Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

bhikkhu

(10,789 posts)
5. ...and to the South, Mexico has been transformed into a middle class country with full employment
Mon Jan 9, 2012, 10:39 AM
Jan 2012
http://johnpaulus.com/blog/2011/08/03/mexico-unemployment-at-4-9-compared-to-9-2-in-the-us/

I'd link to some other article, but it seems most of the coverage of the changes comes from hateful right wing blogs.

In any case, as you say, trade is hardly evil in itself, and perhaps it had done more to level the playing field in North America than anything else. If the trade agreement has lifted Mexico out of a long and crushing poverty at our expense, I have to wonder if our prosperity should require a neighbor to live on scraps again, and how many would like to turn back time and put them back in that position? How much of our wealth was built on a fixed structure of inequality, and advantage gained from exploiting a weak neighbor?

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

As the article indicates, the problems with NAFTA are related to our trade partner to the south. Thaddeus Kosciuszko Jan 2012 #1
...and to the South, Mexico has been transformed into a middle class country with full employment bhikkhu Jan 2012 #5
notsureifserious! You've heard of the severed heads, millions of impoverished expats in el Norte? Romulox Jan 2012 #6
There's more to Mexico that the drug wars along the border. bhikkhu Jan 2012 #14
OK. But you claimed that Mexico has been "transformed". Why so many millions fleeing, then? Romulox Jan 2012 #15
Mexico's emigration rate is effectively zero bhikkhu Jan 2012 #18
Over what period of time? The last year or two? There are over 10 million *illegal* Mexican Romulox Jan 2012 #20
Huh? marmar Jan 2012 #8
Why can't Mexico (China etc.) manufacture for and sell to millions within their borders? FredStembottom Jan 2012 #9
The Mexican story PETRUS Jan 2012 #10
while millions have become "middle class" - bhikkhu Jan 2012 #13
Those statistics are true PETRUS Jan 2012 #19
I wouldn't use the single metric of trading volume with Canada to measure success PETRUS Jan 2012 #7
In the US that is true, but not so much true elsewhere bhikkhu Jan 2012 #17
The data for Canada in that graph ends in the 1990's PETRUS Jan 2012 #22
The American people need to know and understand this. This is crucial to understanding the current think Jan 2012 #2
Who do we vote for if we want to see NAFTA renegotiated??? Obama gave us "free trade" with Korea Romulox Jan 2012 #3
Maybe he'll give us a second chance by promising that again. It worked the first time. AnotherMcIntosh Jan 2012 #26
A big shout-out to Bill Clinton on that one. nt Snotcicles Jan 2012 #4
And to William Daley who helped Clinton get a sufficient number of Democratic votes to approve it. AnotherMcIntosh Jan 2012 #27
+1 Snotcicles Jan 2012 #29
How the three main trade partners applied the profits of expanded trade might be instructive: bhikkhu Jan 2012 #11
Care to answer questions re: your outrageous assertions, upthread? You don't sound more Romulox Jan 2012 #12
I didn't think they were outrageous, though I know its not a conventional viewpoint bhikkhu Jan 2012 #21
You are ignoring issues like: massive violence, corruption, inequality, and millions of economic Romulox Jan 2012 #23
Good points. AnotherMcIntosh Jan 2012 #28
The reality is far less rosy than you seem to think. PETRUS Jan 2012 #16
Your argument misses one very important fact Zalatix Jan 2012 #24
Here's another thread on a similar issue: Heywood J Jan 2012 #25
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The Truth About the North...»Reply #5