2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumBernie’s Revolution – Will it be a Movement or a Moment?
Watching the DNC convention, I can see that most of those in attendance are excited and ready to get to work to try to realize one of the most progressive platforms to be adopted by a major U.S. party. The Democratic platform was in large part based on input from Bernie Sanders and his supporters. This is as much his platform as hers.
Yet, there is still a loud, but vocal minority of delegates who more interested in expressing anger and disapproval at the results. Think of Cornell West who was asked to participate in the development of the platform, yet he walks away and endorses the Green Party candidate. Or, you have Nina Turner getting 15 minutes of fame and then some in order to dutifully play the role of a Democrat still on the fence as to who she might support for President. However, expressions of anger without direction, purpose and, most importantly, only serve to make those who are yelling a part of the problem they are complaining about.
The question I wonder is whether Bernies revolution will ultimately be seen as a movement or a moment? Were Bernies supporters invested in his ideals, which have now been incorporated into the partys platform? Or, was Bernie himself simply being used, yes used, by his supporters as a convenient vehicle for expressing rage irrespective of his policies?
Right now. In the midst of a Presidential election with a would-be demagogue running as the Republican candidate, the underlying issues of the election will get overshadowed. The protests themselves often get muddled and create confusion as to what is being advocates as was the case when you had TPP protestors disrupting speeches by Rep. Cummings and Lewis as they addressed the concerns of BLM activists.
However, when it is all said and done, will Bernies movement endure? Will Bernie himself remain engaged and continue to try to work to get progressive Democrats elected? Will Bernies supporters remain invested in pressuring Congress to pass bills that incorporate the Democratic partys platform? Or, will they both retreat, disengage, and complain from the distance in elections to come?
In short, the real measure of whether Bernies revolution is a movement or merely a moment is where will Bernie and his supporters be during the 2018 midterms. That could be the pivotal year where a movement emerges from the background of a Presidential campaign and transforms Congress. In 2010, a CNBC/Fox inspired Tea Party halted the progressive trajectory of the Obama presidency fresh off the adoption of the ACA, saving the U.S. auto industry, creating a consumer protection agency, and adopting the Dodd-Frank act. Can Bernies movement offer a similar change in 2018 albeit in a progressive direction?
MichiganVote
(21,086 posts)RazBerryBeret
(3,075 posts)Bernie has pulled back a curtain in a lot of ways:
Broad acceptance of Democratic Socialism.
Largest ever Grass Roots movement.
Exposure of the DNC.
10 years ago, this would not have happened. he has started something that will continue.
Avalux
(35,015 posts)Millions of others will too. It's going to be a good thing, to ensure Hillary does everything she said on that stage tonight.
With following Bernie on the get out and do something I am seriously thinking about running for city counsel next time a seat comes up. I live in a very red small town in Texas. So not a party affiliation. But figure what the hey. Might do some good.
global1
(25,242 posts)The primary is over. Hillary is the nominee and soon to be President. She killed it tonight with her acceptance speech. And instead of celebrating that you turn your comments to taking down Bernie - who Hillary even gave shout outs to and says she will be working with him. You are just shameless.
tavernier
(12,387 posts)Just ask any senior citizen why
not.
unitedwethrive
(1,997 posts)many had towards that part of the party. The only reason it was as prominent as it was during the convention, is because Bernie conceded so late. Many people predicted this would happen the longer he drew out his campaign after Hillary clinched the domination. It will be just a blip, and only feels bigger than it is right now because of timing.
TomCADem
(17,387 posts)Bernie talked about a self-sustaining movement, but if it turns out that no one is really paying attention, except during the Presidential years, then there is no movement, it is just a moment.
The Tea Party, for example, was most influential during the mid-terms often nominating extremely right wing candidates over preferred establishment candidates. Likewise, given the lower turnout of the mid-terms, Bernie's movement should have the leverage and the energy to promote progressive candidates during the primaries.
Yo_Mama_Been_Loggin
(107,956 posts)Many young people who voted for Obama couldn't be bothered to. Sad to say I don't expect anything different in 2018.
I'd love to be proven wrong.