2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumBernie Sanders? Who is Bernie Sanders?
Bernie Sanders, Senator from Vermont, virtually unknown, has received nearly 9 million primary votes to date, that's who he is!
This is astounding. That his messages resonated with nearly 9 million people. The importance of this can not, and must not be left at the curb.
Hillary Clinton is known world wide. She is the most well-known woman in American politics.
To date, she is only 3 million popular votes ahead of Sanders. This is astounding. This is meaningful that she did not stop him, the unknown, in his tracks earlier in the primary season.
Bernie Sanders, the unknown, did not and does not have the support of many progressive Democrats, like Sen Sharrod Brown - very few to no nationally known progressives have taken the stage to stand in solidarity with Sanders and his message because the Clinton's spent their life time doing political favors, rasing money and collecting political chits to cash in for a Hillary Clinton presidency. Senators like Brown owe the Clintons. This is a simple and true fact.
Elizabeth Warren did not show up for Sanders, not because he and his message isn't valid or worthy, but because she blinked. Hedge for one second...and the moment is lost.
Who will step into Bernie Sanders shoes and lift the movement to their shoulders to carry it on?
That person will need to introduce themselves to the American primary voter, Sanders at their side.
While I am heart broken Sanders has not catapulted over Clinton, I am hopeful that this is time the progressive movement will not wither away...like it did with McGovern and the death of Bobby Kennedy...
Please tell me you are with me and won't go away...please tell me you are in it for the duration.
Punkingal
(9,522 posts)Those are just the ones who got to vote for him so far.
Ninga
(8,272 posts)establishment.
Punkingal
(9,522 posts)And I will know for the rest of my life it is the best vote I ever made in 65 years of living.
Ninga
(8,272 posts)and I will get to celebrate such a vote in the near future.
2banon
(7,321 posts)When the largest populated state in the union finally has our voice. Yes California is in the bag of HRC but there's a hell of a lot of Bernie supporters here.
BernieforPres2016
(3,017 posts)Add in independent voters plus more voters in the caucus states and Bernie would have millions of more votes.
Kip Humphrey
(4,753 posts)Armstead
(47,803 posts)Ninga
(8,272 posts)progressive movement.
Punkingal
(9,522 posts)2banon
(7,321 posts)DU might diss us, they are after all working on behalf of Hillary and the DLC, but DU isn't the be all of our movement.
Take Heart, and stay strong!
In Solidarity!
djean111
(14,255 posts)And - I am out of the Democratic Party, if Hillary is the nominee.
Too right-wing for me, can't do it.
The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,573 posts)I always figured Bernie was a long shot so I'm not surprised at the outcome, especially considering how the odious DWS put her heavy thumb on the DNC's scale. I'm delighted that he exceeded everybody's expectations and regardless of what happens after this, he proved there are an awful lot of people who don't want more of the same old, same old that we've been getting from what's left of the Democratic Party. The only positive thing I can think of to say about Hillary is that she's not as bad as Donald Trump. If the GOP had been able to nominate somebody who is not criminally insane Hillary would get trampled in the GE; it's only the rank awfulness of Trump that can save her. Isn't it pathetic that each party is set to nominate a candidate who is deeply unpopular?
But onward and upward, regardless. It takes a long time to build a movement, and I hope the people who are disappointed that we're stuck with yet another tool of the financial industry won't give up; that there will be a unified effort to support progressive candidates at the state and local levels (all politics is local), and eventually push the Third-Wayers onto the scrap heap of history where they belong.
I'm sure as heck done with DU if it turns into an echo chamber for Hillary.
Ninga
(8,272 posts)I intend to be vocal in a fact based concrete manner, if required, to underscore the conservative elements in Clinton's programs.
BernieforPres2016
(3,017 posts)Just like they knocked off progressive Senate candidates yesterday in PA and MD.
http://www.cnn.com/2016/04/26/politics/pennsylvania-democratic-senate-primary-joe-sestak-katie-mcginty/
<The Democratic establishment struck back Tuesday with major victories in the Maryland and Pennsylvania Senate primaries, showing the strength of the party leadership over the liberal base.
Nowhere was that clearer than in Pennsylvania, with a furious effort stretching from the White House to local party leaders who sought to prop up Democrat Katie McGinty, who was struggling in the polls just a few weeks ago.
But with millions poured over the airwaves by the Senate Democrats' campaign arm, and Joe Biden stumping alongside McGinty in recent days, the Democratic establishment helped McGinty secure a victory over a man party leaders have long viewed as a persistent agitator: former Rep. Joe Sestak. McGinty, a former chief of staff to Gov. Tom Wolf, will now face off against first-term GOP Sen. Pat Toomey -- in one of the country's most high profile Senate races.
"Katie McGinty has the best chance of beating Toomey -- we always felt that way," said Sen. Chuck Schumer, the likely next Democratic leader who helped recruit McGinty to run against Sestak. "We want to beat him.">
The Velveteen Ocelot
(115,573 posts)The establishment candidates have the money and the support of the party. And sometimes even when you think you've managed to elect a good progressive, once they get elected suddenly they aren't so progressive any more - the need for constant fund-raising and the pressure from TPTB gets to them. Exhibit A: Al Franken.
BernieforPres2016
(3,017 posts)Both major parties are too addicted to corporate and top 0.1% money, not just for getting elected, but for the financially lucrative revolving door to lobbying, Wall Street, etc. that it has opened up to them. I think we'll be seeing fewer career politicians. There is too much money available by turning a stint in politics into big bucks afterwards. People like Dick Gephardt and Tom Daschle are making far more money and have a much easier lifestyle now working as lobbyists than they did as politicians. No fundraising, no campaigning, no commuting between DC and their home states. Sell out and cash in. That's the new name of the game.
428 former members of Congress are now lobbyists:
https://www.opensecrets.org/revolving/top.php?display=Z
A chart on Government Sachs from a few years back (and you could do one on Citigroup in the Obama administration):
http://www.muckety.com/897792228FFFA019E542A0A86226FE6D.map
Ninga
(8,272 posts)conservative mantle...making it Bill Clinton's legacy.
mindwalker_i
(4,407 posts)Now there are two republicans/corporatists running for prez, after a thoroughly fucked up primary, followed by "Get in line _____."
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)... I like that it's forward looking and reflective and shows optimism.
My only recommendations would be that it be an actual Democrat without the baggage and stigma that Bernie's vanity label of "socialist" carries with it. Someone younger would be to their advantage, and someone with a less angry demeanor, and someone that doesn't despise or resent the party, and who sees the value of down-ticket competitiveness, and in getting people to register properly. That should get the ball rolling.
rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)You've essentially told us to sit down and shut up. Now you are mocking us by insinuations like "getting people to register properly". Like all the many voter discrepancies that favored Clinton were the fault of people not getting registered properly.
I can't speak for all progressives but I am not buying your condensation. I will fight you and the Oligarchy you revere so deeply.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)It's your choice.
Because with your 6-to-1 majority at this site, the Bernie supporters have been so put-upon. And so many Bernie supporters have been juried into forced-time-outs with the lopsided Hillary-favoring juries.
You can either learn from the campaign's mistakes or ignore them. It's not like you haven't been told or experienced the consequences for inaction and poor planning. I don't care.
So does that mean we should put you down as a "no" in helping Hillary to defeat the GOP nominee?
Okay.
forjusticethunders
(1,151 posts)If we parse this poll, we see that Hispanics are split, and black people support the concept, and this was 5 years ago. Socialism is also net positive among young people.
In short, the base of the party sees socialism favorably. Maybe not enough for one to win the general against a candidate that isn't Trump/Cruz, but it isn't the anchor it would have been even in 00.
Bernie lost for a bunch of reasons. I don't think him calling himself a "Socialist" was one of them.
I agree with the rest though.
NurseJackie
(42,862 posts)forjusticethunders
(1,151 posts)Slapping a hammer and sickle on Obama's head didn't work but it may work with someone who embraces the word "Socialist". I'd like to think it wouldn't though, at least not outside people who wouldn't vote for this hypothetical progressive candidate to start with.
Ninga
(8,272 posts)that in spite of who he is, that his message was embraced and understood by millions, and many more to come. This is very meaningful and should foreshadow an huge opening for the progressive movement
CrispyQ
(36,413 posts)The problem is that too many people only participate in the process during a presidential year. I have friends who would never miss a presidential election but never vote the mid-terms. Some of them can't even name our state's senators.
rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)oldandhappy
(6,719 posts)I want to see this keep happening. I know things take time. But we need to get started. We need to be grooming and nurturing young progressives to move into local positions and be ready to take on county and state positions. We need to build!
Orsino
(37,428 posts)...and he might not be a great speaker, but his message obviously resonated with those left out of the new economy. He has executed well and performed superbly at just about every step, but that was the minimum requirement for remaining in the race against a celebrity with the kind of enormous easy money he deliberately swore off.
Yeah, he handicapped his own campaign, but that choice is what made him so attractive to so many. He hasn't been bought, or not nearly so completely as as every opponent has been. He's not proceeding according to the playbook, and that drives the party leadership BUGFUCK. Everything Clinton does easily, he has had to do backwards in high heels, and he is much loved for it.
Winning now would be great, but I think Sanders is just the first major figure of a revolution just now gaining visibility. The need is growing.
aikoaiko
(34,160 posts)Bernie's campaign platform, on the other hand, attracted a coalition of those who didn't want the status quo. This coalition nearly overtook the presumed candidate.
Jitter65
(3,089 posts)Running on the issues is what he should have been doing all along instead of reaching back into the administration of Bill Clinton for fodder to use against Hillary. We all have a chance to get over that now but it looks like few are willing to.
aikoaiko
(34,160 posts)HRC was an active politician (albeit unelected) during Bill's presidency and she appeals to her politics from that time period in her own campaign.
Bernie has been very focused on issues.
There is no getting over HRC's past. I might have to be quiet about it from June to November, but the issues will resurface.
ThePhilosopher04
(1,732 posts)Just think if our election process wasn't a sham and the true will of the voters was allowed to shine through. The clock is ticking on the establishment, however. They are getting very nervous.
northernsouthern
(1,511 posts)warrprayer
(4,734 posts)it's not a choice, it's life and death.
happynewyear
(1,724 posts)livetohike
(22,118 posts)Fetterman came in third here in PA's Senate race. He was an early Sanders endorser. Sanders has no coat tails.
Kittycat
(10,493 posts)And not all state races are done.
femmedem
(8,196 posts)Uncle Joe
(58,268 posts)Thanks for the thread, Ninga.
Ninga
(8,272 posts)Uncle Joe
(58,268 posts)Bernie's impact on the American Electorate has legs, it will be felt for decades.
Peace to you.