Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

quantumjunkie

(244 posts)
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 05:40 AM Mar 2016

Hillary Supporters - Honest Question - Are you a Center-Right Democrat?

Although I haven't been here long I notice Bernie supporters are genuinely on the Left. They are unquestionably Liberals and Progressives.

But for you Hillary supporters i can't fully grasp what your leanings are. The more i read about Hillary and her past (and her real, non-campaign, views) and the more i read posts by her supporters on here i can't help but see that you are definitely to the Right of Bernie supporters. I am not saying you are Republicans, you are definitely democrats, but just have much more conservative views than Bernie supporters.

The democratic party's principles have shifted more Right over the years relative to say the 70s and 80s. That is undeniable. And because the party's definition of what is considered Left has shifted more center-right over the years this result has caused the republican party to go even more to-the-right (and hence, more radical) -- the new definition of being "Right".

There is a divide in the democratic party where by you Hillary supporters have followed the party's rightward shift over the years (which is now defined as the new "Left&quot , while the other portion, the Bernie supporters, have continued to stay faithfully at the original definition of Left (of the 70s/80s) with their views.

So the real question then is do you, as Hillary supporters, view yourselves as center-right when you look back at the original definition of what it meant to be a real Left-leaning Democrat?

Thanks

97 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Hillary Supporters - Honest Question - Are you a Center-Right Democrat? (Original Post) quantumjunkie Mar 2016 OP
Bless your cotton socks child. n/t pkdu Mar 2016 #1
Nah, they're solidly Right Wing Lorien Mar 2016 #2
Yep. Red Knight Mar 2016 #4
Depends on the issues. Ninety percent left, ten percent right DRI Mar 2016 #12
Absolutely true. Cobalt Violet Mar 2016 #8
I would say Hill supporters are left-ish on a handful of social issues - on the rest it isn't clear. reformist2 Mar 2016 #14
What has Hillary ever supported that could be considered leftish? marions ghost Mar 2016 #32
I'm about 4 boxes to the left of Ralph Nader Dem2 Mar 2016 #78
Good questions indeed. Paka Mar 2016 #3
They're with her... wherever she decides to be that day! reformist2 Mar 2016 #5
! ejbr Mar 2016 #10
Sad to say ... that is closest. earthside Mar 2016 #61
how can you tell anyone here is 'genuinely' anything? bigtree Mar 2016 #6
The corporatists ejbr Mar 2016 #11
That would be anti-establishment Democratic Party, which is more republican than Democratic RiverLover Mar 2016 #16
+1 Kittycat Mar 2016 #34
I'm more of an observer, but this: "Bernie supporters are genuinely on the Left, unquestionably ecstatic Mar 2016 #7
My guess is that Clinton will appoint justices that are liberal on social issues Vattel Mar 2016 #9
Excellent and succinct post. Trust Buster Mar 2016 #17
I'm just going to say what I said in 2012 and 2008 and 2004. Chan790 Mar 2016 #19
^^^ THIS! RiverLover Mar 2016 #27
Bravo!! Best post here and dana_b Mar 2016 #52
Right on! n/t Jester Messiah Mar 2016 #80
+!! eom BlueMTexpat Mar 2016 #24
And anyone that holds the treat of the Supreme Court over others heads to garner support A Simple Game Mar 2016 #26
Thank you very much. NurseJackie Mar 2016 #28
But what has Clinton ever done marions ghost Mar 2016 #36
+1 Nicely put Hekate Mar 2016 #93
Where do I sign up for your purity test? mark67 Mar 2016 #13
Sorry but that horse left the barn in the last few years marions ghost Mar 2016 #37
I'm tired of NOT making the distinction pengu Mar 2016 #63
I am a member of the democratic party. stonecutter357 Mar 2016 #15
But are you a part of the Democratic Wing of the Democratic Party? Herman4747 Mar 2016 #20
Howard Dean was, right up until DU tossed him under the bus and ran over him a few times. nt Hekate Mar 2016 #95
Hear hear! n/t SylviaD Mar 2016 #21
Efforts to place a self avowed Socialist smack dab in the center of the Democratic Party is farcical Trust Buster Mar 2016 #18
If Bernie is a "radical" leftist to anyone in this party... Red Knight Mar 2016 #22
Sanders is a fringe candidate, always will be. SylviaD Mar 2016 #23
We Need Another FDR Revolution The Far Left Mar 2016 #31
If you want to see one those mentioned take the oath of office INdemo Mar 2016 #33
"He's a radical Leftist." Do you think so? Gee, I hope so! Kip Humphrey Mar 2016 #79
What a condescending and patronizing BlueMTexpat Mar 2016 #25
We have two candidates marions ghost Mar 2016 #39
FFS, it is a fair question, drop the fake outrage. Nt Logical Mar 2016 #43
None of them really want to admit they are right wingers. n/t Cobalt Violet Mar 2016 #62
Bernie Supporters - Honest Question - Are you actually a Democrat? oberliner Mar 2016 #29
Was FDR a Real Democrat? nt The Far Left Mar 2016 #38
Yes, he never ran as an independent oberliner Mar 2016 #42
Bernie is not a corporate surrogate. The Far Left Mar 2016 #56
The original Democratic party? oberliner Mar 2016 #60
The Democratic party has gone so far to the right marions ghost Mar 2016 #40
Bernie Sanders was not a Democrat three decades ago oberliner Mar 2016 #41
I'm beyond labels at this point marions ghost Mar 2016 #47
Bernie Sanders: "I’m not a liberal. Never have been" oberliner Mar 2016 #48
"Liberal" comes weighted with a lot of connotations. Svafa Mar 2016 #88
Yes, a real one. Not a corporate war loving one. Nt Logical Mar 2016 #44
What percentage of Congressional Democrats are real ones? oberliner Mar 2016 #45
The number appears vanishingly small pengu Mar 2016 #64
I'm your huckleberry casperthegm Mar 2016 #67
Understood oberliner Mar 2016 #72
More navel-gazing. NurseJackie Mar 2016 #30
"this result has caused the republican party to go even more to-the-right" Martin Eden Mar 2016 #35
When did this shift begin? oberliner Mar 2016 #46
It began in earnest with the "Reagan Democrats" Martin Eden Mar 2016 #65
So the Democratic Party has been right wing since after McGovern? oberliner Mar 2016 #73
"right wing" Martin Eden Mar 2016 #75
Right of center oberliner Mar 2016 #81
I don't think Obama is to the right of Bill Clinton, tho he's far from the progressive we hoped for Martin Eden Mar 2016 #82
So you think we have a more left-wing president than the 1990s but a more right-wing party? oberliner Mar 2016 #87
I wouldn't call Obama Left Wing. Martin Eden Mar 2016 #96
I worked on obama campaigns starting with his senate run.... beachbum bob Mar 2016 #49
What 2 presidents wanted to cut Social Security? RiverLover Mar 2016 #51
Are you kidding? Demsrule86 Mar 2016 #50
Agree with everything you just said. Thanks. yardwork Mar 2016 #69
Idealism and pragmatism are not mutually exclusive DemocratSinceBirth Mar 2016 #53
I'm not into labels Loki Mar 2016 #54
I stand with President Obama on most issues, Nye Bevan Mar 2016 #55
I was wondering when I would encounter the first purity post today. It took 4 minutes. LonePirate Mar 2016 #57
Why is this important? Thinkingabout Mar 2016 #58
Pfffffffft... Bobbie Jo Mar 2016 #59
Message auto-removed Name removed Mar 2016 #70
And who are you, exactly? Bobbie Jo Mar 2016 #74
Nope, they're all Progressives. Dumb war hawkish, Wall Street/banksters friendly, bad trade deal... WhaTHellsgoingonhere Mar 2016 #66
No, I'm a liberal who believes in capitalism MaggieD Mar 2016 #68
The thing is that America is so far to the right forjusticethunders Mar 2016 #83
I think they view themselves as Hillary supporters boythayer Mar 2016 #71
This is absolute nonsense Nonhlanhla Mar 2016 #90
What do you consider "Center Right?" Adrahil Mar 2016 #76
I have extremely progressive social views hack89 Mar 2016 #77
What a presumptive question Nonhlanhla Mar 2016 #84
A lot of Bernie supporters are very pro-charter school. Starry Messenger Mar 2016 #85
Center??? QC Mar 2016 #86
Her supporters are "left-leaning Democrats"? Nedsdag Mar 2016 #89
Welcome back and bless your little pea brain. Liberal. Very very liberal. nt Hekate Mar 2016 #91
You are what you vote for. Clinton is right wing ThePhilosopher04 Mar 2016 #92
Is this one of those threads used to call out people so you can put them on ignore? n/t taught_me_patience Mar 2016 #94
Kicked for relevance. quantumjunkie Mar 2016 #97

Lorien

(31,935 posts)
2. Nah, they're solidly Right Wing
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:24 AM
Mar 2016

We would call them Reagan Republicans 25 years ago, but decades of Fox "News" and Rush Limbaugh have made them think that being slightly to the left of the crazed Ayn Rand acolyte filled far right wing clown car makes them "centrists". In every other Country they're as hardcore Right as it gets, and that's why they hate us; they dislike Liberals even *more* than Reagan did!

Note: G.W.Bush and Clinton occupy the same spot on the political compass. McCain is slightly to her left, but more authoritarian.

Red Knight

(704 posts)
4. Yep.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:32 AM
Mar 2016

They have moved that goalpost.

Left to them--isn't what it used to be. They have corrupted the party and like the Pied Piper have led their followers along the path with them. Corporate media shifted with them to basically destroy the true left in this country. Bernie running this year has exposed so many of them for what they truly are. They can't pretend anymore. And they hate him for that and have gone "all-in" on seeing he gets defeated so they can bury all of this and go back to pretending. We need more Bernie Sanders in the future--true and honest politicians who will keep swinging that hammer at the establishment.

It's a long fight.

 

DRI

(24 posts)
12. Depends on the issues. Ninety percent left, ten percent right
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:29 AM
Mar 2016

I consider myself very socially liberal, economically liberal, but where i consider myself center right is on the issue of gun rights. Grew up in a rural area, hunted all my life, have small wooded area and yes I carry a gun with me at most times in the car and on the wooded land. Neither myself nor my partner would feel safe traveling some of these roads at night without having a weapon in the car. So for us it is a balancing act in the primaries. In the general election always Democratic candidates but often with great concern about our gun rights. We have quite a few friends who feel similar but for them they will not support a Democratic Party candidate who do not support gun rights.

Cobalt Violet

(9,905 posts)
8. Absolutely true.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:38 AM
Mar 2016

Watched it as it happened. I've always been disgusted by it and still am. I am delighted that millenniasl are Liberal. It's the only hope for the true left.

reformist2

(9,841 posts)
14. I would say Hill supporters are left-ish on a handful of social issues - on the rest it isn't clear.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:31 AM
Mar 2016

They pretty much agree with whatever comes out of Hillary's mouth, even if she's talking out both sides.

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
32. What has Hillary ever supported that could be considered leftish?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:48 AM
Mar 2016

What has she ever done that was liberal/progressive?

I can't think of anything.

Dem2

(8,168 posts)
78. I'm about 4 boxes to the left of Ralph Nader
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 11:37 AM
Mar 2016

Same on libertarian side. I support both candidates equally.

earthside

(6,960 posts)
61. Sad to say ... that is closest.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:15 AM
Mar 2016

For many it is all about "First Woman President!"

They will deny it and object, but the way they shift around and rationalize all of Hillary's flip-flops; her clear preference for bankers, and Wall Street super investors, Walmart-type corporatists; her conservative and neocon tilt, leaves only one logical explanation: "First Woman President" and it is Hillary's turn matters more than being a good solid progressive and/or liberal.

There is some kind of odd generational loyalty to Mrs. Clinton, probably because they were denied eight years ago and it may have something to do with a sense that the 1960s-1970s era of the Women's Lib movement is owed some kind of reward and Hillary (bizarrely in my estimation) is the symbol of that yearning.

Hillary Clinton is all about the advancement of herself; she is one of those Democrats who believes that the nation is inherently conservative and that the biggest obstacle to her success is the liberal/left base of the Democratic Party. She is at best a Rockefeller Repuglican if she has much ideology at all. I have great concerns over her being president for these reasons, there is something rather Nixonian about her character in my view and see only political crisis if heaven forbid she ever get elected.

ejbr

(5,856 posts)
11. The corporatists
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:21 AM
Mar 2016

have taken over the party; we're anti-corporatists. The party was not as it is, so we are not just going with the flow

RiverLover

(7,830 posts)
16. That would be anti-establishment Democratic Party, which is more republican than Democratic
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:42 AM
Mar 2016

these days. And they're obviously corrupted by Moneyed Interests, this hijacking of the party (along with corporate media) in favor of Clinton2 has made that inescapably obvious.

I mean, do you really want us Democrats out here to have to CONTINUE to defend~

*Trade deals that take American jobs & give them to people working for slave wages to further enrich the rich & crush our middle class.

*Rampant & unregulated fracking, polluting our land and air and spewing pipelines across the country which spreads the risks.(keystone was just one of many, with less catchy names.) Barging radioactive waste on the Ohio River, risking the water source of millions.

*Monopolies

*Deregulated Wall Street. (we're at risk for a repeat of 2007/8)

*Unending and extremely costly (in lives & $$$) wars for corporate profit.

*Privatized everything

*Off shore oil drilling (WTF??)

*Minimum wage jobs that don't provide a living wage, and with our manufacturing jobs leaving & college out of reach for the majority, minimum wage is all that is left for the majority.)

*BigAg wiping out small farms & destroying ecosystems & bats, bees, butterflies, birds.

& so on.

What are we voting FOR when we vote for Democrats these days?

ecstatic

(32,681 posts)
7. I'm more of an observer, but this: "Bernie supporters are genuinely on the Left, unquestionably
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:36 AM
Mar 2016

Liberals and Progressives" isn't true when you factor in all the threats of not voting for the Democratic nominee.

I know there are a lot of sincere progressives who support both candidates. But anyone who can't connect the dots between getting liberal policies passed and the reality of the next president nominating up to 4 Supreme Court justices is not liberal, progressive, or left. They might be closer to libertarians and anarchists?

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
9. My guess is that Clinton will appoint justices that are liberal on social issues
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:48 AM
Mar 2016

but way more conservative than Scalia on individual rights, executive power, and government power. I hope I am wrong.

 

Chan790

(20,176 posts)
19. I'm just going to say what I said in 2012 and 2008 and 2004.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:57 AM
Mar 2016
"There's never going to be a good Presidential electoral cycle to withhold our votes from the increasingly-right-wing Democratic candidates to make it clear that we know and no longer accept that they have, factually, divorced and lost the Democratic party base. They do however know this, don't care, and believe they have us captive to their selling-out of us for personal gain.

The American center-left and left is a hostage in its own party and will remain so until they realize, much like the end of Fight Club, that they're the ones holding the gun in their own mouth.


So, it is what it is, we are where we are...and there's a real chance this is the election when the American left decides to pull the trigger and spatter the electability of fake Democrats all over the floor, then watch out the window as the false American political landscape explodes to the atonal opening notes, lone guitar riff, and chirpy vocals of Black Francis on Where is my mind? by The Pixies.



You see doom. I see a beautiful metaphor for our liberation from the likes of Hillary and the saving of the Democratic party by those brave enough to act sanely in the face of mounting insanity and our own oppresson. They're the heroes of the Democratic party, not anarchists or libertarians...they're the only sane ones left in the tent because when they were children, their mothers read them The Lorax by Dr. Seuss and they remember:



Caring makes acting necessary. The consequences of caring lies with our enemies, including the malign right inside the Democratic party. If Hillary loses and we end up with President Trump...it will be the faults of her supporters for being allies and backers of a political hostage-taker. All the left would be doing is acting in self-defense by blowing-up her Presidential aspirations.

dana_b

(11,546 posts)
52. Bravo!! Best post here and
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:57 AM
Mar 2016

it explains (very eloquently and with great graphics!) how I and many of us feel. Thanks!!

A Simple Game

(9,214 posts)
26. And anyone that holds the treat of the Supreme Court over others heads to garner support
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:28 AM
Mar 2016

for someone that is not liberal is no liberal themselves. Qualification for the job comes before who they may or may not appoint to the Supreme Court. Voting for an unqualified candidate because of who they may appoint is foolish.

Voting for the lesser of two evils is still voting for evil.

The best bet is to vote for the best candidate for the job regardless of party, or lack of party, that is the only way the best candidate wins, vote for them.

Human race comes first, then family, friends, then America, there is no place for party. Certainly not party before Country.

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
36. But what has Clinton ever done
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:53 AM
Mar 2016

in the past that is "liberal"?

I can't think of any past evidence or a reason of any kind --why Liberals should go with her. (I am definitely not interested in "first woman president" stuff).

If you can think of even one reason, please post it.

mark67

(196 posts)
13. Where do I sign up for your purity test?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:29 AM
Mar 2016

Center-right, center-left, centrist, hard left, hard right. What difference does it make? The stakes are too high this election cycle for the Democratic Party to make these types of distinctions.

If Sanders gets the nomination I will vote for Sanders. If Clinton gets the nomination I will vote for Clinton.

Watching the Kerry-Dean-Gore campaigns go down in flames (and the Nader campaign contribute to putting W. in the White House...yeah the Green Party...those guys were politically pure) have pushed me into the Clinton arena.

These discussions are interesting but the poster above who put Clinton in the same category as W.? (scratching head)

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
37. Sorry but that horse left the barn in the last few years
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:55 AM
Mar 2016

We MUST make the distinction.

We have two conservative parties in the US now.

I want real democracy.

pengu

(462 posts)
63. I'm tired of NOT making the distinction
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:17 AM
Mar 2016

NOT making the distinction has lead us to this point. NOT making the distinction has let the party drift ever rightward. NOT making the distinction means lefties will never, ever make progress.

It is the PERFECT time to make the distinction.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
18. Efforts to place a self avowed Socialist smack dab in the center of the Democratic Party is farcical
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:55 AM
Mar 2016

I watched last night as Sanders was asked how he will get his far flung proposals through Congress. His response was to go on a tirade about how Congress represents the establishment and he's anti-Establishment. He's a radical Leftist.

Red Knight

(704 posts)
22. If Bernie is a "radical" leftist to anyone in this party...
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:58 AM
Mar 2016

then the party is over.

Fortunately there are enough true Democrats left who will continue to fight for the soul of the party.

You know--from the radical right.

SylviaD

(721 posts)
23. Sanders is a fringe candidate, always will be.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:00 AM
Mar 2016

He has inspired people, but he isn't the one to take on the likes of Donald Trump or Ted Cruz.

 

The Far Left

(59 posts)
31. We Need Another FDR Revolution
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:47 AM
Mar 2016

As this Primary has progressed, I have learned that Hillary Clinton will never be like FDR.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Bill_of_Rights

'The Second Bill of Rights is a list of rights that was proposed by U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt during his State of the Union Address on January 11, 1944.[1] In his address Roosevelt suggested that the nation had come to recognize, and should now implement, a second "bill of rights". Roosevelt's argument was that the "political rights" guaranteed by the US Constitution and the Bill of Rights had "proved inadequate to assure us equality in the pursuit of happiness." Roosevelt's remedy was to declare an "economic bill of rights" which would guarantee eight specific rights:'

Employment (right to work)
Food, clothing and leisure, via enough income to support them
Farmers' rights to a fair income
Freedom from unfair competition and monopolies
Housing
Medical care
Social security
Education

'Roosevelt stated that having these rights would guarantee American security, and that the United States' place in the world depended upon how far these and similar rights had been carried into practice.'

INdemo

(6,994 posts)
33. If you want to see one those mentioned take the oath of office
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:48 AM
Mar 2016

than nominate Hillary..Hillary may have thousands of supporters in the (Corporate Media for now)DU.The Southern States,and States the Corporations have bought for her but DWS will have no influence or dirty tricks to play in the National Election.



BlueMTexpat

(15,366 posts)
25. What a condescending and patronizing
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:25 AM
Mar 2016

question! I. Am. A. Democrat. Hillary. Is. My. Candidate.

You don't know me or my life experience. If you did, you would feel ashamed of yourself for asking such a thing. That is, if you are capable of felling shame.

I am sure that you already have your own idea of the political purity test that I should meet. As a wild outside guess, it would entail my immediately feeling the Bern.

We have two excellent candidates. Many good people support each candidate for various reasons. A "label" - as perceived by someone who supports one candidate or the other - is not the reason.

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
39. We have two candidates
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:01 AM
Mar 2016

One has sold out, hijacked by big money interests --and the other has been ridiculed and marginalized for exposing the truth. One is a corporatist, one is a populist. One will work for business interests, one will work for the good of the whole.

Pick one.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
29. Bernie Supporters - Honest Question - Are you actually a Democrat?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:39 AM
Mar 2016

Bernie Sanders was not a Democrat for almost all of his political life. He has stood outside of the party for decades. He has said: "The fact that I am not a Democrat gives me the freedom to speak out on the floor of the House" and more succinctly "I am not a Democrat and have no intention of become one."

So the real question then is do you, as Bernie supporters, view yourselves as Democrats?

Thanks

 

The Far Left

(59 posts)
56. Bernie is not a corporate surrogate.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:00 AM
Mar 2016

Is it possible for the Democratic policy positions to shift so far to the right that they no longer represent the original Democratic Party?

What if the current DNC leadership acts like moderate corporate Republicans? What then would define a real Democrat?

Are you best defined by your logo, or by the policies you promote?

Bernie is the real deal. He is not a corporate surrogate. Bernie is an FDR Democrat. He's the type of Democrat that made America the greatest nation on Earth.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
60. The original Democratic party?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:13 AM
Mar 2016

I don't think any of us would want to go back to the original Democratic party, do you?

Let me ask you a question: when did this shift to the right begin? At what point was the Democratic Party not the way you categorize it now? What decade are you talking about as being the last time the Democratic Party was what you would have it be?

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
40. The Democratic party has gone so far to the right
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:05 AM
Mar 2016

in the last decades--how do you expect anybody who is NOT conservative to support them any more?

After 30 years of supporting the Democratic party, I am no longer happy to do so unless there is change in the party. Enough.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
41. Bernie Sanders was not a Democrat three decades ago
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:16 AM
Mar 2016

He had been an Independent for over three decades until recently.

This was presumably during the time when you supported the Democratic party.

marions ghost

(19,841 posts)
47. I'm beyond labels at this point
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:43 AM
Mar 2016

He has always been a Liberal (Social Democrat) or whatever label you wish to call the Democratic wing of the Democratic party. I stand for what he stands for.

I want real democracy in America. Not corporatocracy.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
48. Bernie Sanders: "I’m not a liberal. Never have been"
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:48 AM
Mar 2016

He has said that on more than one occasion. Here's the most recent:

http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/12/upshot/class-or-ideology-my-conversation-with-bernie-sanders.html?_r=0

The OP is about labels - my question was really meant in response to the question framed in the OP which I found to be ridiculous.

Personally, I think Bernie and Hillary are both great.

Svafa

(594 posts)
88. "Liberal" comes weighted with a lot of connotations.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:03 PM
Mar 2016

I never use the term "liberal" to describe myself (opting for "progressive" instead), because the word liberal can be used to describe anyone left of center politically, but it also carries the baggage of economic liberalism (e.g., neoliberalism), which is the polar opposite of what many progressives (who may call themselves liberal without knowing about the murkiness of the term) stand for.

Economic liberalization is the lessening of government regulations and restrictions in an economy in exchange for greater participation by private entities; the doctrine is associated with classical liberalism.


If we're speaking about economic liberalism, I am proud to support a candidate who does not identify as liberal.

pengu

(462 posts)
64. The number appears vanishingly small
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:18 AM
Mar 2016

The center right has nearly the entire party structure at this point.

casperthegm

(643 posts)
67. I'm your huckleberry
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:24 AM
Mar 2016

I am a registered democrat and my ideals more closely align with them. It's funny how some people are quick to point out that Sanders was registered as an independent (like that's a bad thing) while not mentioning that HRC was actually a republican at one point, then a moderate democrat, then supposedly progressive. In the end, I could care less about party affiliation. What matters is the person. Who they are, what they've done, and what they stand for. I'm not going to be a sheep and just "support the party." If that puts me at odds with an increasing right of center democratic party, then so be it.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
72. Understood
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:40 AM
Mar 2016

I was really just posing this question as a parody of the question in the OP - which I find to be silly.

Martin Eden

(12,863 posts)
35. "this result has caused the republican party to go even more to-the-right"
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 08:50 AM
Mar 2016

I disagree with that conclusion. While I concur it's evident both parties have shifted to the right, I don't think it's a matter of the shifting of the Democratic Party pushing the R's further right.

The D party has shifted further to the right because it's increasingly beholden to corporate money, and the DNC takes progressive voters for granted because in a two-party system what other viable choice do we have? Also, to some degree, the rightward shift of the R party is dragging the D along with it in an effort to capture the center.

The R party has shifted to the right because they've crafted a rightwing ideology to manipulate and hold onto their voting base. Decades of Faux news and talk radio have relentlessly pounded home an ideology tying Christian identity politics to trickle down economics and jingoistic patriotism. They've convinced people their religion is under assault and their country is being taken over by muslims, immigrants, sexual deviants, socialists, and libruls.

All of this has shifted the center rightward. The Democratic Party leadership and prominent politicians like Hillary Clinton are part of that shift, and they've carried a big chunk of Democratic voters along for the ride. I think most of them aren't any more aware of this shift than the proverbial frog in a slowly warming (and eventually boiling) pot of water.

Martin Eden

(12,863 posts)
65. It began in earnest with the "Reagan Democrats"
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:21 AM
Mar 2016

FDR set the standard for what you refer to as the "Left Wing" Democratic Party. LBJ carried that forward, and George McGovern was the last "Left wing" candidate to win the party's nomination.

There are no absolutes and most things are a matter of degree. Every candidate is a bit of a mixed bag, and even establishment corporate Democrats like Hillary Clinton embrace some "Left wing" policies. But the trend has definitely been rightward. Bill Clinton with his Third Way triangulation was a big part of that shift. Hillary has had to craft her rhetoric to appeal to the Left in this primary battle, but she remains very much an establishment neoliberal Democrat tied to Wall Street.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
73. So the Democratic Party has been right wing since after McGovern?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:42 AM
Mar 2016

That's a really long time.

My personal view is that Hillary and Bernie are actually pretty similar on most issues especially in relation to the positions of the Republicans.

Martin Eden

(12,863 posts)
75. "right wing"
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 11:23 AM
Mar 2016

Not sure what you mean by that.

As I said, there are no absolutes; everything is relative. The D party has been shifting rightward since Reagan. I don't think that constitutes "right wing" relative to the "center" as defined in 1980, but it's steadily shifted to the right of FDR/LBJ/McGovern. The economic game has been rigged in favor of the wealthiest, and that isn't solely the product of Republicans ramming through trade agreements and tax codes. D's are complicit. Big Money has a big influence with the legalized bribery in our electoral system. They're too smart to be caught in quid pro quo, but anyone who thinks nothing is expected in return for the large sums they give to political campaigns (or for paid speeches) is astoundingly naïve.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
81. Right of center
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 01:09 PM
Mar 2016

So you think the Democratic party under President Obama is further to the right than the Democratic party was under President Clinton?

Martin Eden

(12,863 posts)
82. I don't think Obama is to the right of Bill Clinton, tho he's far from the progressive we hoped for
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 02:33 PM
Mar 2016

... and Hillary is definitely to the right of Obama. I think the party overall has drifted to the right in the complicity I pointed out in my last post. In the 2014 midterms many Dem candidates tried their best to distance themselves from Obama, and were soundly defeated at the polls. Voters on the Left stayed away in droves, and Republican-lite candidates won't steal many votes from the real thing.

DWS chairing the DNC does not indicate any change in that direction.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
87. So you think we have a more left-wing president than the 1990s but a more right-wing party?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:02 PM
Mar 2016

Based on the recent Congressional election results?

Martin Eden

(12,863 posts)
96. I wouldn't call Obama Left Wing.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 07:12 PM
Mar 2016

The Democratic National Committee and those they work to nominate have, overall, shifted to the right over the last 35+ years.

 

beachbum bob

(10,437 posts)
49. I worked on obama campaigns starting with his senate run....
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:50 AM
Mar 2016

I am a progressive liberal democrat thats been involved in politics for over 45 years and expect to remain so...and I support Hillary because she is a leader and has faced the devil time and time again.....no conscientious objector or pacifist in her nature...I see her as the candidate BEST to WIN in the general election by overwhelming margins in spite of sanders supporters constant threats of not supporting her....if they hate america that much to let conservatives have the run of it....I feel sorry for them

has nothing to do with center-right...center-left...left....or whatever ....if you want conservatives to screw our world up more....you can.....I will not

RiverLover

(7,830 posts)
51. What 2 presidents wanted to cut Social Security?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:54 AM
Mar 2016

Clinton1 (who also wanted to privatize it)

Obama (with Chained CPI)

**************

But republicans stopped them. How backasswards is THAT?

Just one example.

We are against Hillary because she IS conservative. But like Clinton1 & Obama, she is running as a progressive.

This has to stop.

Demsrule86

(68,549 posts)
50. Are you kidding?
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:54 AM
Mar 2016

I am a liberal...as liberal as Bernie Sanders. I also see the Supreme Court is being the most important thing because unless we get back the Congress nothing else can be accomplished. I think we have a good shot at the Senate...really great young liberal running here in Ohio...but I would vote for Strickland should he win the primary. Why? he may be blue dogish but he is a Democrat and would shift the Senate to the Democrats. These are the things we need to think of...I do not believe Bernie can win. There is a reason one of the Koch brothers wrote an oped praising Bernie and that the right has attacked Hillary non-stop...she can win, and we need her to...she is probably less liberal than I am...so was pres. Obama but I would take him over McCain or Romney any day. Should the GOP get in ...you can kiss social security goodbye as well as medicare...and a woman's right to choose and count on war as well as dirty drinking water. All you Bernie folks attacking Hillary are only helping the Republicans.

DemocratSinceBirth

(99,710 posts)
53. Idealism and pragmatism are not mutually exclusive
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:58 AM
Mar 2016

Idealism and pragmatism are not mutually exclusive and a reasonable adult doesn't let one be the enemy of the other.

Loki

(3,825 posts)
54. I'm not into labels
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:58 AM
Mar 2016

but I do know that I'm not a right wing, racist bigot. How's that for an answer? I'm a Democrat and that encompasses quite a bit of territory.

Nye Bevan

(25,406 posts)
55. I stand with President Obama on most issues,
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 09:59 AM
Mar 2016

except that I strongly oppose the death penalty and support decriminalization of drugs. And on Citizens United I stand with the ACLU. Does that make me "center right"?

Bobbie Jo

(14,341 posts)
59. Pfffffffft...
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:11 AM
Mar 2016

I'm a Hillary supporter, and I'll put my liberal creds up against ANYONE here, ANY TIME.

What a self-righteous, disingenuous crock.

So tired of this "holier than thou" nonsense.

Response to Bobbie Jo (Reply #59)

 

WhaTHellsgoingonhere

(5,252 posts)
66. Nope, they're all Progressives. Dumb war hawkish, Wall Street/banksters friendly, bad trade deal...
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:23 AM
Mar 2016

Progressives. It's a mouthful to say, so they shorten it to Progressive. If they were right of center, they would proudly claim they are Third Wayers: Republicans who got the social issues right.

 

MaggieD

(7,393 posts)
68. No, I'm a liberal who believes in capitalism
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:27 AM
Mar 2016

And I don't consider Clinton to be a centrist by any means. I guess every Dem politician is a centrist if you're comparing it to socialism. But that's the wrong metric. Clinton's actual record is quite liberal. More liberal than Obama and Bill, in fact.

 

forjusticethunders

(1,151 posts)
83. The thing is that America is so far to the right
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 02:48 PM
Mar 2016

That what is right wing in most of the world is "center-left" here.

 

boythayer

(14 posts)
71. I think they view themselves as Hillary supporters
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 10:31 AM
Mar 2016

first and foremost, and if Hillary were more progressive than the candidate she was running against, they would be debating from that POV

everything I have read and heard is that it seems to be more about Hillary than any ideology or movement they back.

Nonhlanhla

(2,074 posts)
90. This is absolute nonsense
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 06:05 PM
Mar 2016

There are several of us who were Obama supporters in 2008 - it obviously wasn't about Hillary then.

I find it ironic that any Bernie supporter would even say this, given the way many here have given godlike status to Bernie.

 

Adrahil

(13,340 posts)
76. What do you consider "Center Right?"
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 11:33 AM
Mar 2016

My Republican relatives think I'm a communist.

Some here think I'm a little to the right of Gen Franco.

I support civil rights and affirmative action. I oppose "reparations" and support programs to remediate impoverished black communities.

I support aggressive progressive taxation. I support massive investment in infrastructure and public support of science (like increasing NASA's budget 10-fold.

I support a transformative education system with high-quality trade education.

I support universal health coverage (with very low out-of-pocket)

I support massive investments in green energy and aggressive carbon taxes.

I favor a strong national defense (though with less money in it than now), and less foreign intervention (though I do support assisting allies, when appropriate)

I support public funding of the arts.

I'm not much worried about labels, but I certainly don't see any Republicans that share my positions.

hack89

(39,171 posts)
77. I have extremely progressive social views
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 11:36 AM
Mar 2016

pro-choice, marriage and gender equality for example. But I am pro-military (being a retired Navy vet) and pro-2A. So you tell me what that means.

Nonhlanhla

(2,074 posts)
84. What a presumptive question
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 02:51 PM
Mar 2016

Why do Bernie supporters assume that Hillary supporters are uninformed/suffering from Stockholm Syndrome/closet conservatives, whatever?

Bernie supporters are not all alike. He draws from Green Party types to former Rand Paul fans.

Hillary supporters are not alike either. Her coalition is pretty broad. In fact, broader than Sanders since she gets more ethnic/racial minority support.

As for me, I'm pretty progressive.
I'm pro-choice.
Anti-gun and pro-gun control.
Pro gay rights and marriage equality.
Separation of church and state.
Welcoming of minority religions.
Vehemently anti-racism
Strongly feminist.
I don't like war, and find Hillary too hawkish for my taste, and Bernie too uninformed on foreign affairs.
I believe that income inequality is a big issue. I don't believe Bernie will be able to do much about it, since I think he is not nuanced enough in his perspectives. His vote against TARP, for example, while ideologically pure, suggests a level of irresponsibility for the real-life consequences of an economy in free fall, that is almost on par with Ted Cruz's irresponsible shutdown of government (I'm not saying he's otherwise as bad as Cruz). I would like to see single payer healthcare, but I think it is too late in history - it should have been started after WWII. Given the complexities of healthcare these days, the fact that the healthcare industry is a huge employer, and the political realities of this nation, I believe that Hillary's incremental approach to achieving universal healthcare is more realistic. Many other countries achieve universal healthcare through systems similar to the ACA, so it's doable, and probably more realistic.

Starry Messenger

(32,342 posts)
85. A lot of Bernie supporters are very pro-charter school.
Mon Mar 7, 2016, 02:51 PM
Mar 2016

Some have trashed unions. I find there are all kinds of conservative views among a broad spectrum of both candidates' supporters. Not everyone supports someone because all of their views line up with a candidate.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Hillary Supporters - Hone...