Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Caliman73

(11,767 posts)
75. No such thing.
Wed May 26, 2021, 01:55 PM
May 2021

Whenever someone says, "Anti-White racism" or "Reverse racism" they show that they are making a bad faith argument OR they are incredibly ignorant and stupid.

Racism is both the belief that one's race is inherently superior to another AND the structural power to enforce that superiority through practice (laws, customs, traditions, etc...). We can all have racial bias, racist beliefs, prejudices, and we can discriminate. Racism however, as a practice, involves attitudes and power.

Now, Mayor Lightfoot certainly has authority in Chicago as the mayor, BUT the power structure in society still firmly rests within Whiteness. Mayor Lightfoot can certainly be argued to have engaged in unfair discrimination. Though I personally don't think that encouraging more diversity by advantaging journalists from historically marginalized groups for one day is really a significant discriminatory practice. Obviously, if she makes it an ongoing thing, then there needs to be more discussion about that.

I fall into the camp of people who think Gabbard is just doing what many "former liberals" do when they are found to be wanting within liberal circles. They veer hard right with respect to identity. There is little, more lucrative than siding with the White power structure to combat the scourge of marginalized people trying to bring awareness to the struggle for equality. They love, or at least loved Dave Rubin, a gay man arguing how intolerant the left is ... or Candace Owens, a Black woman, arguing how "Democrats have Black people on the Plantation". Gabbard is hoping they will love her for attacking Lightfoot.

I will say that Lightfoot's tweets are pretty poorly expressed. She could have made the observation better by saying that while progress is ongoing, there is still a dominance of White media, and that needs to be addressed. She could have pointed to the diversity and announced her wanting to give more diverse experiences more prominence on this day. Of course anything that she would have said with respect to this topic would have drawn outrage from right wingers. Then some liberals would see the outrage and said, hmm there may be something valid to that, and criticized her anyway.

So, bottom line though, anyone using those terms, "Anti-White racism" and "Reverse racism" in the United States, is making a bad faith argument and should be duly ridiculed.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I HAD forgotten 😄 about her....STFU, Tulsi! electric_blue68 May 2021 #1
Tulsi Who? Is that Gen. Gogol's Agent Sux? TheBlackAdder May 2021 #52
Is Gabbard still trying to convince us she is a Dem? ExciteBike66 May 2021 #2
No...she's just an attention whore... diverdownjt May 2021 #13
Yikes! Mike Nelson May 2021 #3
Tulsi has a sad that the Boeberts, MTGs are getting too much attention and she hasn't been hlthe2b May 2021 #4
Ho-hum! NurseJackie May 2021 #5
LOL, the person who said Hillary Clinton was "queen of the warmongers, embodiment betsuni May 2021 #6
While she and Nina Turner are such long and "dear friends." Hortensis May 2021 #57
Tulsi aside, it was certainly terrible optics for Lightfoot oldsoftie May 2021 #7
Agreed Maine Abu El Banat May 2021 #10
Agreed, was foolish and a gift on a silver platter to right-wing hotheads Amishman May 2021 #14
She could have gone on for years not calling on them in press conferences.... diverdownjt May 2021 #15
You can always tell who doesn't read the article. nt RandiFan1290 May 2021 #20
For One Day? ProfessorGAC May 2021 #51
i'd like to see someone on du catsudon May 2021 #54
Silly! ProfessorGAC May 2021 #56
Lol oldsoftie May 2021 #60
yep see how fast catsudon May 2021 #62
LOL. /nt tonedevil May 2021 #63
Yes, thats why i said regardless of the point she was trying to make oldsoftie May 2021 #59
To Quote A Movie Line... ProfessorGAC May 2021 #66
Totally agree! nt Raine May 2021 #65
I tend to agree Skittles May 2021 #71
Mayor Lightfoot's move has been seen by most on the left and the right as a mucifer May 2021 #8
Don't care at all Bullfeathers May 2021 #9
Hopefully that term won't stick bucolic_frolic May 2021 #11
Who? 2naSalit May 2021 #12
That was my knee-jerk response too. NEOBuckeye May 2021 #16
Shit-stirring for attention. 2naSalit May 2021 #17
Just the facts!!!!! 40RatRod May 2021 #18
'cringe' ... marble falls May 2021 #19
We saw a "Tulsi 2020" billboard mountain grammy May 2021 #21
Tulsi Gabbard and the journalist interviews aside frazzled May 2021 #22
That's So Culture Blind colsohlibgal May 2021 #23
And why the need to point out that shes a Lesbian? oldsoftie May 2021 #24
The source is LGBTQ Nation. TwilightZone May 2021 #27
Because Tulsi Gabbard is a well-known HOMOPHOBE tenderfoot May 2021 #28
That, too. TwilightZone May 2021 #31
Tulsa's nuts and the mayor is hopelessly bad at politics. BannonsLiver May 2021 #25
She thinks she is prominent enough? LiberalFighter May 2021 #26
Gabbard is correct. Devil Child May 2021 #29
Huh, her one DU fan is still around. TwilightZone May 2021 #32
Yes. Devil Child May 2021 #34
You think Gabbard is right in calling Mayor Lightfoot a racist? What else is she right about? marble falls May 2021 #36
Yes, I agree with Gabbard's characterization of Lightfoots proposal Devil Child May 2021 #38
So you agree with Gabbard: Mayor lightfoot is a racist. marble falls May 2021 #39
Hell if I know, I'm not a mind-reader. I'll give Lightfoot the benefit of the doubt Devil Child May 2021 #40
Taking one day to only take questions from minority reporters in a room with reporters from ... marble falls May 2021 #41
Post removed Post removed May 2021 #42
Where does the "fuck-off white reporter day" come from? You. How does that make Lightfoot ... marble falls May 2021 #43
Yes, it came from me. Devil Child May 2021 #44
So explain how Mayor Lightfoot's one day afirmative action program was a racist. marble falls May 2021 #48
I love how the same people who insist people of color should never accuse white people of racism StarfishSaver May 2021 #50
+1 rogue emissary May 2021 #58
Who? nt Tommy Carcetti May 2021 #30
Lightfoot certainly upset the WHITE SUPREMACISTS among us. tenderfoot May 2021 #33
And how! See above. marble falls May 2021 #47
Same hackneyed complaints about no_hypocrisy May 2021 #35
And as always, conservatives lie to pump up the outrage. Solly Mack May 2021 #37
Tulsi white again? Iggo May 2021 #45
In this case she's correct Polybius May 2021 #46
Oh yeah? It's not racist. Calling it racist trivializes racism. A whole class of reporters? marble falls May 2021 #49
And if the opposite happened, it wouldn't be racist? Polybius May 2021 #68
Specifically, are you speaking of an actual occurrence? How are both that the same? As a "class" ... marble falls May 2021 #70
She didn't exclude an entire race of reporters. StarfishSaver May 2021 #53
Can you name one Mayor over the last 40 years that publicly called for the opposite? Polybius May 2021 #67
If you knew anything about institutional racism, you'd never ask such a question StarfishSaver May 2021 #69
A black male in his 40's in NY doesn't know about institutional racism? Polybius May 2021 #72
Lots of Black people don't understand institutional racism StarfishSaver May 2021 #73
I know what racism is when I see it Polybius May 2021 #74
Nobody cares what you think Tulsi mcar May 2021 #55
In her final days in office Gabbard tried to push through anti lgbtq legislation JI7 May 2021 #61
Tulski? Toddle on back to your cult leader & tell him you're not The One... Hekate May 2021 #64
No such thing. Caliman73 May 2021 #75
Enlightnen me if I'm wrong The Mouth May 2021 #76
There are a lot of terms that have become "interchangeable". Caliman73 May 2021 #77
Thanks The Mouth May 2021 #78
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Tulsi Gabbard accuses Bla...»Reply #75