Libertarianism is officially dead

[Bernardo de La Paz]

25. Sophistry.

Property is a social convention and less of an innate concept or state than personal freedom.

Some Native American people and some other societies have a philosophical history where property rights are very weak, where the convention is not very strong. (When they are enmeshed with modern US society they are more likely to follow the new than the old, perhaps.)

A thug can take away all your property including most of your body but not your most innate core freedoms: to think and to believe. All freedoms we claim and gain flow from that core. Including the idea of property rights.