Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

In reply to the discussion: Gun ownership is racist [View all]

Igel

(35,386 posts)
21. You can keep saying it.
Sun Apr 1, 2018, 06:38 PM
Apr 2018

But it's still not the case.

When the BOR was up for grabs, there was a very real issue taking place. They'd just fought a war and the militia was very real and very armed. Nobody lined up in DC when the treaty was signed with Britain for the DOD to collect all those firearms. And this made sure it wouldn't happen. The militia was not the slave patrols, and the militia was very much a living, viable entity at the time. So there was no confusion in the minds of anybody at the time with slave patrols.

All that this did was make sure the federal government didn't limit the states' militias. The states could. However, when the rights in the Constitution devolved to the individual states after the Civil War, this, too, trickled down. States couldn't have an state religion; and suddenly the Constitution limitations imposed on the federal government applied to the states, too.

No, slaves at the time weren't allowed to own firearms. Neither were they really accorded freedom of assembly, the right to petition the government, or freedom of speech.

Gun ownership is racist [View all] johnpowdy Apr 2018 OP
Yes nothing the Founding Fathers hated more then the LGBT community... EX500rider Apr 2018 #1
Nothing you just said is correct Loki Liesmith Apr 2018 #2
What is not correct? johnpowdy Apr 2018 #5
Everything you said is wrong SCantiGOP Apr 2018 #10
Actually, you are wrong about a big part of it. A main purpose of the 2nd Amendment was to... brush Apr 2018 #13
Hartman's views are not widely accepted hack89 Apr 2018 #18
3/5s Compromise and the 2nd Amendment go hand in hand. Enslaved people of course were not allowed... brush Apr 2018 #19
Said no real historian ever. hack89 Apr 2018 #20
You can keep saying it. Igel Apr 2018 #21
Not so fast. brush Apr 2018 #17
There are many gun owners that support support blacks, minorities and the LGBT community. democratisphere Apr 2018 #3
We live in the country, murielm99 Apr 2018 #4
I'm okay with farmers able to have a registered double barrel johnpowdy Apr 2018 #6
This gun owner stands with all minorities. hack89 Apr 2018 #7
Three questions- sarisataka Apr 2018 #8
This thread should be deleted SCantiGOP Apr 2018 #9
Nice April Fool joke...had me for a second there nt Dreamer Tatum Apr 2018 #11
Vast majority of serious gunners are white wing racists, that's a fact. Hoyt Apr 2018 #12
Good thing they are not the ones actually killing people. hack89 Apr 2018 #14
From a gun owner and former hunter SonofDonald Apr 2018 #15
When the Black Panthers walked around with guns in the 1960s, guillaumeb Apr 2018 #16
Locking Maeve Apr 2018 #22
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Gun ownership is racist»Reply #21