Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Rob H.

(5,349 posts)
Mon Sep 15, 2014, 08:08 PM Sep 2014

Pope Francis’ new clothes: Why his progressive image is white smoke and mirrors

Excerpt follows; full article is here. All emphases added by me.

Pope Francis’ new clothes: Why his progressive image is white smoke and mirrors
Don't buy his populist rhetoric. The new pope is every bit the sexist homophobe as his predecessors
ANNA MARCH, THE WEEKLINGS


The image of Pope Francis is that he is a breath of fresh air, more progressive on social issues than his predecessor and a kinder, gentler pope. But when the facts are examined, you see that he is none of these things. There is an enormous disconnect between who the pope really is in terms of his policies and his public relations image, as crafted by the Vatican’s PR man, previously with Fox News. The current PR mission is all about reversing the incredible decline in fundraising under the last pope from the U.S. Catholic Church in particular. Pope Francis has made any number of statements that seem to indicate change and progress that are not reflected in policy. In fact, in the wake of such comments from Pope Francis, the Vatican often makes a point to explicitly state that no church policy has changed.

While the pope transmits a populist vibe—particularly about the economy— he is an old-school conservative who, despite his great PR, maintains nearly all of the social policies of his predecessors and keeps up a hardline Vatican “cabinet.” He has done virtually nothing to change the policies of the church to match his more compassionate rhetoric. People excuse the pope, claiming that he doesn’t have much power to make changes, but this simply isn’t true. Further, it is ludicrous to suggest that a man who denies comprehensive reproductive health care (including all forms of birth control including condoms and abortion) and comprehensive family planning is a man who cares about the poor of this world. The bigotry of homophobia and sexism cloaked in religion are still bigotry and sexism. By giving to the church, American Catholics aren’t supporting “progress,” they are supporting oppression and in this way are complicit in the bigotry, sexism, and oppression of the church.

...

Another critical area where Pope Francis has continued in the tradition of his predecessor Pope Benedict is the sexual abuse scandal in the Catholic Church. In addition to praising Pope Benedict’s handling of the scandal, Pope Francis also said in March of this year, “The Catholic Church is perhaps the only public institution that has moved with transparency and responsibility. No one has done more. And yet the church is the only one that has been attacked.” According to an AP report immediately after the Pope made those statements, the Vatican “still has no blanket policy telling bishops to report abusers to police or risk being sanctioned themselves, and to date no bishop has been punished for a cover up. In addition, the harshest penalty the church hands out to abusers is the ecclesial equivalent of firing the priest.” Pope Francis continues to engage in “…. more of what we’ve seen for decades — more gestures, promises, symbolism and public relations,” according to Joelle Casteix of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, or SNAP.

...

Instead, the church has the same focus on dogma over helping the poor, the same oppressive views on women and homosexuals, and the same abhorrent behavior in response to the sex abuse scandals. There is zero flexibility on contraception, abortion, gay rights, women’s role in the church. Pope John Paul II and Benedict XVI were at least honest salesmen; they told you exactly what you were getting. Pope Francis is much craftier than that. He uses his charm and humility (and a strong public relations strategy) to achieve the same goal as a used car salesman: to separate you from your money. American Catholics must put their faith and money where their mouth is if they want to see real change in the church. The idea that one can remain an active member of the church and expect ideological change only encourages the current pope to continue the practice of saying one thing and doing another. And why not? His numbers are up. The Catholic Church’s numbers are up. And it stands to reason that donations from American Catholics follow his favorability numbers and rise dramatically.

...
25 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Pope Francis’ new clothes: Why his progressive image is white smoke and mirrors (Original Post) Rob H. Sep 2014 OP
Clearly, he's managing to do what he was hired to do. LiberalAndProud Sep 2014 #1
Probably not an appropriate time to mention Gelliebeans Sep 2014 #20
Let's remember who invented the word "propaganda..." onager Sep 2014 #2
Progressive image or no, bvf Sep 2014 #3
"the Vatican hired Greg Burke, a former Fox News correspondent, as a senior communications adviser" beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #4
Burke is a traditionalist, a celibate, a member of the conservative catholic alliance Opus-Dei, ... AlbertCat Sep 2014 #10
I know, seriously, wtf? beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #13
"American Catholics must put their faith and money where their mouth is if they want to see... trotsky Sep 2014 #5
To me, some things seem painfully obvious: Rob H. Sep 2014 #24
"...what, exactly, is it going to take?" trotsky Sep 2014 #25
I'm amazed at how naive and gullible so many DUers are about Pope Charlatan. Arugula Latte Sep 2014 #6
*Especially* the so-called progressive ones. mr blur Sep 2014 #7
I can understand why criticism makes Catholics squirmy. beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #8
You're an atheist, mr blur Sep 2014 #9
Whoops! beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #11
Even Skinner joined in on The Popefest . Arugula Latte Sep 2014 #14
A double standard, why are other religious right wingers fair game? beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #15
I don't know, but a lot of times a comment along these lines shows up on a pope thread: Arugula Latte Sep 2014 #16
Ah. beam me up scottie Sep 2014 #17
how little it takes to pull the wool over peoples' eyes, AlbertCat Sep 2014 #12
Interesting read k&r n/t Gelliebeans Sep 2014 #18
At first, I cut him some slack Cartoonist Sep 2014 #19
Gold collected thru centuries of selling indulgences, robbing Jews... onager Sep 2014 #23
I'm cautiously optimistic Act_of_Reparation Sep 2014 #21
Frankie isn't going to change a damned thing. Manifestor_of_Light Sep 2014 #22

Gelliebeans

(5,043 posts)
20. Probably not an appropriate time to mention
Thu Sep 18, 2014, 08:38 AM
Sep 2014
Just listening to that made me think of all my PF on my iPhone ( I had a greatest time to listening all of their music that night ) so to you

onager

(9,356 posts)
2. Let's remember who invented the word "propaganda..."
Mon Sep 15, 2014, 08:56 PM
Sep 2014

From "Holy Congregation for the Propagation of the Faith."

When in Rome, visit their world headquarters! Easy to find from the Via Veneto/Spanish Steps. You can stop off on your way to the big shopping street Via Condotti...appropriately enough...

beam me up scottie

(57,349 posts)
4. "the Vatican hired Greg Burke, a former Fox News correspondent, as a senior communications adviser"
Mon Sep 15, 2014, 11:08 PM
Sep 2014
The wheels were set in motion to change the perception of the church before Pope Francis was elected. In March of 2010, Pope Benedict XVI had only a 40 percent favorable rating in the United States. By June of that year, the U.S. Bishops were planning a PR campaign to soften their image and attract the younger generation. Shortly thereafter, the Vatican hired Greg Burke, a former Fox News correspondent, as a senior communications adviser reporting directly to the Vatican’s third-ranking official, Archbishop Giovanni Angelo Becciu. The New York Times points out that Mr. Burke had previously met Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the archbishop of New York, and “did not rule out that being known by the cardinal might have helped him get hired.” Clearly, the American cardinals have a great deal of influence over Vatican PR, given how much Vatican funding comes from the U.S. Burke is a traditionalist, a celibate, a member of the conservative catholic alliance Opus-Dei, and his spiritual practices reportedly include self-flagellation, in keeping with Opus Dei traditionalists.


Makes sense, FOX News convinced Americans that there's a war on christianity.


 

AlbertCat

(17,505 posts)
10. Burke is a traditionalist, a celibate, a member of the conservative catholic alliance Opus-Dei, ...
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 02:35 PM
Sep 2014
... and his spiritual practices reportedly include self-flagellation, in keeping with Opus Dei traditionalists."


In other words, Burke is a loony tune religious nutcase as bad as any fundamentalist from any religion.

trotsky

(49,533 posts)
5. "American Catholics must put their faith and money where their mouth is if they want to see...
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 07:25 AM
Sep 2014

real change in the church."

Careful - say that here on DU and people will attack you for religious bigotry! Just ask AtheistCrusader!

Rob H.

(5,349 posts)
24. To me, some things seem painfully obvious:
Fri Sep 19, 2014, 06:21 PM
Sep 2014

People talk about "changing the church from within" yet they're still giving monetary support and donating their time. Do they really believe the church is going to change as long as they continue to support it regardless of what it does? And if they won't leave it in the wake of all the pedophilia scandals (which should be enough reason all by itself for most people to abandon it) what, exactly, is it going to take?

 

Arugula Latte

(50,566 posts)
6. I'm amazed at how naive and gullible so many DUers are about Pope Charlatan.
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 01:08 PM
Sep 2014

It makes me realize how little it takes to pull the wool over peoples' eyes, even so-called progressive ones.

beam me up scottie

(57,349 posts)
8. I can understand why criticism makes Catholics squirmy.
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 02:25 PM
Sep 2014

But why are apologists constantly jumping to his defense?

It's even more disgusting that LGBT DUers are bullied every time they point out the pope's hypocrisy.

The Church uses all of its money and influence to persecute a minority, the new pope doubles down and we're not supposed to complain about it here?


 

Arugula Latte

(50,566 posts)
14. Even Skinner joined in on The Popefest .
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 03:18 PM
Sep 2014

It depresses me. If a male public figure from a political group espoused the same crap that Francis does, the admins would have made fun of him with one of their cartoony graphics on the front page of DU. But he's *RELIGIOUS* so anyone who criticizes him is a hate-filled bigot.

 

Arugula Latte

(50,566 posts)
16. I don't know, but a lot of times a comment along these lines shows up on a pope thread:
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 03:27 PM
Sep 2014

"How dare you?! Don't you know that millions of Catholics are good Democratic voters?! Are you trying to alienate them and turn them into Republicans?!"

 

AlbertCat

(17,505 posts)
12. how little it takes to pull the wool over peoples' eyes,
Tue Sep 16, 2014, 02:41 PM
Sep 2014

Last edited Tue Sep 16, 2014, 03:17 PM - Edit history (1)

Pope Fabulous merely utters the most sophomoric declarations of altruism and folks just go all gooey!

No one seems to notice that astonishment and surprise that kindness and "love thy brother" is >GASP< coming from the Catholic church is an hysterical joke! "Why I never knew Catholicism entertained such sentiments!"

Cartoonist

(7,309 posts)
19. At first, I cut him some slack
Thu Sep 18, 2014, 03:00 AM
Sep 2014

but as the OP points out, there has actually been Zero change. Kinda like when Randy said he would cancel all executive orders in American history to thunderous applause, then had his toadie say, "not really."

On another note, while surfing the TV, I found a show on the History channel visiting the Vatican museum. What a mind boggling display of wealth. I wonder if Fort Knox has half that much gold. I know Tiffany's doesn't have as much jewelry.
Jesus weeps.

onager

(9,356 posts)
23. Gold collected thru centuries of selling indulgences, robbing Jews...
Thu Sep 18, 2014, 08:14 PM
Sep 2014

...and slaughtering bunches of godless heathens like the Aztecs and Incas.

But we're not supposed to mention any of that, so I won't.

I toured the Vatican Museum. Like most tours, mine ended in St. Peter's Square. Our tour guide pointed toward the obelisk in the Square, and told us that was the very spot where early Xians were martyred by the Romans.

He didn't mention some more recent history of St. Peter's Square - that in Oct. 1943, it was the place where Italian Jews were rounded up for transport to the concentration camps. Right under the nose of Pope Pius XII. I helpfully pointed that out, but the tour guide didn't seem to appreciate it very much. (I figured it was the end of the tour anyway, so they couldn't kick me out.)

Act_of_Reparation

(9,116 posts)
21. I'm cautiously optimistic
Thu Sep 18, 2014, 10:58 AM
Sep 2014

You just have to have patience. On my Roman holiday, I had the great fortune to speak to many Italians about Pope Francis. They told me, "Badate a' fatti vostri!" Which means, I think, "Relax, brosef. He's working on it."

Things are gonna change any minute now. Any... minute... now...



 

Manifestor_of_Light

(21,046 posts)
22. Frankie isn't going to change a damned thing.
Thu Sep 18, 2014, 06:26 PM
Sep 2014

Talks nice, but won't change anything.


Meet the New Boss, same as the Old Boss --Pete Townshend, "Won't Get Fooled Again"

Latest Discussions»Alliance Forums»Atheists & Agnostics»Pope Francis’ new clothes...