Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ProfessorGAC

(76,960 posts)
36. I Read Them
Sun Nov 1, 2020, 12:17 PM
Nov 2020

They do not fully support your contention.
Were they working on a nuke? Obviously, yes. They had plans & blueprints.
Did they have a small lump of uranium? Yes. Was it enough for a device in those days? No.
Were they building an enrichment centrifuge? Yes. One, not yet finished when they needed 15 or 20 dozen.
On many prior readings on this subject, their plan was a gun barrel U-235 based device like Little Boy. Little Boy had 140+ pounds of 98.7% enriched U-235. The cube mentioned in one of the cites would have weigh roughly a pound. The technology didn't exist then to get 1 pound to critical mass.
As to the economic infrastructure, the Manhattan Project cost about 0.7% of the entire expenditure for WW2. Japan only had a GDP of about $24 billion. They were already spending 75% of GDP on the war.
They didn't have another 8% to do what the US had.
They also lacked the electrical infrastructure to process all that uranium due to the bombing campaigns.
Lastly, raw material was a gigantic problem. It requires 140# of high quality ore to get 1# of 90% or higher fissile product.
They did not have access to a ton of quality ore. It's very rare in Japan, and they didn't have control, after 1942, of any region with reasonable ore deposits.
Your cites clearly confirm they had a plan, understood the science, and were actively pursuing a nuclear weapon.
They don't cover feasibility or probability of success.
If they had the money, they were at least 3 years away (likely closer to 5), and they didn't have the economic resources.
They were not even close.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Well done, voters! ananda Oct 2020 #1
Good for them. Fuck the cops. LizBeth Oct 2020 #2
Tell me again how white people are supposed to be scared because black people are going to invade tulipsandroses Oct 2020 #3
Exactly. The hypocrisy is stifling. nt iluvtennis Oct 2020 #16
The projection ... soldierant Oct 2020 #23
+ agree.nt iluvtennis Nov 2020 #32
Rt for Democracy! Cha Oct 2020 #4
Another video clip that makes me want to move to another country. madaboutharry Oct 2020 #5
I live in another country and this all is just stressing me the fuck out Celerity Oct 2020 #9
For the record, neither the Nazis nor the Empire of the Sun where anywhere near having nukes localroger Oct 2020 #12
WaPo - How Nazi Germany got a lot closer to building a nuclear weapon in WWII Celerity Oct 2020 #13
Article is misleading localroger Nov 2020 #28
You twisted my words, that article backs me up Celerity Nov 2020 #33
LA Times - New evidence of Japan's effort to build atom bomb at the end of WWII Celerity Oct 2020 #15
Even more misleading localroger Nov 2020 #29
You twisted my words, that article backs me up Celerity Nov 2020 #34
They Were Not Remotely Close ProfessorGAC Nov 2020 #30
The poster I replied to twisted my words, these articles back up what I actually said Celerity Nov 2020 #35
I Read Them ProfessorGAC Nov 2020 #36
Starting to does not equate to imminent nt Celerity Nov 2020 #37
Those cops should be fired! n/t angstlessk Oct 2020 #6
My hometown, disgusted! MagickMuffin Oct 2020 #7
Too many low-info rednecks here :(. Sad to say Laura PourMeADrink Oct 2020 #8
i'd like to drive through some lines of drumpf voters with my Biden Harris flag Takket Oct 2020 #10
thanks for the chuckle. very well said my friend orleans Oct 2020 #17
Get your bitch ass out of here for good. Trump Trash. Pepsidog Oct 2020 #11
That was weird. JohnnyRingo Oct 2020 #14
Escorted by police? RussBLib Oct 2020 #18
I bet the trumper in the SUV had to powerwash the drivers seat. It is not the 1950s trumper irisblue Oct 2020 #19
History repeating itself orangecrush Oct 2020 #20
The Worst Part About It All Is That the Ft. Worth Cops Were Complicit in Voter Intimidation panfluteman Oct 2020 #21
If they had not been there to provide a barrier, there could have been a serious incident yellowdogintexas Nov 2020 #27
And they wonder why people want them to be defunded... Rice4VP Oct 2020 #22
+1 Crowman2009 Nov 2020 #26
Shortly after the 2016 election, I predicted that there would be gunfire in the streets. BobTheSubgenius Nov 2020 #24
Not a far fetched scenario at all. This wasn't the first incident of these knuckleheads going tulipsandroses Nov 2020 #41
Wow MustLoveBeagles Nov 2020 #25
Proving once again why law enforcement needs to be fumigated Vivienne235729 Nov 2020 #31
Get yo ass outta here! BusyBeingBest Nov 2020 #38
K&R Blue Owl Nov 2020 #39
Nazis protecting Nazis. dalton99a Nov 2020 #40
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Pro Trump caravan, escort...»Reply #36