General Discussion

SweetieD

(1,673 posts)

3. Not sure what you are talking about. They definitely would have been considered

Fri Aug 10, 2018, 09:19 AM

Aug 2018

White. I'm sure they faced anti immigrant sentiment and were otherized but on any census or official form they would have always been listed as white or Italian not colored or negro. Same with Irish. No group in this country went through what black people went through specifically. If you guys were truly considered black the experience would have been much different.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

56 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

How is it that all 4 of my Grandparents were considered non-white, but I'm considered white? [View all] louis c Aug 2018 OP

Got some of that Middle Eastern blood.... Historic NY Aug 2018 #1

My husband is of Italian & Sicilian ancestry. Dulcinea Aug 2018 #28

Same with the Irish Older Than I Look Aug 2018 #2

Not sure what you are talking about. They definitely would have been considered SweetieD Aug 2018 #3

Read the link. louis c Aug 2018 #5

Italians were NOT considered white Drahthaardogs Aug 2018 #18

July 30, 1866, 44 African Americans were killed in New Orleans in a race riot LakeSuperiorView Aug 2018 #37

Yes it was Drahthaardogs Aug 2018 #41

You are saying that manner someone was murdered is the important part? LakeSuperiorView Aug 2018 #42

I am saying that is you looked up the largest mass lynching in American Drahthaardogs Aug 2018 #45

That's exactly what I did and the top article LakeSuperiorView Aug 2018 #46

Google the largest mass Lynching in American history Drahthaardogs Aug 2018 #49

Told you, I did Google. LakeSuperiorView Aug 2018 #51

I agree blueniteflower Aug 2018 #53

Gee, I just watched Vendetta the story of the LARGEST mass Drahthaardogs Aug 2018 #55

No one is arguing with your straw man. n/t pnwmom Aug 2018 #20

No that's quite wrong Loki Liesmith Aug 2018 #26

This "racial adaptability" chart from 1925 separates "White Americans" from "Italians" ck4829 Aug 2018 #32

One is perceived by how they appear when walking out their front door. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #4

My point is that during this time of thinking that we will become a Majority-Minority nation louis c Aug 2018 #6

The only appropriate response would have been. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #7

I don't think you understand louis c Aug 2018 #9

You are wrong. We are not all illegal immigrants. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #10

Then you must be a Native American. What tribe do you belong to? louis c Aug 2018 #11

I belong to the American Citizenship Tribe. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #12

I guess you just don't get it. louis c Aug 2018 #14

There is a difference between not getting it. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #15

It's kinda tough to "get" a dogmatic premise supported with little more than absolutism. LanternWaste Aug 2018 #47

I don't think you understand what "illegally" means Lee-Lee Aug 2018 #36

And disease d_r Aug 2018 #54

Most of our ancestors were either invaders from Europe or came here before pnwmom Aug 2018 #21

Before 1940. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #22

I see nowhere in the OP, which I just reread, where the OP claims that pnwmom Aug 2018 #23

They have called me illegal multiple times. NCTraveler Aug 2018 #24

That's how assimilation works. In a couple of generations all of sinkingfeeling Aug 2018 #8

Me too!!! phylny Aug 2018 #13

Shows you how fucked up racism is. ismnotwasm Aug 2018 #16

I totally understand what you're saying. Shanti Mama Aug 2018 #17

The Irish ran into the same thing. And I remember visiting England in the late 70's, pnwmom Aug 2018 #19

The origins of Paddy Wagon are unclear but some say it was the PD (Police Dept) LakeSuperiorView Aug 2018 #40

history of the term SoCalDem Aug 2018 #44

The racial categorization of black/white/asian is a social construct and can change any time ck4829 Aug 2018 #25

My point is that my contemporaries can't grasp the logic louis c Aug 2018 #33

That I think is a serious issue ck4829 Aug 2018 #35

Exactly. n/t pnwmom Aug 2018 #43

In a few decades Asians and some Latinos Loki Liesmith Aug 2018 #27

Indeed, and we're already seeing it ck4829 Aug 2018 #29

Wouldn't it be great Soxfan58 Aug 2018 #30

If you did that, then greymattermom Aug 2018 #31

It will take some time... N_E_1 for Tennis Aug 2018 #34

I have my father's 8th grade picture from 1928 CanonRay Aug 2018 #38

My Mom's family is from Salerno and Sicily HockeyMom Aug 2018 #39

Anti-Chinese sentiments, anti-Irish sentiments, anti-Italian sentiments have all come and gone. LanternWaste Aug 2018 #48

I'm Sicilian-Irish maveric Aug 2018 #50

This is true. If you were Irish or Italian, at one time underthematrix Aug 2018 #52

Because race and culture are malleable constructs. nt Hekate Aug 2018 #56