Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mathematic

(1,439 posts)
20. This is just the opposite side of making this a culture war issue
Thu Jul 29, 2021, 12:46 PM
Jul 2021

Biles withdrew from the competition because she was unable to perform. She was not making a political statement. She was not fighting for mental health rights. She failed her vault, realized she didn't have it that day, and withdrew.

Conservatives have been using sports to fight the culture war for generations. Black athletes have been using sports to make political statements for generations. This was only one of those things. It wasn't revolutionary because Biles was making a sport decision for the best outcome of the team.

She is not prioritizing her health and safety. If she were doing so she would have retired after 2016, a champion and a millionaire. Being a world class athlete is bad for your health. This is all post hoc justification for her having a bad night and pulling herself from competition, which was a justifiable action if she felt she couldn't perform considering USA gymnastics has a great team and could still win the gold without her.

The olympics is not "just another day on the job" for Simone Biles, that's you and your spin, promoting the issues and framing you think are important. Did you even watch the event? When I take a day off work, I'm not in tears. Biles was devastated. Pulling herself from the event was indeed a rational decision. I'd characterize it as mature and selfless because it wasn't for her health or safety. It was because on that day, in her judgement, the three other american women had a better chance to win gold without her.

Simone Rules Goonch Jul 2021 #1
I suspect a white gymnast would get more sympathy from the CONservatives & those 3 in 1st para. . nt Bernardo de La Paz Jul 2021 #2
Oh definitely Bucky Jul 2021 #4
They way they think Traildogbob Jul 2021 #3
+1 ancianita Jul 2021 #6
THIS n/t malaise Jul 2021 #8
100% racist bullshit. joshcryer Jul 2021 #12
actually CatWoman Jul 2021 #14
I think that's what that poster was indicating. joshcryer Jul 2021 #18
Thank you. I tried to say it best I could. Bucky Jul 2021 #21
Give her some peace. twodogsbarking Jul 2021 #5
Remember "No mas"? There are times when you've made your point and there's no sense... TreasonousBastard Jul 2021 #7
And at great cost to herself. She was in an impossible position, where whatever Scrivener7 Jul 2021 #9
Great summary! Another important aspect: it's attention to mental health and well being fishwax Jul 2021 #10
Yes Bucky Jul 2021 #11
Biles' fatal error was calling her problem "mental" when even the Olympics called it "medical." Rocknation Jul 2021 #13
This distinction needs to be buried. Claire Oh Nette Jul 2021 #22
I agree and would add Naomi Osaka to that list as well. PunkinPi Jul 2021 #15
I dare say Osaka's mental health issues Rocknation Jul 2021 #17
Well, biracial people face "not being enough" from ignorant folks all the time and... PunkinPi Jul 2021 #19
That little tory boy Piers only sees a minstrel show Dawson Leery Jul 2021 #16
This is just the opposite side of making this a culture war issue mathematic Jul 2021 #20
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The more I think about it...»Reply #20