Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Moostache

(11,133 posts)
5. That - focusing on the worst offenders - is why progress is so achingly slow on equality...
Thu Jun 18, 2020, 01:33 PM
Jun 2020

First, I am white, so outside of a historical perspective and self-education, I know exactly JACK-ALL about what it means to be black, how it feels to be a minority or what systemic repression and racism does to an entire group of people for hundreds of years. If I am talking out of turn or simply have this completely wrong, please correct me and help me understand where I err in my thinking or interpretation.

But what I can say is that when something like Aunt Jemina or Uncle Ben or even Mrs. Butterworth is looked at in the abstract, they are indeed offensive symbols. Uncle Ben is obvious, so too is Aunt Jemina...they are quite literally a half-step from minstrel shows and blackface in many ways. They are also powerful marketing images in that they are widely seen in positive light by nearly all white people; and while they certainly raise an eyebrow amongst African-Americans, they probably don't ring too offensive for Hispanic-Americans or Asian-Americans. And there in lies the problem. Something that is just beneath the surface hurtful, tinged with historical analogies and analogs; and yet widely ignored, is like a splinter that is on its way to an infection and a very nasty situation. It indirectly causes pain and amplifies it when larger issues flare up. They are inflammation, not stabs or shots or worse...but they contribute to the overall condition just as surely.

These small things, the things that pass without notice or care by millions every day - mainly through ignorance or lack of recognition; simply reinforce the stereotypes and prejudices in silent strength, they act as threads that when woven together make the rope as strong and as unyielding as it appears when held...a symbol does not have to be the battle flag of the Confederacy, or the Iron Cross of the Nazi Party, or the Swastika to inflict pain and buttress systemic issues. In fact, the little things are what act as the glue to keep the whole thing going. Without these small, overlooked, unthought of and unrecognized things, the larger more obvious and more pervasive issues would be much harder to sustain and ignore.

Once people truly begin to stop and think about these "little things" and ask themself "if that were being proposed TODAY, would it have ANY CHANCE of being adopted? or promoted? or defended?"...then, change is approaching the top of the wave and coming down fast is the next step. If we continue to stay on point and continue to expand and redouble the efforts, especially for White Americans who may have been until very recently in denial or simply on the sidelines, believing in error that equality was someone else's responsibility, someone else's fight, someone else's cross to bear...

I have seen it once in my lifetime with marriage equality, which in 1993 I would have said will NEVER happen to my great and eternal shame...but it has come to pass and we're not going back. Racial injustice is so deeply ingrained in us as a society though that there are literally THOUSANDS of little things that pass unmarked or unchallenged. The fact that they are now being called out, being discussed, being changed is a positive sign that progress - real, true and lasting progress - is within reach. It is clear that so much work remains, so much ingrained behavior, speech, attitude, and symbolical imagery remain to be reconsidered, retired and rethought, but the light at the end of the tunnel is ever so brighter at the moment...and a steady elimination of small things, while continuing to push for bigger things simultaneously, is the way we win in the end.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

To be honest, I thought this was the Onion... I too have never given Mrs. Butterworth a thought hlthe2b Jun 2020 #1
That - focusing on the worst offenders - is why progress is so achingly slow on equality... Moostache Jun 2020 #5
There is no doubt about Aunt Jemima and Uncle Ben's. hlthe2b Jun 2020 #7
There is ambiguity in Mrs. Butterworth that is definitely not in other symbols for sure. Moostache Jun 2020 #15
You are being offensive by suggesting anyone here is defending or equating Aunt Jemima issue. hlthe2b Jun 2020 #16
Then I have utterly failed. Moostache Jun 2020 #19
Wait until the questioning of Log Cabin Syrup starts. RhodeIslandOne Jun 2020 #28
No...Not Mrs.Butterworth! orwell Jun 2020 #2
There used to be a commercial with a talking bottle of Mrs. Butterworth syrup Ex Lurker Jun 2020 #3
If you look at the old commercials ms liberty Jun 2020 #4
That's My Recollection ProfessorGAC Jun 2020 #6
Mrs. Butterworth commercial was voiced by a white lady. Sneederbunk Jun 2020 #8
I Thought That's What I Said ProfessorGAC Jun 2020 #10
Yep. "Mrs. Butterworth, I love you!" SMC22307 Jun 2020 #24
Stubbs BBQ sauce must go. Sneederbunk Jun 2020 #9
You do realize that's the photo of the guy who marketed his own sauce, right? GoCubsGo Jun 2020 #11
see my post below making that very point. hlthe2b Jun 2020 #13
Does not matter in these sensitive times Sneederbunk Jun 2020 #14
So, people aren't allowed to put their own image on their product? GoCubsGo Jun 2020 #18
I guess Famous Amos and his cookies Raine Jun 2020 #23
The Stubbs Story hlthe2b Jun 2020 #12
Yep. That's what I'm saying, too. n/t GoCubsGo Jun 2020 #17
I expect that many corporations will avoid putting any characterizations of AA on consumer products MichMan Jun 2020 #20
I always assumed Mrs Butterworth was a fat white woman Raine Jun 2020 #21
As a child, I thought Mrs. Butterworth was Swedish cabot Jun 2020 #22
Mrs. Buttersworth? Catherine Vincent Jun 2020 #25
So Conagra doesn't even know their own product history??? RhodeIslandOne Jun 2020 #26
The animated Mrs. Butterworths used to remind me of the ice robot in the movie Logan's Run TheBlackAdder Jun 2020 #27
Isn't that just Robin Williams in a dress? lame54 Jun 2020 #29
I thought Mrs. Butterworth was a white woman... NurseJackie Jun 2020 #30
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Conagra Brands reviewing ...»Reply #5