Jewish Group
Related: About this forum“Gaza = Auschwitz”
Holocaust inversionthe claim that Israelis are the new Nazis and Palestinians the new Jewshas come to the American university campus.Five years ago, during an earlier Israeli operation in Gaza, the British novelist Howard Jacobson explained why calling the Israelis Nazis and likening Gaza to the Warsaw Ghetto goes far beyond mere criticism of Israel:
Experts call this Holocaust inversion. Based in the claim that Israel now behaves toward the Palestinians as Nazi Germany behaved toward the Jews, it originated in post-World War II Soviet propaganda, and from there spread to the Soviets Arab clients. It is now fully embedded in the Arab-Muslim world, where it grows and mutates in symbiosis with outright denial that the Holocaust occurred or a radical reduction of its genocidal scale, ferocity, and number of victims. Holocaust inversion has a graphic omnipresence in cartoons all over the Arab and Iranian press, where Israelis are regularly portrayed in Nazi regalia. Elsewhere in the Middle East and beyond, it has surfaced in the rhetoric of populist demagogues and the media. In Turkeys new president and long-time prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, it now has a champion in a head of state. In Europe, Holocaust inversion is busy spreading beyond its original locus of infection and finding a home among intellectuals and activists, especially on the Left.
....There is such a thing as legitimate criticism of Israel, and there is such a thing as crossing the line into demonization and, to put it plainly, Jew-baiting. The analogies spewed by Columbias tenured professors are of the latter kind, and are obscene. Jew-baiting covers a wider range than anti-Semitism, and Holocaust inversion is its favorite technique. Jew-baiting is the demand that Israel and ITS SUPPORTERS explain why Gaza isnt like a Nazi extermination camp or a starved ghetto for the doomed, or why a targeted air campaign isnt just like the incineration of Dresden. That it should be practiced so openly by tenured professors at New Yorks Ivy League home is a scandal, and a warning.
http://mosaicmagazine.com/tesserae/2014/08/gaza-equals-auschwitz/
jaysunb
(11,856 posts)Many Jewish people don't like or approve what this group is doing. The author needs to take a seat.
shira
(30,109 posts)Gaza is Auschwitz.
No other events worldwide are constantly compared to Nazi atrocities. Only the Jewish state is accused of being the new Nazis. Only the victims of the Holocaust and their offspring are compared to Nazis. Constantly.
This is Jew-baiting.
jaysunb
(11,856 posts)to make it appear that all people of Jewish heritage are of the same mind set and are somehow collectively responsible for the atrocities being committed, or at least being blamed. This is not so.
If any one is "Jew baiting" it's him. IMO
Behind the Aegis
(53,989 posts)You do realize you are posting in the Jewish Group, right? If so, then I invite you to look through our "extensive" archives and note all the conflation of Jews around the world being blamed for the actions of Israel. You should not presume to tell a Jew who is Jew-baiting and what it isn't.
Behind the Aegis
(53,989 posts)The reason it is used is precisely as the author lays out, and that is to paint the Israelis (and Jews by proxy) as the Nazis and the Palestinians as the Jews. It is taking something from the history of the Jewish people and being used to "criticize" a predominantly Jewish nation; it isn't subtle.
Also what isn't subtle, is the number of non-Jews who dictate to Jews what is and isn't anti-Semitism and mock, ridicule, and diminish real anti-Semitism. It is quite annoying when the majority group who has historically oppressed the group in question continues said oppression by demanding to dictate what is and isn't discrimination against them.
King_David
(14,851 posts)Exactly right.