Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Trump may just get run out of town. [View all]Hortensis
(58,785 posts)72. An Atlantic article's title is "The Trump Regime Is Beginning to Topple"
The best way to grasp the magnitude of what were seeing is to look for precedents abroad.
What the United States is witnessing is less like the chaos of 1968, which further divided a nation, and more like the nonviolent movements that earned broad societal support in places such as Serbia, Ukraine, and Tunisia, and swept away the dictatorial likes of Miloević, Yanukovych, and Ben Ali.
(Sharp) wanted to understand the weaknesses of authoritarian regimesand how nonviolent movements could exploit them. Sharp distilled what he learned into a 93-page handbook, From Dictatorship to Democracy, a how-to guide for toppling autocracy.
Sharps foundational insight is embedded in an aphorism: Obedience is at the heart of political power. (Me: And haven't we seen that in the Republican Party, their U.S. senators abandoning all duty to subservience.) A dictator doesnt maintain power on his own; he relies on individuals and institutions to carry out his orders. A successful democratic revolution prods these enablers to stop obeying. It makes them ashamed of their complicity and fearful of the social and economic costs of continued collaboration.
Sharp posited that revolutionaries should focus first on the regimes softest underbelly: the media, the business elites, and the police. The allegiance of individuals in the outer circle of power is thin and rooted in fear. By standing strong in the face of armed suppression, protesters can supply examples of courage that inspire functionaries to stop carrying out orders, or as Sharp put it, to withhold cooperation. Each instance of resistance provides the model for further resistance. As the isolation of the dictators growsas the inner circles of power join the outer circle in withholding cooperationthe regime crumbles.
What the United States is witnessing is less like the chaos of 1968, which further divided a nation, and more like the nonviolent movements that earned broad societal support in places such as Serbia, Ukraine, and Tunisia, and swept away the dictatorial likes of Miloević, Yanukovych, and Ben Ali.
(Sharp) wanted to understand the weaknesses of authoritarian regimesand how nonviolent movements could exploit them. Sharp distilled what he learned into a 93-page handbook, From Dictatorship to Democracy, a how-to guide for toppling autocracy.
Sharps foundational insight is embedded in an aphorism: Obedience is at the heart of political power. (Me: And haven't we seen that in the Republican Party, their U.S. senators abandoning all duty to subservience.) A dictator doesnt maintain power on his own; he relies on individuals and institutions to carry out his orders. A successful democratic revolution prods these enablers to stop obeying. It makes them ashamed of their complicity and fearful of the social and economic costs of continued collaboration.
Sharp posited that revolutionaries should focus first on the regimes softest underbelly: the media, the business elites, and the police. The allegiance of individuals in the outer circle of power is thin and rooted in fear. By standing strong in the face of armed suppression, protesters can supply examples of courage that inspire functionaries to stop carrying out orders, or as Sharp put it, to withhold cooperation. Each instance of resistance provides the model for further resistance. As the isolation of the dictators growsas the inner circles of power join the outer circle in withholding cooperationthe regime crumbles.
The author believes this is what we're witnessing, comparing events that toppled Ukraine's Yanukovoch and others. Trump's main platform Twitter labeling Trump's tweets as misleading was a key event, then hiding posts that threatened violence, which was followed by a "wide swath of" S&P 500 companies withdrawing support.
A cycle of noncooperation was set in motion. Local governments were the next layer of the elite to buck Trumps commands. After the president insisted that governors dominate the streets on his behalf, they roundly refused to escalate their response. ... As each group of elites refused Trump, it became harder for the next to comply in good conscience. In Sharps taxonomy, the autocrats grasp on power depends entirely on the allegiance of the armed forces. When the armed forces withhold cooperation, the dictator is finished. Of course, the U.S. is far more democratic than the regimes Sharp studied and doesnt fit his taxonomy neatly. But on Wednesday, the presidents very own secretary of defense explicitly rejected Trumps threat to deploy active-duty military officers to American streets. ... Jim Mattiss excoriation of his old boss prodded Trumps former chief of staff John Kelly and Senator Lisa Murkowski of Alaska to echo his condemnation of the president. ...
We'll see. The Republican senators are a critical part of this regime's inner defenses. They're currently threatened with losing everything. Or are they? Title of another of this author's articles is Putin Is Well on His Way to Stealing the Next Election -- RIP democracy.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
Recommendations
0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):
84 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
I don't have a pitchfork but I do have a garden fork. Will that do?
The Velveteen Ocelot
Jun 2020
#38
He needs to be like the insane CEO that gets kicked upstairs so he has no power
bucolic_frolic
Jun 2020
#19
I'll settle for Turd being perp walked out of the White House at high noon on January 20, 2021.
Brother Mythos
Jun 2020
#25
Trump needs to be tarred, feathered, and run out of DC on a rail straight to Leavenworth.
backscatter712
Jun 2020
#31
Watching these protests you know people,e are angry about police violence but this is
kimbutgar
Jun 2020
#49
Impeach. 25th. Lock him up. give him UV light and Hydroxychloroquin. I don't care, Do U?
Evolve Dammit
Jun 2020
#62
Made me think of this scene from "O Brother Where art Thou?" Run him out on a rail.
captain jack
Jun 2020
#67