Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Serious question (not trying to bait anyone). What do you make of the rise of Independents? [View all]Garrett78
(10,721 posts)92. Most of them align very strongly with one party or the other. But they also tend to be...
...less engaged.
While around four-in-10 voters say theyre independents, very few are actually swing voters. In fact, according to an analysis of voting patterns conducted by Michigan State University political scientist Corwin Smidt, those who identify as independents today are more stable in their support for one or the other party than were strong partisans back in the 1970s. According to Dan Hopkins, a professor of government at the University of Pennsylvania, independents who lean toward the Democrats are less likely to back GOP candidates than are weak Democrats.
While most independents vote like partisans, on average theyre slightly more likely to just stay home in November. Typically independents are less active and less engaged in politics than are strong partisans, says Smidt.
Rising polarizationand the increasingly personal and nasty nature of our politicshas had a paradoxical effect on the American electorate. On one hand, the growing distance between the two major parties has contributed to a dramatic decrease in the number of true swing voters. Smidt found that low-information voters today are as aware that there are significant differences between the two major parties as well-informed people were in the 1970s, and people who are aware of those differences tend to have more consistent views of the parties candidates. At the same time, says Smidt, many people who vote consistently for one party say theyre independents because they view partisanship as bad and see claiming allegiance to a party as socially unacceptable.
While most independents vote like partisans, on average theyre slightly more likely to just stay home in November. Typically independents are less active and less engaged in politics than are strong partisans, says Smidt.
Rising polarizationand the increasingly personal and nasty nature of our politicshas had a paradoxical effect on the American electorate. On one hand, the growing distance between the two major parties has contributed to a dramatic decrease in the number of true swing voters. Smidt found that low-information voters today are as aware that there are significant differences between the two major parties as well-informed people were in the 1970s, and people who are aware of those differences tend to have more consistent views of the parties candidates. At the same time, says Smidt, many people who vote consistently for one party say theyre independents because they view partisanship as bad and see claiming allegiance to a party as socially unacceptable.
https://www.thenation.com/article/what-everyone-gets-wrong-about-independent-voters/
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
110 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Serious question (not trying to bait anyone). What do you make of the rise of Independents? [View all]
Tom Rinaldo
Aug 2018
OP
Most so-called independents are highly partisan, and independents who support Democrats...
Garrett78
Aug 2018
#90
You're not alone. That's a big reason why people call themselves "independent."
Garrett78
Aug 2018
#91
Of course it goes beyond that as well. If non voter was a candidate in 2016, non voter would...
Tom Rinaldo
Aug 2018
#6
They don't want to commit but they sure want to vote in primaries to pick the candidates.
brush
Aug 2018
#39
Who knew allowing repugs to vote on who Democratic candidates are was a good thing?
brush
Aug 2018
#83
Most of them align very strongly with one party or the other. But they also tend to be...
Garrett78
Aug 2018
#92
My right wing brother in law takes offense when you call him a republican. He's an Independent!
Cousin Dupree
Aug 2018
#12
I think it is similar to millenial females supporting equal rights but denying support for "feminism
hlthe2b
Aug 2018
#8
Because consumerism has taken over democracy. People look at voting as an act of self-expression.
Recursion
Aug 2018
#24
I find the Rank Choice Voting method of selecting candidates interesting. Keeping an eye on Maine.
Snotcicles
Aug 2018
#18
Propaganda from both parties is working and this trend will continue with the 24 hr news cycle...
NCTraveler
Aug 2018
#20
"...a socialist party that want (sic) everything for free and supports violent groups like ANTIFA."
shanny
Aug 2018
#74
Exactly! It's a vanity label. A way to say "look at me" and to suggest to others...
NurseJackie
Aug 2018
#26
What do I make of an increase in the number of independents? To me it suggests that the
Nitram
Aug 2018
#32
I am technically Independent. I vote in Democratic Primaries and other elections
Freethinker65
Aug 2018
#34
Some poeple will state they they believe that both major parties are the same.
guillaumeb
Aug 2018
#51
I agree. That's exactly what I hear from folks who say they are Independent. They don't trust
KPN
Aug 2018
#67
I think the older ones are ashamed to say they are Republicans & the younger ones don't know enough
Hekate
Aug 2018
#52
Honest answer. Now some honest questions: why are you still here at DU? why have you
KPN
Aug 2018
#65
Republican Party is unpopular but Democratic Party is not particularly popular
Awsi Dooger
Aug 2018
#63
It's inevitable, as the 2 major parties move to their respective more extreme corners.
Honeycombe8
Aug 2018
#64
The percentage of independents has held pretty steady and the incumbent re-election...
Garrett78
Aug 2018
#102
I think youre seeing a problem where none exists - many states like mine dont require registration
Kashkakat v.2.0
Sep 2018
#110