Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

IowaGuy

(788 posts)
Fri Sep 3, 2021, 03:28 PM Sep 2021

Re: the Texas abortion law...strategies on how to fight? [View all]

Yeah, I get why everybody is jumping up and down with their hair on fire about this, justifiably so.
But bottom line, we are where we are at and just saying fight harder isn't helping much. What are some concrete ideas on what can be done?
I was thinking any suit brought should be countered with a lawsuit alleging possession of stolen property. Your medical records belong to you and can only be accessed by the people you deem appropriate and only for the uses you identify (HIPAA). Anybody bringing such a suit would have to identify how they legally obtained such information. This law also does not in anyway circumvent Roe Vs Wade's determination of a constitutional right to privacy. Bringing such an action in a court of law clearly would violate that. It seems conspiracy charges for accepting such obviously stolen info for the purposes of personal financial gain while violating a constitutional right to privacy would be an easy case to bring, both in Civil and criminal courts. Such legal liability would easily be greater than the 10,000 buck payout people think they would get.
Any thoughts on this idea or any others that could be used to hit back at these assholes?

23 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Boycott companies based in Texas. Johonny Sep 2021 #1
No ideas myself, but there are greater minds. hamsterjill Sep 2021 #2
I read that the lawsuits are free. No court costs LeftInTX Sep 2021 #5
I don't think they thought this through. hamsterjill Sep 2021 #9
It would seem to me anybody that participated in the scheme to file a lawsuit IowaGuy Sep 2021 #7
Will they get a 1099-MISC income form hamsterjill Sep 2021 #10
I was just looking at a site that came up on my Facebook page. vanlassie Sep 2021 #3
And that is how it is done... sanatanadharma Sep 2021 #14
yeah qazplm135 Sep 2021 #4
Depends on your goal. WhiskeyGrinder Sep 2021 #6
Your medical records aren't shielded during litigation. They'll be released to court Arazi Sep 2021 #8
I like it. hamsterjill Sep 2021 #11
The women aren't being sued. Anyone who helped her get an abortion gets sued Arazi Sep 2021 #13
No, I think the woman can be sued, as well. hamsterjill Sep 2021 #15
And each and every person sued, could countersue and allege that the basis of the original IowaGuy Sep 2021 #17
The more the merrier Arazi Sep 2021 #18
Yup!! IowaGuy Sep 2021 #19
Even if the woman isn't being sued, if they allege something to be true in court which isn't IowaGuy Sep 2021 #20
No. 2 is a good idea IowaGuy Sep 2021 #12
I love this! hamsterjill Sep 2021 #16
No medical records belong to the Doctor or clinic. twin_ghost Sep 2021 #21
Here is some clarification on that... IowaGuy Sep 2021 #22
The HIPPA penalties will neutralize the bounty payment. vanlassie Sep 2021 #23
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Re: the Texas abortion la...