General Discussion

AZSkiffyGeek

(12,744 posts)

145. That's at the bottom of Stevie Nicks Mac tunes for me

Fri Sep 17, 2021, 12:05 PM

Sep 2021

I can't see how it scored higher than "Landslide," (or "Silver Spring," but that song is always overlooked) and I don't even think that should be Top 10.

And it's DEFINITELY not better than "God Only Knows" or "Waterloo Sunset."

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

205 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Rolling Stone updates 500 Greatest Songs of All Time list with big changes, new No. 1 [View all] demmiblue Sep 2021 OP

Interesting hibbing Sep 2021 #1

No flaming from me. It's obvious that the two of us were not consulted abqtommy Sep 2021 #8

It's an outrage!! hehe hibbing Sep 2021 #19

I Wasn't Consulted Either RobinA Sep 2021 #197

That's OK. Rolling Stone is one of the most overrated publications in history. NNadir Sep 2021 #18

It died 40 years ago and became total irrelevant, IMHO Dakota Flint Sep 2021 #51

This message was self-deleted by its author Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #70

Agreed. Nirvana is the most overrated of all time. CrackityJones75 Sep 2021 #66

I'm thinking #5. Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #72

Music is super subjective BannonsLiver Sep 2021 #138

Motley Crue Ahpook Sep 2021 #193

The most overrated band ever has two songs on that list by my count Amishman Sep 2021 #186

Nothing at all by Led Zeppelin? True Dough Sep 2021 #2

No Stairway? Aristus Sep 2021 #3

How many years have you been plotting to use that clip, Aristus? True Dough Sep 2021 #10

Many, many years. Aristus Sep 2021 #12

Just one other thing to add... True Dough Sep 2021 #15

Stairway to Heaven is #61. n/t demmiblue Sep 2021 #7

surius. NT Happy Hoosier Sep 2021 #25

They hate and have always hated Led Zeppelin Johonny Sep 2021 #196

Seems Ok, Except... ProfessorGAC Sep 2021 #4

Disagree. It was a worldwide crossover hit with a visionary video, it's spawned countless remixes WhiskeyGrinder Sep 2021 #22

I love it, but Top 10? AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #28

How about Hallelujah? Polybius Sep 2021 #200

They put Cohen's version on the list AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #202

I meant in the top 20 Polybius Sep 2021 #204

We'll Agree To Disagree ProfessorGAC Sep 2021 #37

"Work It" by Missy was 1,000 times better Polybius Sep 2021 #199

Boy. Did Rolling Stone blow that, or what? BComplex Sep 2021 #5

I'd agree that "Respect" and "Gimme Shelter" probably belong in the top 20. Doubts about highplainsdem Sep 2021 #11

Oh, I think Marvin Gaye's should be even higher than it is. llmart Sep 2021 #151

Waterloo Sunset. #14. What a fantastic song. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #6

I'd never heard of it underpants Sep 2021 #14

Lol, I had never heard this song. WhiskeyGrinder Sep 2021 #16

Same here TexasTowelie Sep 2021 #20

I bought the single when I first heard it on the radio in 1967 Tom Rinaldo Sep 2021 #38

Over 50 classic rock fan TheDemsshouldhireme Sep 2021 #57

That's why I'm amazed it was #14. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #73

I was lucky to see Elliot Smith cover it shortly before his suicide. maxsolomon Sep 2021 #142

This whole list is bs. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #144

Well, if the purpose is clickbait (it usually is these days) maxsolomon Sep 2021 #148

It is overlooked now, but I do think it is Ray's finest songwriting AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #149

I agree. Well Respected Man is also great. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #150

The Kinks' album run from Something Else through Muswell Hillbillies.... AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #152

Yep. I was fortunate to see them in the 70's LakeArenal Sep 2021 #156

Top 20 album for me for sure AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #158

Kindred 🎶 spirit. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #161

Good song, but when we're talking "great" I imagine the metrics should be... Goodheart Sep 2021 #74

Lola, Well Respected Man, or Apeman before WS LakeArenal Sep 2021 #76

"Death of a Clown"?? bullwinkle428 Sep 2021 #112

Strangers is my favorite Dave song AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #153

The Kinks could have had many more on it Norbert Sep 2021 #81

Amazed even. LakeArenal Sep 2021 #84

Its the "Of All Time" claim that is both annoying and comical Otto_Harper Sep 2021 #9

Richard Thompson does a "1000 Years of Popular Music" show AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #30

Message auto-removed Name removed Sep 2021 #131

Yes! geardaddy Sep 2021 #64

What about Leader of the Laundromat? Not ranked? Unfair Champp Sep 2021 #13

I'd say that brings back memories but really nilram Sep 2021 #52

LOL llmart Sep 2021 #159

I'm getting old. I only like one of the top ten songs. nt TexasTowelie Sep 2021 #17

Nirvana?! radicalleft Sep 2021 #21

Yeah, that's fine. Lots of us don't agree with you. NT Happy Hoosier Sep 2021 #26

Lol USALiberal Sep 2021 #29

Incredibly insightful. LanternWaste Sep 2021 #62

It appears some songs are ones that had an impact on future music C Moon Sep 2021 #55

I agree with you 100%! Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #77

Totally disagree - music does not have to make you feel good FreeState Sep 2021 #95

Music can be many things but, Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #96

Wow.... how analytical. Happy Hoosier Sep 2021 #166

+1 Celerity Sep 2021 #103

Yeah, I can see how these songs can make you feel good Bongo Prophet Sep 2021 #98

The presentations and productions are vastly different. Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #99

'Music is supposed to make you feel good.' Celerity Sep 2021 #102

list your favourite bands please Celerity Sep 2021 #101

Well as a Gen Xer, heavy metal from the 70's and 80's ranks up there radicalleft Sep 2021 #114

As A Gen Xer Who Was Deeply Entrenched In The 80's-90's Metal Scene;... ruet Sep 2021 #177

I wonder if there will be a new version of that old joke AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #181

I'm an Xer, and while I hated them too, it belongs there Polybius Sep 2021 #203

Well, opinions and all, but NOPE. NT Happy Hoosier Sep 2021 #23

No "My Pal Foot Foot"? No Peace! gratuitous Sep 2021 #24

Oh man, that and It's Halloween geardaddy Sep 2021 #60

Now I will have that annoying, Fleetwood Mac: "Dreams" earworm LeftInTX Sep 2021 #27

I really dislike that song. Goodheart Sep 2021 #63

Fleetwood mac had so many better songs tinymontgomery Sep 2021 #97

That's at the bottom of Stevie Nicks Mac tunes for me AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #145

A lot of the folks who liked Rolling Stone's 500GSAT from 17 years ago are probably dead now. sop Sep 2021 #31

For me, the Beatles take the top ten spots. Cartoonist Sep 2021 #32

no Celerity Sep 2021 #104

I agree Poiuyt Sep 2021 #108

I think... Mike Nelson Sep 2021 #33

Just mistakes from the Beatles tracks alone... Moostache Sep 2021 #34

While I agree there are better Beatles songs xmas74 Sep 2021 #130

These lists are stupid and annoying Mysterian Sep 2021 #35

Absolutely, yes. YES! Jansen Sep 2021 #58

yes, and the same can be said about many of the replies here (NOT yours) Celerity Sep 2021 #107

Outkast at #10 with "Hey Ya"?!?! WTMF??? Roland99 Sep 2021 #36

Been to a wedding in the last 20 years? maxsolomon Sep 2021 #85

Popularity is not quality Roland99 Sep 2021 #87

Except that "Hey Ya" is good. AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #154

No. It's bad. Real bad Roland99 Sep 2021 #169

Nah, but it's not as good as BOB or Ms. Jackson AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #170

So is "All the Single Ladies" at most wedding receptions. llmart Sep 2021 #163

YES IT DOES. maxsolomon Sep 2021 #172

IKR!? Mr. Evil Sep 2021 #86

So much Nope! 2, 3, 7, 8, 10, 14, 16, & 20 don't belong that high up at all. NightWatcher Sep 2021 #39

🙄 nt ecstatic Sep 2021 #115

Un bel di vedremo Giacomo Puccini Maria Callas marie999 Sep 2021 #40

Who the heck is Robyn and where is The Boss? (n/t) MissMillie Sep 2021 #41

dancing on my own sung by callum scott on britain's got talent. chilling msongs Sep 2021 #43

I prefer her version Rosco T. Sep 2021 #45

What a terribly edhopper Sep 2021 #127

I just listened to this song... AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #180

I love Respect Casady1 Sep 2021 #42

Here's the BEST road trip songlist Brother Buzz Sep 2021 #44

That's a hell of a road trip list, but I'd replace the Heartbreakers "Mary Jane's Last Dance" with sop Sep 2021 #46

"any intelligent person knows any decent road trip will start with ZZ Top" left-of-center2012 Sep 2021 #53

Totally agree. ShazzieB Sep 2021 #191

I like your music left-of-center2012 Sep 2021 #192

Have a Cigar Klaralven Sep 2021 #93

This message was self-deleted by its author JustABozoOnThisBus Sep 2021 #109

This message was self-deleted by its author JustABozoOnThisBus Sep 2021 #117

LOL But after he lost the original list, did he come up with the same one the second time around? Princess Turandot Sep 2021 #140

Life would be boring if things didn't change Brother Buzz Sep 2021 #155

Fight the Power isn't even a top 5 Public Enemy song. nt LexVegas Sep 2021 #47

Some I never heard of -- Some I never liked left-of-center2012 Sep 2021 #48

But WHICH version of Respect? DFW Sep 2021 #49

I'm surprised that Purple Rain isn't in the top 10 geardaddy Sep 2021 #50

THIS!!! MontanaMama Sep 2021 #59

Yep. geardaddy Sep 2021 #61

I'm listening through the list right now AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #188

Great call on Strange Fruit! geardaddy Sep 2021 #195

Perfect Roy Rolling Sep 2021 #54

That list is embarrassingly bad. Goodheart Sep 2021 #56

It is laughable left-of-center2012 Sep 2021 #67

Want to know just how ridiculous it is? Goodheart Sep 2021 #71

"Bridge Over Troubled Water" left-of-center2012 Sep 2021 #75

Don't know if I'd make it #1... llmart Sep 2021 #165

Both sides now was written and first recorded by Judy Collins GusBob Sep 2021 #79

It was written by Joni Mitchell, first recorded by Judy Collins. Goodheart Sep 2021 #82

Now that's confusing...LOL LeftInTX Sep 2021 #89

Even more so when you learn that Joni didn't like the way Judy sang it. LOL Goodheart Sep 2021 #90

Thanks for the detailed review. Nt USALiberal Sep 2021 #118

Bizarre Love Triangle is certainly the greatest song of all time. Goodheart Sep 2021 #65

for New Order, I would go with Temptation Celerity Sep 2021 #106

My favorite New Order song changes from day to day Goodheart Sep 2021 #133

Did you fuse these two personally? Goodheart Sep 2021 #134

No, I do not post on YT. nt Celerity Sep 2021 #136

I like both Temptation and Bizzare Love Triangle AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #146

They're fucking high. Iggo Sep 2021 #68

the Bat's cover from 1984 shreds Celerity Sep 2021 #105

Bruce rules Rolling Stone drools bronxiteforever Sep 2021 #69

He never had a number 1 hit! Nt USALiberal Sep 2021 #120

Lol! Marconi played the mamba. N.t. bronxiteforever Sep 2021 #143

This list is "sort of" greatest songs, but more so cultural impact songs. For example... themaguffin Sep 2021 #78

How are My Generation, Baba O'Reilly, or Won't Get Fooled Again maxrandb Sep 2021 #80

Having a song written by Otis Redding in the top 20 is great and all (especially that song, sung by deurbano Sep 2021 #83

Me and Bobby McGee lpbk2713 Sep 2021 #88

None of those make my top 20. My number 1 of all time GoodRaisin Sep 2021 #91

Where is Thunder Road? ThunderRoad Sep 2021 #92

It is on the list, but lower AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #157

RS is trying to diversify. maxsolomon Sep 2021 #94

This list shows how little they understand, really. yardwork Sep 2021 #111

Lol, so they know nothing about music? Nt USALiberal Sep 2021 #121

Those who voted don't edhopper Sep 2021 #129

They're trying to appeal to a difference audience LeftInTX Sep 2021 #171

Every one of us would make a different list. maxsolomon Sep 2021 #141

Current musicians and industry figures are the ones who voted on the songs AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #189

this was number one on some list a few years ago Demovictory9 Sep 2021 #100

Message auto-removed Name removed Sep 2021 #110

Freddie is looking down at this self important publication list tavernier Sep 2021 #113

No Michael Jackson, Whitney Houston, Mariah Carey or Boyz II Men? ecstatic Sep 2021 #116

I've never even heard 1/2 these songs. Calista241 Sep 2021 #119

Where is "Making Love in A Subaru"? Dirty Socialist Sep 2021 #122

I'm kinda surprised that there's quite a few I've never heard of fescuerescue Sep 2021 #123

No Bob Marley? WTF? Opinions are like a$$holes. Everybody has one. nt Roisin Ni Fiachra Sep 2021 #124

I hate to open a can of worms, but Dirty Socialist Sep 2021 #125

The list doesn't specify Rock and Roll AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #160

Bah! Humbug! panader0 Sep 2021 #126

Message auto-removed Name removed Sep 2021 #128

Quite embarsssing edhopper Sep 2021 #132

Robyn's Dancing on my Own?1!! Not as good as the worst ABBA song. SYFROYH Sep 2021 #135

I really like that song. Maybe it depends on whose leftyladyfrommo Sep 2021 #173

Hey Ya! sucks. BannonsLiver Sep 2021 #137

Message auto-removed Name removed Sep 2021 #139

No Jimi Hendrix? jalan48 Sep 2021 #147

He is in the top 500... Happy Hoosier Sep 2021 #167

I was thinking they would lean toward the most influential artists. Oh well, The Best always jalan48 Sep 2021 #178

My definition of greatest and theirs is much different ... Lucinda Sep 2021 #162

Whaaaattt? No Nicki Menaj? A poet and wordsmith like her left off? Shame!!! albacore Sep 2021 #164

Rolling Stone magazine came out in 1967 llmart Sep 2021 #168

Was Disturbed's Sound of Silence on there? leftyladyfrommo Sep 2021 #174

Disturbed? ruet Sep 2021 #175

David Draiman is wonderful when he's not doing leftyladyfrommo Sep 2021 #176

Just Watched It. If I Heard it Without Knowing Anything Else About It,... ruet Sep 2021 #179

At least you tried. I am kind 8f surprised leftyladyfrommo Sep 2021 #184

An Internal Bias I Can't Correct For. -NT- ruet Sep 2021 #185

David Draiman is an incredible person. leftyladyfrommo Sep 2021 #187

sad to say i do not know all of these songs nt orleans Sep 2021 #182

Why is "Don't Fear the Reaper" 446, while Hall and Oates, "She's Gone" 336? LeftInTX Sep 2021 #183

The whole lsit on Spotify... AZSkiffyGeek Sep 2021 #190

uugh Shellback Squid Sep 2021 #194

Seriously, "Hey Ya" by Outcast is 10?!? Polybius Sep 2021 #198

That rag has sucked for half a century. miyazaki Sep 2021 #201

Great list. I love it. Captain Stern Sep 2021 #205