Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

X_Digger

(18,585 posts)
11. Civil obedience has consequences. Why are some surprised?
Wed Feb 21, 2018, 09:23 PM
Feb 2018

The first amendment doesn't protect you from getting fired if your boss sees you on TV when you called in sick to protest, it doesn't stop schools from enforcing rules related to maintaining order. Students can be punished for disrupting class, even if it's for protected speech.

Think about it- if it were otherwise, then a religious nut could stand up all day and talk over the teacher without consequence, expounding on whatever bug crawled up their ass that day- planned parenthood, illuminati, new world order..

What schools can't do is place rules that infringe the first amendment that have no relationship to maintaining order. See Tinker, etc.

If you skip school, expect to be punished, however worthy the cause. Take it as a badge of honor- those who participated in civil disobedience in the 60's sure as shit did.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My daughter graduated from high school last year, but if she was still in school I would Luciferous Feb 2018 #1
fine......... Takket Feb 2018 #2
Please change you subject line. trof Feb 2018 #3
Agree, the school district should be noted in the header. appalachiablue Feb 2018 #17
Suspension as badge of honor. nocalflea Feb 2018 #4
Exactly! -eom poboy2 Feb 2018 #20
The entire student body needs to protest ProudLib72 Feb 2018 #5
That's the answer. There is strength in numbers. TomSlick Feb 2018 #12
Since school districts are paid by the number of students they have in class in Texas trc Feb 2018 #14
October count? ProudLib72 Feb 2018 #15
The districts get paid for daily attendance, trc Feb 2018 #18
Ok, Texas is different in that than CO ProudLib72 Feb 2018 #23
Just move to Florida!!! onecent Feb 2018 #6
The right wing in Matthew28 Feb 2018 #7
They're trying to treat their students like Jerry Jones and the Dallas Cowboys. Mayberry Machiavelli Feb 2018 #8
I'd take the suspension. n/t LuckyCharms Feb 2018 #9
They're worried about funding, cloudbase Feb 2018 #10
Civil obedience has consequences. Why are some surprised? X_Digger Feb 2018 #11
The right of the people peaceably to assemble and petition the government for a redress of grievance shenmue Feb 2018 #13
Please edit your title- It's one Texas school district, Needville (bright red) not all of Texas. TexasProgresive Feb 2018 #16
I assume the ACLU is already drafting briefs on this. Ken Burch Feb 2018 #19
Right on! loyalsister Feb 2018 #21
I HOPE they all WALK OUT..what are they going to do? yuiyoshida Feb 2018 #22
That gives them 3 more days to protest! TeamPooka Feb 2018 #24
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Texas will suspend studen...»Reply #11