Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Black Lives Matter: Philadelphia Super Bowl Riots Reaction Glaring Example of White Privilege [View all]BumRushDaShow
(171,123 posts)120. Hi Steve!
Not assuming that all suburbanites are white, but the demos here in the Philly area suburbs (yes I am a Philly resident and multigenerational) include many whites who fled the city in the '60s & '70s (back when our city population was >2,000,000), and their children/grandchildren. I have sisters who live in Montgomery County and Delaware County.
The "metro" area (tristate, 5-county) is actually ~6 million, but the population of the city by itself is 1.5 million. So yes, white suburbanites can "swamp" the area and have done so in the past during other team championships. PA is only ~12% black and most are here in Philly (and a few suburban towns like Upper Darby or Chester, etc) and Pittsburgh (which itself doesn't have that many).
Most of the damage that made national news was done in a couple-block area downtown in Center City near City Hall and in the "theater district" - around the Kimmel Center and Academy of Music. The Macy's (which is across the street from City Hall) that had windows broken out, was originally the old John Wanamaker department store (that has the largest working organ in the world inside). That area is very easy to get to from out of town because of its central location, with all major rail lines passing through or near it including PATCO (which comes across the bridge from Jersey).
As I was watching the various local broadcasts here, most people were celebrating in their own neighborhoods. And although there is a very active residential population downtown in Center City, it's not really a "residential" area - it is a "business district".... And since it is well known due to the parades (Thanksgiving, Mummers), it is where out-of-towners will go for "gathering" events like this, particularly due to the restaurants and bars in the area plus the Reading Terminal market & Convention Center (the alternate spot is Penn's Landing by the Delaware River)... And the images showed the crowds THERE were predominately white. Other reporters in other neighborhoods showed much much more of the local population and demographics, depending on the neighborhood.
Right now, they are prepping the parade here in anticipation of having 3 million show up.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
137 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Black Lives Matter: Philadelphia Super Bowl Riots Reaction Glaring Example of White Privilege [View all]
malaise
Feb 2018
OP
I wish white leaders would speak out about the destruction in their community and the cultural
WhiskeyGrinder
Feb 2018
#2
The notion that the crowds in Philadelphia were exclusively one race or another is ridiculous
jberryhill
Feb 2018
#23
When black folk run amok, damage property, it's a "riot." When white folk do it, it's "homecoming."
EffieBlack
Feb 2018
#97
turned over cars set fires smashed Macys windows ...what makes a riot then??Anger ?so every protest?
lunasun
Feb 2018
#105
And you are missing the point that a unpermitted block party is different from a permitted one
jberryhill
Feb 2018
#73
Flipping cars, breaking storefronts and windows, trashing traffic lights, crowds of drunks eating
WhiskeyGrinder
Feb 2018
#7
Wait it was done by white people? Totally just a victory celebration! /sarc
ExciteBike66
Feb 2018
#8
Bottles thrown at cops, the volume of calls overwhelming response, fires...
WhiskeyGrinder
Feb 2018
#13
Community? I would bet the owner and employees of that store are not feeling a great sense of
Tipperary
Feb 2018
#129
"The relative degree of general mayhem was lower than a normal night in Philadelphia."
mahatmakanejeeves
Feb 2018
#27
I call it illegal behavior but not indicative of a "riot" when it concerns only 4 or 5 people out
whathehell
Feb 2018
#124
The other weird thing is how people outside of Philly somehow think the crowds were all white
jberryhill
Feb 2018
#12
And the desire to move the narrative away from the OPs point as quickly as possible
LanternWaste
Feb 2018
#34
I cant believe the denial I am reading in this thread, no wait, I can, sigh.
Eliot Rosewater
Feb 2018
#76
How many women were tearing down lamp posts? I'd love to know. Bet there were none.
YOHABLO
Feb 2018
#29
I would usually be inclined to agree and do think this warrents a serious discussion
randr
Feb 2018
#41
Have you ever been to Philadelphia? Philadelphia has as many African Americans as white people
stevenleser
Feb 2018
#45
I've been posting on fb since the win, that if they were black, they'd be dead.
ancianita
Feb 2018
#46
It's not missing. It's not assumed either way. You are injecting 3 assumptions
stevenleser
Feb 2018
#108
Apparently, someone is bothered by a city demonstrating diverse unity in celebration
jberryhill
Feb 2018
#55
I thought they might be concerned about the co-opting of MLK's message by big business.
jalan48
Feb 2018
#101
They can't, nor should they be expected to, comment on every single instance of screwed up sh!t that
EffieBlack
Feb 2018
#102
that gathering place was a quite a culmination of folks of many backgrounds!
jberryhill
Feb 2018
#79
As an African American I get there's racism but we need voters to get rid of the current
underthematrix
Feb 2018
#78
You're right - it's about the underlying reason for the demonstration, not the demonstration itself
EffieBlack
Feb 2018
#100
So if the people committing the sports disturbance were 95% black there would be no
uponit7771
Feb 2018
#109
Then I'll take the answer as no, if the crowd was 95% black then they wouldn't get treated
uponit7771
Feb 2018
#135