General Discussion

Bernardo de La Paz

(60,320 posts)

8. The problem of evil. God is one of: not omnipotent, malevolent, careless, or not a god.

Fri Feb 16, 2018, 09:42 PM

Feb 2018

Sean Finnegan
‏Verified account @shotbyfinnegan
4h4 hours ago

Ah yes, the problem of evil. Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent. Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent. Is he both able and willing? Then why does evil exist?
Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

59 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

GOOD FOR Neil deGrasse Tyson - For Saying What MUST Be Said. [View all] kpete Feb 2018 OP

K&R for visibility. nt tblue37 Feb 2018 #1

I was going to say "thoughts" also are insufficient... Blue Owl Feb 2018 #2

Maybe it's time to say our thoughts and prayers are being answered ck4829 Feb 2018 #3

A "god" that's omnipotent and omniscient..... SergeStorms Feb 2018 #26

concur heaven05 Feb 2018 #34

K&R... spanone Feb 2018 #4

PC way of saying prayer is absolute BS Skittles Feb 2018 #5

A smart way Stardust1 Feb 2018 #30

He is speaking as a scientist with tongue in cheek a bit, but still being deadly serious. nt Lucky Luciano Feb 2018 #39

I know Skittles Feb 2018 #55

K&R Arkansas Granny Feb 2018 #6

kick, kick, kick, kick rurallib Feb 2018 #7

The problem of evil. God is one of: not omnipotent, malevolent, careless, or not a god. Bernardo de La Paz Feb 2018 #8

Epicurus--as an atheist it is one of my favorite quotes. panader0 Feb 2018 #14

And the invariable reply to that..... SergeStorms Feb 2018 #28

The one Ive heard is He's testing is. Fritz Walter Feb 2018 #52

K&R! gademocrat7 Feb 2018 #9

Whatever he says merits exposure question everything Feb 2018 #10

If it kills many quickly Red Mountain Feb 2018 #11

NDT is not a great scientist edhopper Feb 2018 #12

He's been a pretty good successor to Carl Sagan... Wounded Bear Feb 2018 #13

Yes he definitely is edhopper Feb 2018 #15

I was a little worried about Cosmos at first... Wounded Bear Feb 2018 #16

outside of the cheesy animation edhopper Feb 2018 #17

The original used live-action historical recreations. Dave Starsky Feb 2018 #57

I didn't mind edhopper Feb 2018 #59

That is what he is supposed to be, a teacher. murielm99 Feb 2018 #49

Maybe I'm misunderstanding you Stardust1 Feb 2018 #31

Only about 1-3% of PhDs are the great ones. nt Lucky Luciano Feb 2018 #40

I don't agree Stardust1 Feb 2018 #41

I know you said agree to disagree, but Ill put in my 2 cents anyway. :) Lucky Luciano Feb 2018 #54

He is a science educator edhopper Feb 2018 #46

They certainly are hard to get sammythecat Feb 2018 #53

why is heaven05 Feb 2018 #35

He doesn't work in the field. edhopper Feb 2018 #47

But but but how about the ones that WERE stopped by prayer but you don't even know about them NBachers Feb 2018 #18

Updated and love your tag line ( were) Maggiemayhem Feb 2018 #43

Checkmate. Dave Starsky Feb 2018 #58

I love that guy. n/t LittleGirl Feb 2018 #19

There's a high correlation between proximity to firearms and death. nt Xipe Totec Feb 2018 #20

Clearly god doesn't listen to people who love and cherish little children. nt Binkie The Clown Feb 2018 #21

Yep. Talking to oneself has no effect JenniferJuniper Feb 2018 #22

Love it!!!! Initech Feb 2018 #23

George Carlin Prayed to the Sun ....His Prayers Answered Half the Time Old Enough 2 Feb 2018 #24

Here's George on religion, the bit you mentioned. longship Feb 2018 #25

What great comedian Stardust1 Feb 2018 #32

Brilliant! smirkymonkey Feb 2018 #37

Best ten minutes in comedy hatrack Feb 2018 #56

Well said Dr. Tyson! Snackshack Feb 2018 #27

Have you seen the checks written to politicians Maggiemayhem Feb 2018 #44

No, I have not. Snackshack Feb 2018 #48

NdGT you sho got that right! InAbLuEsTaTe Feb 2018 #29

After so many "thoughts and prayers"..... paleotn Feb 2018 #33

if thats heaven05 Feb 2018 #36

K&R Neil deGrasse Tyson spoke truth. Progressive dog Feb 2018 #38

Their thoughts are no good either. They should try different thoughts. IronLionZion Feb 2018 #42

The fact that the most atheist countries are the most peaceful reinforces this logic. nt Quixote1818 Feb 2018 #45

People seem to praise God when something good happens but Poiuyt Feb 2018 #50

They perceive god as an abusive boss. sarge43 Feb 2018 #51