2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumTHE NATION: Bernie Sanders Is Hurting Himself by Playing the Victim
The Vermont senator could turn from movement leader into the messiah of an angry white male cult with his claims of a rigged nomination process. ts been five days since the conflagration at the Nevada State Democratic Convention, and the embers are still burning. Much of it has singed Senator Bernie Sanders. The intimidation of speakers and the misogynist death threats against party chair Roberta Lange have led to a wave of critical pieces by Bernie supporterssome of them now former Bernie supporters. Sanderss loyal CNN backer Sally Kohn wrote in Time: I Felt the Bern But the Bros Are Extinguishing the Flames. Esquires Charles Pierce, who voted for Sanders, weighed in Tuesday: Its Time for Bernies People to Calm Down. Sanders supporter Harold Meyerson now insists, The Bros Are Undermining Bernie.
In the pages of the Sanders fanzine Salon (for which I used to work), at least two Bernie supporters have written that its over: For them, the mayhem in Las Vegas has doused the burn. Even on Sanders-friendly Reddit, former Berners were leaving the fold. Much of the media has reacted with shock to the Nevada chaos, and Sanders surrogates have faced tougher grilling on cable news than they have for the entire campaign.
But the Sanders camp is defiant, with the senator himself condemning the threats and reports of violence, butand you never add but to a sentence thats condemning threatening behaviorinsisting party leaders had it coming, because convention rules were less than fair or transparent. Sanders has continued to rip the Democratic Party for unfairness, and his supporters are now telling reporters there will be trouble at the convention in Philadelphia over the rigged primary process.....Let me stipulate that the Democratic establishment isnt blameless in this mess. I understand the anger and even fear of Nevada Democrats, but the local partys letter to the DNC charging that theres a penchant for violence in the Sanders campaign was histrionic and only escalated the conflict. I get it: After Clinton supporters were forced to walk a gauntlet of shame in East Los Angeles, screamed at by angry Sandernistas with bullhorns who even bullied children; after protesters crowded Clintons car on the way to a fundraiser; and now, after Nevada, there is growing concern about an apparent mob mentality that can cross the line into physical harassment, if not violence. But describing a penchant for violence is unfair to the many millions of peaceful, respectful Sanders supporters.
With hindsight, I wish chair Roberta Lange had used her discretion to call for roll-call votes on the contested issuesalthough its common in meetings like that for a chair to use her judgment in evaluating a voice vote, when one side clearly has the edge in numbers, but is out-shouted by the smaller contingent. And once again, Democratic National Committee chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz escalated a conflict that she should have worked to defuse. Repeatedly accused of unfairness by the Sanders campaignnot always with clear evidenceshe has time and again replied harshly and defensively to her critics. When the Sanders campaign sued the DNC in December for briefly locking it out of a party voter filebecause Sanders staffers, who were quickly fired, tried to steal private Clinton voter data during a security breachWasserman Schultz took the lead in defending herself. Even Governor Howard Dean, a former DNC chair who normally defends his successor in public, suggested she should have left the defense to surrogates and waited for the results of the DNCs own investigation......Weve also seen some real injustice along the way to the nomination: more than 100,000 voters wrongly purged in Brooklyn; polling places shut down in Phoenix, Arizona. But both were the work of local election officialsand in Phoenix, a Republicannot the national party. Other Sanders complaints are specious: You dont have to like closed primaries, but they were established long before Sanders came along, and acting like they disenfranchise his independent or non-aligned voters is an insult to the mostly African-American and poor people who are truly disenfranchised in this country. Still, several states, including New York, make it ridiculously hard to change your registration and become a Democrat. Theres plenty of room for reform to make the party more inclusive.
All of that said: The Sanders campaign has less than a leg to stand on in its Nevada protests. Politifact fact-checked campaign manager Jeff Weavers claim that the state party hijacked the process on the floor of the convention ignoring the regular procedure and ramming through what they wanted to do. After an exhaustive examination of the long day of skirmishes, it found Weavers claim to be false.
The defections of some supporters, the increased skepticism of even once-friendly cable hosts, and a rebuke by Politifact isnt fatal to Sanderss campaign, of course. What will be fatal to Sanderss future as a mass-movement leaderas opposed to the messiah of an angry, heavily white, and male cultis his continued insistence that his enemy now is not so much the corporate overlords, or income inequality, or the big banks, but a corrupt Democratic Party, epitomized by Wall Street flunkie Hillary Clinton, that has rigged the election to thwart himas he raged in a tone-deaf speech Tuesday night, as cable news was showing the texted death threats to Roberta Lange in the background (which Sanders did not even mention)..... He thinks hes the only one who can defeat Donald Trump. But in fact, hes the only one who can elect him, by tearing the party apart.
More at link: http://www.thenation.com/article/bernie-sanders-is-hurting-himself-by-playing-the-victim/
obamanut2012
(26,061 posts)wallyworld2
(375 posts)Charlotte Ritchie says:
May 19, 2016 at 2:31 pm
This article is filled with so many specious allegations that it's difficult to know where to start, but first of all, the author caricatures Bernie's candidacy and followers as "bros," "heavily white and male," when in fact Bernie has built a vast and diverse coalition of supporters that is representative of this country. He is the only candidate who is currently shining a bright light on some of the profound suffering in many Native American communities across the land.
The implication that Bernie passively condones violence is just part of a huge smear campaign that the Democratic Establishment, in collusion with the corporate media (WaPo, NYT, MSNBC, CNN) is perpetrating to knock him down in the weeks before the all important California primaries; it's no surprise that CA's two senators, Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer were on the airwaves yesterday spewing faux outrage over everything related to Bernie. Where is mention of high profile Clinton supporter, actor Wendell Pierce, who was arrested for bashing a female Sanders supporter in the head, in Atlanta? Where, Joan Walsh, is your outrage over that? Nowhere in this piece is the congratulations Bernie earned by sweeping the Oregon primary by 12% (56-44%). Nowhere mentioned is the fact that many of Bernie's top surrogates are people like African American former Ohio State Senator Nina Turner, actor Danny Glover, Bernie's African American press secretary Symone Sanders, and others too numerous to count. Bernie is currently ahead of Hillary in the Latino vote, and has many high profile surrogates in that community working hard on his behalf. So the suggestion that somehow he is leading a movement of angry, violent prone white males is just insulting, and very poor journalism. It's a hit piece.
Joan Walsh ends by saying: Bernie "thinks hes the only one who can defeat Donald Trump. But in fact, hes the only one who can elect him, by tearing the party apart." This is so far from the truth. Bernie has treated Clinton respectfully and has only pointed out the truths that should indeed haunt her campaign: She is hawkish, and nobody disputes that (Iraq war vote, Libya, Honduras etc). She took in some $22 million in speeches to Wall Street and other industry behemoths, between her term as S.O.S. and when she announced her candidacy. She says she didn't know during that period whether she was going to run, but there is much evidence pointing to the fact that she did indeed know. Apparently Donald Trump has volumes of opposition research from which to draw, compared to which what Bernie has said is a drop in the proverbial bucket. There are hours and hours of Hillary in her own words, available on youtube, for all to see, and Donald will no doubt hit her very hard with all of it and more. So to blame Bernie is disrespectful of this very fine man. This is an unacceptable, distorted and dishonest portrayal of his campaign.
obamanut2012
(26,061 posts)LexVegas
(6,043 posts)Skwmom
(12,685 posts)people and start practicing the words - President Trump.
There are a lot of corporate hacks being exposed this primary season.
Does this ever have the smell of a desperate corporate campaign.
MADem
(135,425 posts)It's THE NATION, you know.
When THE NATION starts getting critical of Sanders, he's got trouble.
ThePhilosopher04
(1,732 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)obamanut2012
(26,061 posts)Calling THE NATION'S writers corporate hacks.
ThePhilosopher04
(1,732 posts)obamanut2012
(26,061 posts)"Corporate Hack" !!!!!!!!!
nc4bo
(17,651 posts)In our primary.
Right out the gate was I'm a woman followed by some words.
Disagree? You're sexist, he's sexist, they're sexist.
There were shenanigans in multiple States so now when there are complaints .....we're victims.
Yup, I see how this works.
msanthrope
(37,549 posts)ThePhilosopher04
(1,732 posts)Mary Mac
(323 posts)But she is capable, nerdy, energetic and idealistic. And wicked smart.
BeyondGeography
(39,367 posts)Number23
(24,544 posts)publications trashing this man this week. Politifact basically said his campaign is full of shit with the "Nevada was rigged" scenario. He only won by 12 in Oregon when he needed a 30+ point blow out to even pretend to stay viable. He lost Kentucky (which given the demographics he should have won easily) and one of his few superdelegates as well.
The man has not had a good week. Not even a little bit.
He thinks hes the only one who can defeat Donald Trump. But in fact, hes the only one who can elect him, by tearing the party apart.
Looks like that bad week is going to be continuing for some time.
wallyworld2
(375 posts)Even Rachel complained about Politifact being the gate keeper of what is true or not
And I have trouble when Hillary supporter, Jeff Bezos' and Washington Post owner say something negative about Bernie.
Political commentators will speculate and dramatize in support of their candidate
That's all they are doing
Throwing made up chairs at made up crisis
Hell Hath No Fury
(16,327 posts)who is, for all intensive purposes, a Clinton surrogate.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Which should tell you something....
frylock
(34,825 posts)anotherproletariat
(1,446 posts)I hope he's not paying them too much.