Jewish Group
Related: About this forumJews Under Attack Deserve Better Than Selective Outrage
By Benjamin Wittes
Contributing writer at The Atlantic and editor in chief of Lawfare
The Jewish community has turned selective outrage over anti-Semitism into a kind of norm.
There was a timeand it was not that long agowhen regardless of what separated Jews, we made a certain common cause over those who traded in the themes that had caused so many Jewish deaths. You could be religious or secular, liberal or conservative, but protecting Jews in the Soviet Union was a fight we all fought. Jews didnt look the other way when Louis Farrakhan or David Duke spouted hatred. And an attack on a synagogue was, well, an attack on a synagogue.
Times have changed. Over the past few weeks, Orthodox Jews in the New York area have been targeted in a series of violent attacks. Yet the reaction has been muffled, including from peopleespecially but not exclusively Jewswho one would expect to be up in arms. The reaction is about what youd expect for unpleasant graffiti-writing or anti-Semitic name-calling. It is certainly not what I would have expected in response to a wave of hate crimes, including attacks with guns and machetes, that have left people dead and in critical condition.
Why the comparatively mild response? For many American Jews, the answer is that these arent our kind of Jewsand the attackers arent motivated by the kind of anti-Semitism we most want to talk about.
Batya Unger-Sargon, the opinion editor at the Forward, put it bluntly and correctly this morning:
After the massacre at a Pittsburgh synagogue on Shabbat that killed 11 people last year, and another fatal shooting at a shul in Poway, California six months later, one often heard that the great threat to Jewseven the only threatcomes from white supremacy. Conventional wisdom said it was the political right, and the rights avatar in the White House, that was to blame for the rising levels of hate against Jews.
But the majority of the perpetrators of the Brooklyn attacks, and the suspects in Jersey Citywho were killed in a shootout with the policeand now Monsey, were not white, leaving many at a loss about how to explain it or even talk about it. There is little evidence that these attacks are ideologically motivated, at least in terms of the ideologies of hate we are most familiar with.
And therein lies the trouble with talking about the violent attacks against Orthodox Jews: At a time when ideology seems to [reign] supreme in the chattering and political classes, the return of pogroms to Jewish life on American soil transcends ideology. In the fight against anti-Semitism, you dont get to easily blame your traditional enemieswhich, in the age of Trump, is a non-starter for most people.
In our political moment, a great many people seem more outraged by the other sides anti-Semitism than by their own sides. Only recently, Jewish supporters of the president seemed not to notice when Rudy Giulianithe presidents lawyerdisparaged the Judaism of a Holocaust survivor. Trump trades in anti-Semitic stereotypes on a relatively routine basis; he once suggested that Jews had to vote for him because Senator Elizabeth Warren would take away their wealth, and he ran an ad at the close of the 2016 election insinuating that a Jewish elite holds too much power and control. Trumps Jewish supporters have looked the other way even as they have seen a menace to the Jewish future from Democraticbut not Republicanmembers of Congress who have advanced similar ideas.
Rest at link: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/what-monsey-attack-says-about-jewish-community/604228/?utm_content=edit-promo&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook&utm_term=2019-12-29T21%3A48%3A31&utm_campaign=the-atlantic&fbclid=IwAR2AlUkfrHHr3yUx3nggC1rBWQ7ACe41GdPGb2K0f82GNv4FS6OWRfUWqYE
This article is spot on. We need to quit pretending anti-semitism is only a feature in the right wing.
elleng
(130,905 posts)EllieBC
(3,014 posts)elleng
(130,905 posts)and I thought it was useful.
Caption under title: 'If youre not willing to confront the diversity of anti-Semitism, youre just not being serious.'
Thanks for posting.
no_hypocrisy
(46,104 posts)Don't think this mass attack of antisemitism will stop if Trump leaves in 2021.
EllieBC
(3,014 posts)We all pretended it was.
Jewish students on college campuses have been harassed for years. Orthodox Jews have been regularly harassed in cities for years. Jews in Europe have been treated like...well like Jews in Europe.
And no one cared. People kind of care now but only because theres a white supremacist in the WH hurting other groups of minorities. No one cared when it wasnt or when it isnt white supremacists.
Behind the Aegis
(53,956 posts)Attacks like this last one is an "inconvenient" form of anti-Semitism. It seems some only want to combat (or care about) anti-Semitism when it can be tied to white supremacy/neo-Nazis. I have watched as people desperately try to tie this to the asshole squatting in the White House. While it is true, he and his administration have made open bigotry more acceptable, not every act of hate, including anti-Semitism, can be tied to him. I am even more disgusted by those who keep trying to tie this to Israel, or worse yet, blaming Jews for acts of anti-Semitism; usually Netanyahu, but also Miller, Jarvanka, etc.
Just like this article states, it seems there are some Jews who "deserve" acts of anti-Semitism. Not that long ago there was an anti-Semitic video bemoaning Jews moving into the neighborhood. If that video had been about any other minority, the same people who made excuses, would be screeching like deranged, lobotomized parrots, "BIGOTRY!!" But, because it was a version of Jews they don't "approve of", it was seen as "not anti-Semitic."
Both sides of the fence, including our own kind (Jews), have a real issue confronting anti-Semitism when it comes from their own pasture. It was appalling watching Jews bark like trained seals when the "president" was making one anti-Semitic comment after another, but it was just as disgusting watching so-called liberals telling Jews like Nadler to "Shut the fuck up!" when he spoke out against what he felt was anti-Semitic remarks from our side. Both sides only seem to attack the other side's anti-Semitism.
Anti-Semitism is anti-Semitism!
EllieBC
(3,014 posts)Ok ok SOME attacks are made by non-white people but LOOK AT TRUMP!!!.
They literally cannot say, hey antisemites come from everywhere. and leave it at that.
JudyM
(29,248 posts)Glad to read it. The growing rumbling of thunder is surrounding us, and we have to get real about accountability.
MosheFeingold
(3,051 posts)Coupled with the Chanukah attacks caused my shul to have a very heated discussion regarding firearms, down to the minutiae of what can and cannot be carried on Shabbos.
Long story short, several of our ex-IDF members and other ex police or military are taking an active shooter class, the local police are giving us a plan and there will be armed people (including two women) during all services, with a specific plan.
Its the times in which we live.
EllieBC
(3,014 posts)MosheFeingold
(3,051 posts)And paralleled much of the discussion that was had.
Two things came to mind:
(1) about once or twice a year we have a serious disrupter, generally someone who is crazy and had asked for money (same as with the church in Texas) and
(2) that preservation of innocent life is superior to almost all other mitzvah (and, in fact, all we could think of that were in play)
The unfortunate thing is this particular shul is not in a great neighborhood and is next to apartments that many of us stay in for Shabbos (that have to travel). They have a lot of "Section 8" housing and troubled people. Lots of rude comments, but no real problems, yet.
Because of the nature of the space, it is also hard to secure it.