Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Igel

(37,324 posts)
32. It's one way of acknowledging reality.
Sun Apr 5, 2020, 02:44 PM
Apr 2020

If you have 100 people on life support indefinitely with virtually no chance of recovery, it's a problem.

It's bad enough when they're vegetative or in a coma. When they're conscious and can't hardly move, have to be catheterized and intubated, it's hell. https://epmonthly.com/article/post-intubation-sedation-the-tube-is-in-now-what/ Think of what that would be from the patient's perspective, not the ER doctor's.

It would also be hell to have to tell somebody whose conscious that the odds are close to zero they'd ever breathe without the machine, so the option is they stay intubated, taking an ICU bed, for the rest of their lives, possibly in pain, or they're removed and they live or die.

Worse is when there are limited resources. It's why some states have end-of-life options for hospitals. TX allows this: If a hospital determines that a patient will not recover and is just using resources, whether or not they can pay, they can be disconnected. If the family can arrange for alternative treatment in another hospital, great.

I'm not sure the alternative is appealing. Let's say that NYC has all the ventilators that Cuomo wants in use--30k patients. 90% don't come off. That's 27,000 people. On ventilators. Where do you put the 27,000 people? Giant warehouses of people with hard tubes down their bronchial tubes, unable to talk, sedated or doped because the tubes hurt, not mobile? And you keep them there for years, with visitation rights for their families? Farm them out for families to manage?

Reality bites.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

This isn't terribly different from what Cuomo said last week democrattotheend Apr 2020 #1
Or maybe we could just build and distribute more ventilators. dawg day Apr 2020 #7
Sadly, yes Tweedy Apr 2020 #28
It's one way of acknowledging reality. Igel Apr 2020 #32
As someone in the disability community comments like this scare the shit out of me. thucythucy Apr 2020 #42
"Rates of hospitalization going down"? Yeah, right. n/t blitzen Apr 2020 #2
Where? I wonder Tweedy Apr 2020 #29
Yet they claim the 'pro-life' banner. mzmolly Apr 2020 #3
Maybe it's just me but I liked Dr. Kervorkian better. gibraltar72 Apr 2020 #4
Fox was kind of forced to get some doctor ANY doctor on air. underpants Apr 2020 #5
The lengths they will go to for the sake of defending Trump for his criminal lack of action dawg day Apr 2020 #6
I don't want to defend anything from Fox news blogslut Apr 2020 #8
Yes, I think you're right, but it seems babylonsister Apr 2020 #10
I understand blogslut Apr 2020 #18
The reports I have seen said 60-90 percent don't recover madville Apr 2020 #11
The majority who require ventilators don't survive madville Apr 2020 #9
It's also a harrowing way to linger and then die janterry Apr 2020 #14
Sad story davekriss Apr 2020 #36
I'm so sorry janterry Apr 2020 #40
I guess they should just go ahead and die ... rustysgurl Apr 2020 #12
She must have taken the Hippocratic oath at Trump University. procon Apr 2020 #13
WTAF... What ever happened to "first do no harm"? Zoonart Apr 2020 #15
Trump U replaced it with; "get your own first, to hell with everyone else." nt procon Apr 2020 #27
WWJD??? LakeArenal Apr 2020 #16
Odd she didn't mention that because of TRUMP hospitals don't have enough ventilators CousinIT Apr 2020 #17
Here's a good article about ventilation janterry Apr 2020 #19
See post #36 (my post) davekriss Apr 2020 #37
Add Another Couple Of Million To That Lawsuit Me. Apr 2020 #20
FOX News supported keeping Terri Schiavo on life support for seven years. sop Apr 2020 #21
She was breathing on her own. Mariana Apr 2020 #38
It's the lengths Republicans will go to keep people alive when it serves their right to life agenda, sop Apr 2020 #46
Remember Bill Frist diagnosing her from afar? nt tblue37 Apr 2020 #43
When people take infectious disease advice ... GeorgeGist Apr 2020 #22
I can tell you as of right now covid-19 positive patients cannot be organ donors ismnotwasm Apr 2020 #23
The answer is obvious...the 65 yr old father probably has good insurance! ret5hd Apr 2020 #35
"And they're either going to survive or they're either going to die," ... DEbluedude Apr 2020 #24
Her credentials are tremendous, many say the best credentials they've ever seen mr_lebowski Apr 2020 #26
down in the pits of hell, Doctor Mengele is thrilled DBoon Apr 2020 #25
Screw faux news and everything they touch. I wouldn't ever, ever do what they suggest, SWBTATTReg Apr 2020 #30
Are they talking this way to their core voters, just die already? ffr Apr 2020 #31
Wait a minute? Explain that Pro-life logic to me once again Under The Radar Apr 2020 #33
This message was self-deleted by its author geralmar Apr 2020 #34
Fuck Fox News. How long one should remain on a ventilator is between a physician and their family, still_one Apr 2020 #39
They don't even try to hide it anymore. nt tblue37 Apr 2020 #41
Happens every day in America hack89 Apr 2020 #44
I find this sort of discussion absolutely terrifying. thucythucy Apr 2020 #45
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Fox News Doc: It's Time F...»Reply #32