Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Lionel Mandrake

(4,126 posts)
Sat Feb 11, 2017, 03:31 PM Feb 2017

Wiktionary IPA symbol R is messed up.

In the standard German pronunciation of words that begin with an r, like "reich", the first IPA symbol should be R, which indicates a uvular trill, but when I look up "reich" in Wiktionary, the R is upside down, which indicates a uvular fricative. This is true on three different web browsers. I wonder what's going on. I'm using a Macintosh computer.

3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Wiktionary IPA symbol R is messed up. (Original Post) Lionel Mandrake Feb 2017 OP
Long, long time since taking Phonetics . . . Aimee in OKC Feb 2017 #1
I think Wiktionary's right. Igel Feb 2018 #2
That's good to know. Lionel Mandrake Feb 2018 #3

Aimee in OKC

(160 posts)
1. Long, long time since taking Phonetics . . .
Sat Feb 11, 2017, 04:20 PM
Feb 2017

R shows as uvular trill, upside down as fricative ... on a PC, so probably not a Mac thing.

www.ipachart.com -- had to go here to reach for dim memories and now the web makes it so easy to hear it on demand.

Good luck with the puzzle.

Igel

(36,189 posts)
2. I think Wiktionary's right.
Sat Feb 10, 2018, 04:48 PM
Feb 2018

German /r/ in initial position is a uvular fricative. Flip that R upside down.

Uvular trills are vanishingly rare. Last I hear some dialects of Swedish used them and some language in Malaysia or Indonesia. It's likely that they were transitional between a dental trill and the uvular fricative (I think), but a lot of people really have trouble with them and they're very, very poorly attested. Wiki has a slightly different list (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uvular_trill); what I remember is from UPSID in the late 1990s. It pays to not consider extreme versions of the sound to be normative--in the right circumstance a native speaker might pronounce the fricative as a trill; but I've heard speakers of languages do strange things when being especially emphatic, with ejectives and implosives or aspirated consonants popping up in languages without either.

A uvular trill and a dental trill are very, very similar to my ears. I perceive the uvular trill to be a bit sloppier, a bit less sharp (to use an old phonological feature) and with less lateral frication. I'd record and embed spectrograms but my PRAAT knowledge wasn't great and is now in complete disrepair. I've never heard a native speaker of a language variety with a uvular trill. Note that I've learned some French, some German and a bit of Arabic and Portuguese, and they all had uvular fricatives. With Arabic, of course, the one that didn't have the fricative as a reflex of an originally dental trill.

Lionel Mandrake

(4,126 posts)
3. That's good to know.
Sat Feb 10, 2018, 08:02 PM
Feb 2018

I can't do either kind of trill, nor can I hear the difference. I'll never speak proper Spanish. The initial German R sounds the same to me as that of the dialect of French spoken in Paris, which is taken to be standard. If I understand what you are saying, and if the noise in question is not a trill, then there's hope for me (or there would be if I were younger). I can pronounce German words like "Bach", so maybe I can add voicing to make an acceptable approximation to the initial noise of words like "Reich".

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Languages and Linguistics»Wiktionary IPA symbol R i...