Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

PatrickforO

(14,572 posts)
32. Of course he did. However...
Sun Sep 2, 2018, 12:52 PM
Sep 2018

He did heavily stress the manufacturing that had been moved offshore and the need for better-negotiated trade agreements to bring back good jobs. That was his populist thread, and if you've ever met people in a little town that had a factory that moved, you know that whole swaths of this country's economy have turned to rust. People who were once middle class and had decent lives now are working at places like Wal-Mart because those are the only jobs. They don't have healthcare any more. Their once-new truck is now on its last legs. They can't afford to send their kids to college. Et cetera. When a politician says he wants to address those things, or implies he does, as Trump did, it is in fact a populist message. Trump was lying, of course, but that is a populist message.

Trump is also a racist, as you point out, and early on his campaign swung from hope into fear and hatred. I agree with you on that.

Clinton had a great platform, and in fact won the popular vote. Trump cheated, yes, with Russia, and was aided by years of Republican gerrymandering and voter suppression, to win the Electoral College by what? 78,000 votes in three states?

But don't forget the power of the media. They showed all of Trump's rallies in their entirety - great for ratings, and they presented him over and over and over and over as a legitimate candidate and a populist.

Like it or not, Clinton faced two major hurdles: first, unlike Trump, she was not perceived as a populist. Somehow, with much of the fault at the media's doorstep, Clinton's genuineness and caring was never stressed. Clinton is a great lady. She never forgets, and she still checks in with people whom she helped many years ago. She really cares, and that can't be taught. You either have it or you don't and Clinton is genuinely a very nice, very caring, hardworking person who would have made a fantastic president back in the day when we actually had people in DC who wanted to govern us. Had she won, the Republicans would for sure have impeached her by now, and you know this is true. They would have obstructed her every...single...step...of...the...way, unrelentingly, 24/7/365.

And, of course, this brings us to my second point: The right wing for some reason had spent years and years, decades, smearing Clinton. Whitewater this, emails that, pizzagate, and so on. The bottom line is that corporate hate-propaganda, that decades-long smear campaign worked. It made a substantial portion of our population, mostly older white men, absolutely, fervently hate her. I mean to the point where they are so into their hatred they spray saliva when they are talking about her.

So, she had that baggage - horribly biased media coverage creating the perception she was the establishment candidate, and the feverish hatred, built over decades, once again fanned into flame on thousands of AM radio stations, Fox 'news' and other corporate capitalist propaganda organs.

Trump wasn't a populist and isn't now. But as Marshall McLuhan said, "The medium is the message." And that is the message people got because Trump is a master at creating chaos and riding it to victory. He implied he was a populist and this lie was accepted at face value. Somehow, he sensed that Americans want the game to change in some fundamental ways. And, you cannot deny we do want that kind of fundamental change - but there's the rub. What needs to change looks different for Trump supporters than it does to us. To an old white guy who used to be prosperous but now has to work two jobs just to stay above water, the fear, carefully fostered as part of the GOP's 'southern strategy,' makes him afraid he's going to ultimately lose everything to immigrants, gays and minorities.

This is why, when I'm talking to young people who want to run for office, I tell them they must pound on kitchen table issues. All politics is local, and the game people want to change is they want to have a better say in policies that affect them at the local, state and national levels. Kitchen table issues are populist issues. WE have the populist platform, and we need to pound on that with one voice. Then we'll win.

Great thread malaise Sep 2018 #1
Truth for Republicans, yes. False equalization with Democrats. Hortensis Sep 2018 #80
Well put jberryhill Sep 2018 #2
I think about this every time I see people like Bill Krystal out there criticizing Trump Renew Deal Sep 2018 #3
Or Steve Schmidt. nt GreenEyedLefty Sep 2018 #10
...and Rick Wilson, Charlie Sykes, David Frum, Mona Charen, Max Boot, etc. JHB Sep 2018 #14
This is what I wrote after Schmidt left the GOP: Garrett78 Sep 2018 #28
+ 1 ChiTownDenny Sep 2018 #34
Very true, none more than this: Merlot Sep 2018 #56
Well put. But don't forget rightwing media. EndGOPPropaganda Sep 2018 #66
Absolutely. Right wing media has been instrumental and I should have made mention of that. Garrett78 Sep 2018 #75
should be an OP Hermit-The-Prog Sep 2018 #72
Thanks. I made it an OP at the time. I more recently made post #25 of this thread an OP, as well. Garrett78 Sep 2018 #76
Did you see his list of speakers for the Trump funeral? oberliner Sep 2018 #4
No Scott Baio? Beartracks Sep 2018 #52
He lost me when he blamed Pres Obama ecstatic Sep 2018 #5
I think it was a failure not to prosecute bankers. Bluepinky Sep 2018 #7
Absolutely correct. n/t MsLeopard Sep 2018 #9
Hard to say for sure... paleotn Sep 2018 #19
I'm not an economist, but it seems that increasing income inequality is a big problem. Bluepinky Sep 2018 #57
Our tax system is one of the largest contributors to income inequality... paleotn Sep 2018 #62
Presidents don't prosecute. Otherwise, Trump would be prosecuting Hillary. SunSeeker Sep 2018 #20
Thank you. SharonClark Sep 2018 #47
You're right, and I don't mean to put the blame on Obama. Bluepinky Sep 2018 #53
Thank you. He chose to save lives by spending his very limited political capital on healthcare betsuni Sep 2018 #78
Obama entered the office with an overriding passion for compromise, getting along, bipartisanship Chemisse Sep 2018 #31
I agree proglib217 Sep 2018 #54
I agree with your perspective. Chemisse Sep 2018 #61
Same here. n/t GoCubsGo Sep 2018 #36
I am a VERY big BHO guy Cosmocat Sep 2018 #43
Exactly right. shanny Sep 2018 #6
Well done! PatrickforO Sep 2018 #8
No, they wanted a racist radical noodle Sep 2018 #12
That was clear as day in 2010 with their malaise Sep 2018 #15
Exactly radical noodle Sep 2018 #24
Remember their attacks on some African-American Congressmen malaise Sep 2018 #27
Of course he did. However... PatrickforO Sep 2018 #32
Well said. eom BlueWI Sep 2018 #39
Yes... some of that is true..some of it not quite so much.. JHan Sep 2018 #44
K&R SharonClark Sep 2018 #48
Well...we're in agreement, then. PatrickforO Sep 2018 #51
ty for that. Good points but this is how I differentiate it: JHan Sep 2018 #58
Good points all. Thx for thoughtful reply. PatrickforO Sep 2018 #73
Happy you mentioned Teddy, JHan Sep 2018 #74
Right now, countries with Universal Health Care and low wealth inequality, JHan Sep 2018 #13
This set of tweets is the opinion brer cat Sep 2018 #46
"Pander to the center" - do you get how ridiculous that phrase is? I'm guessing not. Squinch Sep 2018 #55
It's part of a collection of boilerplate memes that are just repeated over and over... JHan Sep 2018 #68
Yes. And the concept, in the context of politics, is so mindlessly illogical it's hilarious. Squinch Sep 2018 #81
NOPE , they wanted a Bigot that takes brown kids from their parents . that's why they are ok with JI7 Sep 2018 #64
they wanted everybody they could anger Hermit-The-Prog Sep 2018 #77
'Squalor'. Aristus Sep 2018 #11
Just consider blue-wave Sep 2018 #16
More false equivalence bullshit. Dems are not responsible for Trump, the GOP is. SunSeeker Sep 2018 #17
Bingo! paleotn Sep 2018 #21
Yeah he is definitely their baby. The pinnacle of Republicanism ismnotwasm Sep 2018 #23
Yes, thank you! peggysue2 Sep 2018 #26
There's more accountability to go around BlueWI Sep 2018 #49
No. Trump is the culmination of the GOP "Southern Strategy" that started in the 1960s. SunSeeker Sep 2018 #50
Of course there's a Southern strategy BlueWI Sep 2018 #63
no, things like attending a wedding are not on the same level as bigotry and Russian attacks on the JI7 Sep 2018 #67
Attending a wedding is perfectly legal BlueWI Sep 2018 #89
exactly, attending a wedding is legal JI7 Sep 2018 #90
So you have nothing to say about the obvious corruption BlueWI Sep 2018 #91
NYC was not always democratic . and his rise was due to Russian Oligarchs . He wasn't getting Money JI7 Sep 2018 #92
+1 BannonsLiver Sep 2018 #87
Just a couple questions classof56 Sep 2018 #18
He writes for "The National Review." GoCubsGo Sep 2018 #38
I thank you. classof56 Sep 2018 #59
Actually, it's "The New Republic", not the National Review JHB Sep 2018 #60
This message was self-deleted by its author BannonsLiver Sep 2018 #88
The Rs still like the message, just not Trump DeminPennswoods Sep 2018 #22
I find it hard to argue with any of that. As I wrote recently: Garrett78 Sep 2018 #25
Sure resonated with me Jarqui Sep 2018 #29
+ 1 ChiTownDenny Sep 2018 #40
Fascinating. America is so brilliant and flush with intelligent thinkers. Crutchez_CuiBono Sep 2018 #30
K&R SamKnause Sep 2018 #33
I partly agree with him about Obama marylandblue Sep 2018 #35
President Obama was unable to fix the "Old Order" because...... StepnKretchit Sep 2018 #41
Racism was a factor, but really, I don't think a white Democrat would have done much better marylandblue Sep 2018 #42
Okay. StepnKretchit Sep 2018 #45
This. Also, I seem to remember billionaire execs thumbing their noses BlancheSplanchnik Sep 2018 #84
I'm willing to give President Obama a pass on this . . . Erda Sep 2018 #86
I personally think it's awful to live in an age when "tweets/twits" pass as thinking. NNadir Sep 2018 #37
+ JI7 Sep 2018 #65
+2 orangecrush Sep 2018 #69
We are where we are at today Mr.Bill Sep 2018 #70
Hogwash. Honeycombe8 Sep 2018 #71
GOP "Southern Strategy" of race-baiting. lindysalsagal Sep 2018 #79
Who is this brilliant person? BlancheSplanchnik Sep 2018 #82
And I will add mine.. mountain grammy Sep 2018 #83
This encapulates exactly the tenious position we find ourselves in now The Liberal Lion Sep 2018 #85
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Biting political analysis...»Reply #32