Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Pentagon Says Trump Was Never Supposed To Share Picture Of Damaged Iranian Launchpad [View all]progree
(13,058 posts)40. This NPR story goes into why the image's release is so disturbing
https://www.mprnews.org/story/2019/08/30/npr-president-trump-tweets-sensitive-surveillance-image-of-iran
More from article -- But there's a redaction that might indicate ... on the other hand ...
Some of the highest-resolution imagery available commercially comes from the company Maxar, whose WorldView-2 satellite sports 46-centimeter resolution.
But the image shown in the president's tweet appears to be of far better quality, says Ankit Panda, an adjunct senior fellow at the Federation of American Scientists, who specializes in analyzing satellite imagery. "The resolution is amazingly high," says Panda. "I would think it's probably below well below 20 centimeters, which is much higher than anything I've ever seen."
Panda says that the tweet discloses "some pretty amazing capabilities that the public simply wasn't privy to before this."
It was not entirely clear where the president's photo came from. Panda believes it was likely taken by a classified U.S. satellite. But Melissa Hanham, deputy director of the Open Nuclear Network at the One Earth Foundation, believes that the resolution is so high, it may be beyond the physical limits at which satellites can operate. "The atmosphere is thick enough that after somewhere around 11 to nine centimeters, things get wonky," she says.
That could mean it was taken by a drone or spy plane, though such a vehicle would be violating Iranian airspace. Hanham also says that the European company Airbus has been experimenting with drones that fly so high, they are technically outside the atmosphere and thus operating outside of national boundaries. But she says she doesn't know whether the U.S. has such a system.
But the image shown in the president's tweet appears to be of far better quality, says Ankit Panda, an adjunct senior fellow at the Federation of American Scientists, who specializes in analyzing satellite imagery. "The resolution is amazingly high," says Panda. "I would think it's probably below well below 20 centimeters, which is much higher than anything I've ever seen."
Panda says that the tweet discloses "some pretty amazing capabilities that the public simply wasn't privy to before this."
It was not entirely clear where the president's photo came from. Panda believes it was likely taken by a classified U.S. satellite. But Melissa Hanham, deputy director of the Open Nuclear Network at the One Earth Foundation, believes that the resolution is so high, it may be beyond the physical limits at which satellites can operate. "The atmosphere is thick enough that after somewhere around 11 to nine centimeters, things get wonky," she says.
That could mean it was taken by a drone or spy plane, though such a vehicle would be violating Iranian airspace. Hanham also says that the European company Airbus has been experimenting with drones that fly so high, they are technically outside the atmosphere and thus operating outside of national boundaries. But she says she doesn't know whether the U.S. has such a system.
More from article -- But there's a redaction that might indicate ... on the other hand ...
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
89 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Pentagon Says Trump Was Never Supposed To Share Picture Of Damaged Iranian Launchpad [View all]
babylonsister
Aug 2019
OP
Correct, they should know by now that they cannot share secret information with this idiot
Perseus
Aug 2019
#18
No, "President" is a title, nothing else, they have to defend the nation, patriotism is higher than
Perseus
Aug 2019
#74
President is the title of the individual legally entrusted with the highest security of the country.
Mike_DuBois
Aug 2019
#75
Why does anybody tell him or let him see anything relating to security, or even of
smirkymonkey
Aug 2019
#4
How did Trump get the pic in. Tweet?take Pic and post? Wouldn't think he has
OAITW r.2.0
Aug 2019
#6
Problem is, Trump can declassify anything he wants, so there is nothing they can do about it.
vsrazdem
Aug 2019
#9
The president can classify or declassify anything at any time without any process
dalton99a
Aug 2019
#37
Of course there's a process. Since when did that stop Trumpy from doing what he wants? n/t
Eyeball_Kid
Aug 2019
#45
Intel agencies revise the level of classified info Fat Donnie will get:
LastLiberal in PalmSprings
Aug 2019
#13
"Yes but" my butt. Joe Biden in no way resembles Trump, so be prepared to refute...
Hekate
Aug 2019
#76
He wanted his base (& Putin) to think he is tough, not a boasting cowardly bluster bluffer
TeamPooka
Aug 2019
#17
But think of the (false) accusations he makes against Hillary and Comey, that they mishandled
tblue37
Aug 2019
#20
Yes he is ... every single time he gets those narcissistic, infantile urges to "show and tell" and
KPN
Aug 2019
#50
He's a security risk, and compromised, but I'm not sure there is anything in that photo that
Hoyt
Aug 2019
#27
What "capability." Iran's? Or, our surveillance capabilities? I doubt the latter is in question.
Hoyt
Aug 2019
#30
That commercial image has nowhere near the resolution of the one Trump tweeted
VMA131Marine
Aug 2019
#57
On the other hand, and I hate defending trump, it could simply put them on notice that we know all
Hoyt
Aug 2019
#59
There is absolutely no reason to downplay the potential impact of this release
VMA131Marine
Aug 2019
#69
Christ, Iran, Russia, China, etc., probably have same, if not better, capabilities.
Hoyt
Aug 2019
#70
Well, apparently you believe what your superiors told you was truth. My experience says
Hoyt
Aug 2019
#85
Thank you. Personally, I find it frustrating that this question even has to be asked right now.
KPN
Aug 2019
#48
+1. "We don't even share a lot of this kind of imagery with our closest allies."
dalton99a
Aug 2019
#46
Trump or one of his aides may have snapped a picture of the image using a cellphone.
Gothmog
Aug 2019
#64