Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Josiesdad

(65 posts)
31. The premise in this thread is absolutely spot on...
Sun Sep 5, 2021, 12:29 PM
Sep 2021

Forget what you think you know about constitutionally protected activities granted by our federal constitution. These actions protect citizens against actions by state actors. The Texas law has pulled back the thin veneer of these protections and has allowed the constitutionally protected activities to be controlled by bypassing the constitution completely and creating a common law tort centered around activities that enable abortions.

So be it. If this is the constitutional model that the Federalist society wants to be the norm for the rest of this century then bring it on. If they are now saying that the federal constitution is no longer primary then let's create torts that allows citizens to litigate and sue to collect damages in the case of federal bribery (aka lobbying activities) or perhaps it could be come a tort to transport or sell firearms. Or on the other side perhaps it becomes a tort to offer food and water to people that are standing in line to cast their vote.

The possibilities are literally endless.

It has been an unstated goal of the Republicans and the Federalist society to weaken the power of the trial lawyers... It looks like they don't care about that any more.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Maybe we could have a Constitutional Convention and BlueGreenLady Sep 2021 #1
For a lot of reasons, I don't think we want a constitutional convention rurallib Sep 2021 #11
A Constitutional Convention is on the agenda of every RW billionaire. xxqqqzme Sep 2021 #20
+1 2naSalit Sep 2021 #22
EXACTLY! That would unfortunately open a can of MAGA-gots. As other have said the billionaire dream. usaf-vet Sep 2021 #24
Yep. They're prepped and ready for a new CC, and would end up running the show. JHB Sep 2021 #32
I like it. Also, use the approach for gun control and men having sex with underaged girls. NCjack Sep 2021 #2
THIS!!! We ALL have standing against guns, not so much abortion or lobbying. nt joetheman Sep 2021 #18
Probably be a blue state that would be able to pass something like this MichMan Sep 2021 #3
A chance worth taking... I suspect the SCOTUS would not take a pass on this one though berni_mccoy Sep 2021 #4
Right. Because ancianita Sep 2021 #13
It would have to be a RED state... lame54 Sep 2021 #5
I think it should be done with mask mandates! LeftInTX Sep 2021 #6
You are incorrect - Texas DID make abortion after a fetal heartbeat illegal.. Ms. Toad Sep 2021 #7
Why isn't a doctor defying the law AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #8
Thanks for the correction. I edited to correct. berni_mccoy Sep 2021 #9
Then don't detect AncientOfDays Sep 2021 #30
They thought of that Ms. Toad Sep 2021 #33
or better yet yaesu Sep 2021 #10
Awkward Diraven Sep 2021 #26
Or pass a similar law wryter2000 Sep 2021 #12
I think there is judicial precedent iemanja Sep 2021 #14
Political campaigning is not part of their job berni_mccoy Sep 2021 #16
Or every woman can incorporate as a IVF business, with dr., driver, nurse, etc., as employees. ancianita Sep 2021 #15
Bring it on! BlueIdaho Sep 2021 #17
Maybe a blue state could say $10,000 reward bluestarone Sep 2021 #19
I was actually thinking about this earlier Diraven Sep 2021 #27
Not that the SCOTUS is above twisting logic like taffey, but I think that is what saved the ACA. LT Barclay Sep 2021 #21
This message was self-deleted by its author TZ617 Sep 2021 #23
K&R Blue Owl Sep 2021 #25
No comparison to Texas. brooklynite Sep 2021 #28
Both are tested actions ruled protected by the Constitution berni_mccoy Sep 2021 #29
The premise in this thread is absolutely spot on... Josiesdad Sep 2021 #31
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Just ONE State Could Unwi...»Reply #31