Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nonhlanhla

(2,074 posts)
19. As a white South African, let me say how much is wrong here
Mon Jan 22, 2018, 11:38 AM
Jan 2018

First of all, since whites are a minority in South Africa, making it into a white country would entail genocide or mass removal of people of color. That is an evil idea in itself.

Ironically, not even the apartheid government really had that goal. The initial ideology of apartheid, wrongheaded as it was, was not premised on removing black people, but on separation based on a twisted form of multiculturalism - each cultural group living separately and on their own terms. I'm NOT defending it - just saying not even those apartheid guys went as far as aiming at SA being a completely white country.

Thirdly, apartheid was the direct consequence of British colonialism in South Africa, on two levels: apartheid policies were to a large extent a continuation of colonial policies; secondly, apartheid was the Afrikaners' response to the horrors of the Anglo Boer War, in which the British basically committed genocide on the Afrikaners. (Again, not defending apartheid here, but to understand where it came from, history is important - the book, "Apartheid: Britain's Bastard Child" by Hélène Opperman Lewis, might be insightful here.)

So, basically, Thatcher was horrible and full of $#!t.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

K&FuckingR! Guy Whitey Corngood Jan 2018 #1
They must have the right to steal us from our own continent malaise Jan 2018 #3
We all knew she was racist... HipChick Jan 2018 #2
We did for sure malaise Jan 2018 #4
This suggests woeful ignorance of history on the part of Ms. Thatcher. lapislzi Jan 2018 #5
Well said malaise Jan 2018 #6
A genocidal British PM? Say it ain't so! Orrex Jan 2018 #7
Hehehehhe malaise Jan 2018 #8
lol Orrex Jan 2018 #14
Not surprised by any means. IluvPitties Jan 2018 #9
When you strip out everything else, racism is the common denominator of the conservative movement. Bleacher Creature Jan 2018 #10
More than racism, it's the preservation of white dominance. IluvPitties Jan 2018 #11
White dominance on the African Continent! malaise Jan 2018 #12
Not at all shocked tenderfoot Jan 2018 #13
Thatcher: the PM who brought racism in from the cold dalton99a Jan 2018 #15
Democracy? I guess she meant colonialism... IluvPitties Jan 2018 #16
Yep. Typical RW bullshit e.g. W.'s "democracy to every corner of the world" crap dalton99a Jan 2018 #17
It's like we need to be thankful to our colonizers IluvPitties Jan 2018 #21
Thatcher, Reagan and the New World Order malaise Jan 2018 #18
As a white South African, let me say how much is wrong here Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #19
Good post malaise Jan 2018 #20
Indeed Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #24
Excellent info. and reminders of the familiar use of racist and classist policies appalachiablue Jan 2018 #38
Which is why Selassie was right on matters race - and thankfully Marley spread his words malaise Jan 2018 #41
Love Bob Marley! Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #46
You're welcome malaise Jan 2018 #47
Yup. Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #45
+1 yes brutal lunasun Jan 2018 #48
I read all of those malaise Jan 2018 #42
Well said. lapislzi Jan 2018 #31
I have more than a passing knowledge of Calvinism Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #34
Thank you for that! lapislzi Jan 2018 #35
I am sorry you did not feel welcome there Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #37
It sure did...I was a cuckoo in the Afrikaans nest lapislzi Jan 2018 #39
Haha! Nonhlanhla Jan 2018 #40
The complexity of religion and Colonialism is that there is always the tension between malaise Jan 2018 #43
I also think she was like trump when it came to Nuclear Weapons maryellen99 Jan 2018 #22
Hooray for colonialism! It's the best! panader0 Jan 2018 #23
Fugging thieves malaise Jan 2018 #25
We love you Mrs. Thatcher, I'd love to kick you in the janterry Jan 2018 #26
Perfect malaise Jan 2018 #27
As much as I hated Thatcher and her policies that made the rich richer and the poor poorer, Doodley Jan 2018 #28
Some pretty damning revelations emerged from the release of government archives TubbersUK Jan 2018 #30
Released documents always expose malaise Jan 2018 #33
Thatcher was a racist - she was a protege of the notorious Enoch Powell TubbersUK Jan 2018 #29
There was a reason she became the UK's first female prime minister - she was even meaner than her Doodley Jan 2018 #32
Not to forget British slavery. moondust Jan 2018 #36
Yes indeed malaise Jan 2018 #44
I'm not sure what your point is. You know how long ago the Norman Conquest was? 1066 AD Hekate Jan 2018 #50
What a piece of work Hekate Jan 2018 #49
Thatcher being a racist is news? Blue_Tires Jan 2018 #51
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Margaret Thatcher believe...»Reply #19