Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

moriah

(8,312 posts)
64. Here's the BBC version:
Tue Jun 5, 2018, 07:21 PM
Jun 2018
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-44366360

And the link in Amheric, the official language of Ethiopia.

https://www.bbc.com/amharic/44355105

Google Translate gets it a little odd, but okay, here's a few differences between the fake story about Zimbabwe (which for some reason first appeared in English) and this.

1) Baptisms aren't events of hubris, like claiming that a person can walk on water.

2) The large number of people to be baptized isn't unusual, whereas pastors preparing to show congregants a miracle, fasting and praying and then "walking out 30 meters before trying to get to the surface" certainly is. If you were able to walk on water, shouldn't you have started at the beginning?

3) There's no suggestions that the lake was considered unsafe by natives in the original version or the BBC English version of this story -- in fact, fisherman were mentioned in both the original and the English BBC version, using nets. You don't get to do much fishing on lakeshores with nets without getting your feet as wet as a person would using that location for baptisms. In the urban legend, there's the note that he deliberately chose a river called the "Crocodile River".

4) Part of the original foreign language version states that a funeral was held for the pastor, and people were trying to save his body from the crocodile -- and were successful at that, though not at killing the crock. In the urban legend, the only things left allegedly were his sandals and underwear.... conveniently floating atop the surface like he'd allegedly intended.

----

Now, whether this actually happened or not is something none of us can know, as apparently there wasn't video of the incident.

Is this some propaganda attempt to scare people off of being baptized? Possibly.

Are DUers making fun of full-immersion baptisms falling prey to the same type of thing that made the obvious urban legend spread like wildfire, including cultural insensitivity/supremacy? Perhaps.

But this one has the ring of tragedy, not trying to teach some moral lesson on pride -- which in the "walk on water" UL was clearly an integral part of the story, even if it had the "dumb people from Africa" trope also for the setting they chose.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

next time they do this perhaps they won't do the full immersion technique... lapfog_1 Jun 2018 #1
Friends used the bucket of a front loader when exboyfil Jun 2018 #30
Isn't that how catholic priests baptize people? nt Blue_true Jun 2018 #55
I guess the crocodile was doing a little baptising of his own. panader0 Jun 2018 #2
The laws of nature malaise Jun 2018 #4
Mother Nature beats "our Father." Tipperary Jun 2018 #12
Yep, undefeated. Waiting for the next one to step into the ring. nt Blue_true Jun 2018 #57
Ah, the crock may have been doing the Holy Communion thing... magicarpet Jun 2018 #32
Lol treestar Jun 2018 #35
The crocodile god had dibs on his soul... hunter Jun 2018 #48
Surviving relatives of the dinosaurs.. They will always do what is instinctive hlthe2b Jun 2018 #3
Crocodiles are much older than dinosaurs. hunter Jun 2018 #51
movie script writers around the world are feeling inspired after this dembotoz Jun 2018 #5
And I'm sure some of the church members malaise Jun 2018 #7
Lake Abaya is side by side w Lake Chamo...very little land separates them Solly Mack Jun 2018 #6
Yuh think? malaise Jun 2018 #8
Well, to be fair, the uh faithful went along willingly to the croc hole. Solly Mack Jun 2018 #9
On the other hand malaise Jun 2018 #10
Oh, now. I'm trying to be nice. Solly Mack Jun 2018 #13
Except it was Zimbabwe last year jberryhill Jun 2018 #23
Here's the BBC version: moriah Jun 2018 #64
There's a university (and a crocodile farm) in Arba Minch jberryhill Jun 2018 #74
Oh Solly, CrispyQ Jun 2018 #11
The Creole Nature Trail Solly Mack Jun 2018 #14
God's will. God's plan. LakeArenal Jun 2018 #15
one of God's creatures was hungry rurallib Jun 2018 #16
I have spent a few days at the lakes at Arba Minch fishing for Nile Perch DrDan Jun 2018 #17
Wow! malaise Jun 2018 #18
we were in Ethiopia for 2 years - in Addis Ababa DrDan Jun 2018 #19
Lots of Jamaicans live in Ethiopia (mostly Rastas) malaise Jun 2018 #24
it is just a beautiful country DrDan Jun 2018 #47
Haile Selassie man. panader0 Jun 2018 #58
yes - it is a beautiful county - my wife and I arrived there just after he was ousted from power DrDan Jun 2018 #60
I think former Senator Paul Tsongas served in the Peace Corps there in the 60's AdamGG Jun 2018 #59
horseback riding was a popular diversion while we were there mid-to-late 70's DrDan Jun 2018 #62
OH NOES! HIPPOS. pansypoo53219 Jun 2018 #72
Okay, so I gotta ask... jmowreader Jun 2018 #20
Would you want to be malaise Jun 2018 #25
Is it bad that I'm laughing? Ligyron Jun 2018 #21
Didn't this one come and go around a few months ago? jberryhill Jun 2018 #22
But this one is in real media today malaise Jun 2018 #27
So was that one jberryhill Jun 2018 #28
It's a "let's laugh at stupid Africans" story jberryhill Jun 2018 #31
Not where I am malaise Jun 2018 #34
Okay, so let me ask you a question jberryhill Jun 2018 #38
I don't credit snake oil salesmen malaise Jun 2018 #40
Here's a thing that makes you go "huh"? jberryhill Jun 2018 #42
Yep malaise Jun 2018 #43
Does that sort of thing even show up in the news in Jamaica? jberryhill Jun 2018 #45
No - I can't remember hearing one of those here malaise Jun 2018 #46
It would have been me... jberryhill Jun 2018 #49
Our crocs are on the South Coast malaise Jun 2018 #50
In fairness this story has to be set treestar Jun 2018 #36
And here you go... from Australia..... jberryhill Jun 2018 #41
Kind of like the snake handlers treestar Jun 2018 #67
We have crocodiles here malaise Jun 2018 #44
As long as they don't come up those rivers treestar Jun 2018 #66
Good point - when there are major weather events malaise Jun 2018 #68
To be fair, I was laughing at religion, not Africans AdamGG Jun 2018 #61
Same here malaise Jun 2018 #69
And just about every year in the US, mountain lions kill cyclists/runners. Tipperary Jun 2018 #73
It was definitely a crock sarisataka Jun 2018 #33
Oh, I resent your alligation! jberryhill Jun 2018 #39
dammit you beat me to it. LSFL Jun 2018 #54
I heard that if you drink a glass of water before bedtime, it scares off crocs jberryhill Jun 2018 #26
That's sad. NCTraveler Jun 2018 #29
I wondered what happened to the Disney crocs (n/t) PJMcK Jun 2018 #37
Those damned Librul crocs.....they keep trying to destroy Christianity. nt Ferrets are Cool Jun 2018 #52
Whatta croc! LSFL Jun 2018 #53
LOL malaise Jun 2018 #56
Me too! treestar Jun 2018 #70
I was in Tamarindo, Costa Rica two years ago panader0 Jun 2018 #63
That's on the Pacific side malaise Jun 2018 #71
Sad, must have been horrifying Raine Jun 2018 #65
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Good Grief - Pastor kille...»Reply #64