moderation is a good thing. If you spend all your time on a screen (or any other single activity), then you're not spending time doing other things, and thus depriving yourself of other important mental, physical and social activities. But I'm not at all convinced that this is any worse for screen time than TV (the bugbear in my own childhood), comics (a bugbear in the previous generation), popular music (always a bugbear in one form or another), etc.

I would guess that children and teenagers with attention deficits, mood problems, or reading delays are probably more likely than others to become addicted to screens in the first place. This may then be unhelpful in overcoming the problems; but I doubt that it's usually the cause of them.