Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Several legal pundits are saying former presidents can't invoke executive privilege. That's not true [View all]LetMyPeopleVote
(145,086 posts)20. Biden White House leans toward releasing information about Trump and Jan. 6 attack, setting off lega
You are ignoring the fact that the material being disclosed relates to a potential criminal investigation. Executive privilege does allow one to hide material that is relevant to a criminal investigation
Link to tweet
While Trump has struck a defiant tone, his options may be limited if Biden decides to hand over the information the former president says should be protected, according to several legal experts including those who have reviewed similar requests in the past.
The law we have is not favorable to the former president, said Bob Bauer, who served as White House counsel under President Barack Obama. A former president has a chance to review the materials, to raise issues of privilege and if the former and the current presidents cannot reach some agreement, to take the dispute to the courts.
Bauer added that while an inquiry into a former president is unique, legal precedents suggest disclosure of the information Congress is seeking.
The circumstances here the former president acting at the time in his capacity as a candidate seeking to challenge his defeat at the polls make this uphill battle much, much tougher, he said.
Donald McGahn tells House panel about Trumps bid to undermine Mueller probe
Norm Eisen, a former Obama administration official who advised the first House impeachment inquiry of Trump, said the former presidents power to assert executive privilege has weakened since he left the White House.
The executive privilege stonewalling that Trump used while he was in office wont work anymore, Eisen said, noting that the current president not the former has the real decision-making power.
A former federal judge who worked on executive privilege issues in the Reagan White House and the George H.W. Bush Justice Department pointed out that privilege requests do not typically attempt to shield information about potential wrongdoing.
With a few notable exceptions, the historical practice has been for Presidents to avoid asserting Executive Privilege to protect from disclosure information that suggests wrongdoing or potential wrongdoing by a President and/or his advisers, J. Michael Luttig, a former U.S. federal judge, said in an email.
The law we have is not favorable to the former president, said Bob Bauer, who served as White House counsel under President Barack Obama. A former president has a chance to review the materials, to raise issues of privilege and if the former and the current presidents cannot reach some agreement, to take the dispute to the courts.
Bauer added that while an inquiry into a former president is unique, legal precedents suggest disclosure of the information Congress is seeking.
The circumstances here the former president acting at the time in his capacity as a candidate seeking to challenge his defeat at the polls make this uphill battle much, much tougher, he said.
Donald McGahn tells House panel about Trumps bid to undermine Mueller probe
Norm Eisen, a former Obama administration official who advised the first House impeachment inquiry of Trump, said the former presidents power to assert executive privilege has weakened since he left the White House.
The executive privilege stonewalling that Trump used while he was in office wont work anymore, Eisen said, noting that the current president not the former has the real decision-making power.
A former federal judge who worked on executive privilege issues in the Reagan White House and the George H.W. Bush Justice Department pointed out that privilege requests do not typically attempt to shield information about potential wrongdoing.
With a few notable exceptions, the historical practice has been for Presidents to avoid asserting Executive Privilege to protect from disclosure information that suggests wrongdoing or potential wrongdoing by a President and/or his advisers, J. Michael Luttig, a former U.S. federal judge, said in an email.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
21 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Several legal pundits are saying former presidents can't invoke executive privilege. That's not true [View all]
StarfishSaver
Sep 2021
OP
I guess this would be true even if the evidence is requested as part of a criminal investigation?
wcmagumba
Sep 2021
#1
Okay, thanks for a great explanation, I'm not a lawyer but it sounds as though drumphy
wcmagumba
Sep 2021
#9
Glad to explain it - I know it's confusing. Even skilled lawyers are getting it wrong
StarfishSaver
Sep 2021
#12
Executive Privilege and Former Presidents: Constitutional Principles and Current Application
PoliticAverse
Sep 2021
#2
It also says that is is the applied in the constitutional functions of a president
Bev54
Sep 2021
#13
Yes - that's one of the reasons I think his attempt to claim executive privilege will fail
StarfishSaver
Sep 2021
#14
I think people really under estimate how much power a former President still wields
fescuerescue
Sep 2021
#5
And the "heard to assert" fits with the rule that Trump has 60 days now to make this claim.
pnwmom
Sep 2021
#16
Biden White House leans toward releasing information about Trump and Jan. 6 attack, setting off lega
LetMyPeopleVote
Sep 2021
#20