Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

Segami

(14,923 posts)
Sun Aug 12, 2012, 07:35 PM Aug 2012

Rachel Maddow KILLS The Romney/Ryan MEDICARE LIE Dead In its Tracks [View all]




Rachel Maddow delivered a quick knock out punch to the Republican lie that Mitt Romney doesn’t support Paul Ryan’s Medicare voucher plan on Meet The Press.






Transcript via Meet The Press:




RICH LOWRY: –Republicans should go on offense on Medicare, because the president, as part of Obamacare, passed $700 billion in cuts in Medicare. And Romney wants to repeal Obamacare, including those cuts.

RACHEL MADDOW: Wait, wait. Hold on. Hold on.

RICH LOWRY: So it’s–

RICH LOWRY:–so at the top– hold on. So at the top of a ticket Romney versus Obama, there’s only one of those guys who wants any cuts affecting current seniors.

RACHEL MADDOW: Wait, wait. There’s–

RICH LOWRY: That’s not Mitt Romney.

RACHEL MADDOW : -Romney versus Ryan then. The Ryan plan keeps the Obama cuts for Medicare.

RICH LOWRY: The Ryan plan–

RACHEL MADDOW: So which one is it?

RICH LOWRY: –does.

RACHEL MADDOW:The Romney or Ryan plan?

RICH LOWRY: The Ryan plan does mostly as a matter of just preserving the CDO baseline. But the top to the ticket is Mitt Romney. Mitt Romney wants to repeal those cuts. And the fact is, Rachel–

RACHEL MADDOW: Wait, that’s amazing.

RICH LOWRY: The fact is, Rachel–

RACHEL MADDOW: –Romney versus Ryan–

RICH LOWRY: If the Republicans–

RACHEL MADDOW: –on Medicare.

RICH LOWRY: –were proposing–

RACHEL MADDOW: That’s going to be awkward.

RICH LOWRY: –$700 billion. Had passed $700 billion in Medicare cuts, you’d be savaging–

RACHEL MADDOW: Wait–

RICH LOWRY: –that president for their brutality–

RACHEL MADDOW: So what–

RICH LOWRY: –to seniors.

RACHEL MADDOW: –but you’re saying–

RICH LOWRY: And that is–

RACHEL MADDOW: Wait–

RICH LOWRY: –Barack Obama.

RACHEL MADDOW: Is Romney running on the Ryan plan or not? Is Romney accepting–

RICH LOWRY: He’s running on–

RACHEL MADDOW: He said that (UNINTEL) he–

RICH LOWRY: –his own version of those ideas.

RACHEL MADDOW: That’s amazing. Paul Ryan accepted the exact same cuts.




See how easy that was? Rachel Maddow derailed Lowry in a matter of seconds on Medicare. As soon as she spotted the inconsistency in Lowry’s talking point, Maddow pounced and it was all over for Rich Lowry. As Maddow expertly revealed Republicans have to keep the conversation on Medicare superficial, because their whole talking point falls apart as soon as it is scrutinized in the slightest.



So Republicans are going to try to sell America on the idea that the Medicare privatization plan that Romney endorsed isn’t really Romney’s plan? That unpopular thing about the vouchers? That’s all Paul Ryan. Not us, no sir. Mitt Romney would never ever implement the plan that he endorsed and urged the Senate to pass. That is seriously going to be the Republican strategy on Paul Ryan’s Medicare voucher plan.




cont'


http://www.politicususa.com/rachel-maddow-kills-romneyryan-medicare-lie-dead-tracks.html

.
28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Obama's so-called "cuts to Medicare" were reforms to hedgehog Aug 2012 #1
+1,000 freshwest Aug 2012 #3
No, go ahead and SHOUT because I ALSO read the same such news and it would seem to be occurring with Segami Aug 2012 #5
Yeah. But even some Dems don't get that. n/t vaberella Aug 2012 #6
And it was 500 billion - now the repugs are saying it was 700 billion and NO ONE IS SAYING A FUCKING jillan Aug 2012 #13
Yeah, mostly the doctors, and insurers, and therapists who are in the 1% and who vote GOPnt nanabugg Aug 2012 #15
Further to this, cleduc Aug 2012 #2
Get real for a second thatsrhetoric Aug 2012 #7
Thank you for your concern. nt Ruby the Liberal Aug 2012 #8
Post removed Post removed Aug 2012 #19
Er, what? Ruby the Liberal Aug 2012 #21
? :( thatsrhetoric Aug 2012 #22
My sig line? Ruby the Liberal Aug 2012 #25
Wow, you joined DU so you could post that? SunSeeker Aug 2012 #11
You seem to be confusing Medicare with Medicaid. Tanuki Aug 2012 #12
I have a serious question for you - jillan Aug 2012 #14
Isn't Medicare paid 100% by the federal government? creeksneakers2 Aug 2012 #17
NO!!!!!!!!!! Medicare is paid by premiums that are deducted from our paychecks every week BlueStreak Aug 2012 #27
Completely wrong. EC Aug 2012 #20
Ryan floated your concerns at the start of this video cleduc Aug 2012 #23
They were NOT cuts, they were savings. NashvilleLefty Aug 2012 #24
Republicans are going to have a very hard time selling the Ryan JDPriestly Aug 2012 #26
Rmoney said he supports the vouchers on 60 minutes n2doc Aug 2012 #4
Was he asked if he supports a voucher system for Medicare? SHRED Aug 2012 #9
What matters most is which person @ top of ticket cuts Medicare. Honeycombe8 Aug 2012 #10
Ryans job is going to funerals julian09 Aug 2012 #28
And that was all the time David Gregory gave her. The next time she tried to talk - jillan Aug 2012 #16
She kicked ass this morning! B Calm Aug 2012 #18
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Rachel Maddow KILLS The R...