Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Buckeye_Democrat

(15,526 posts)
47. Maybe the extra dosage?
Fri Oct 29, 2021, 06:23 PM
Oct 2021

Moderna shots provided over three times as much mRNA vaccine compared to Pfizer, which is why I wanted it months ago. The reports of worse side-effects for Moderna recipients at that time didn't matter to me, especially since none of the reactions were very serious for the vast majority of people.

Is Moderna Really Better Than Pfizer—Or Is It Just a Higher Dose?
https://www.govexec.com/management/2021/10/moderna-really-better-pfizeror-it-just-higher-dose/186435/

... A recent (but not yet peer-reviewed) study of more than half a million U.S. veterans showed that the Johnson & Johnson shot’s protection against infection (whether or not that leads to disease or hospitalization) had plummeted from 88 percent to 3 percent by mid-August, while the other vaccines’ effectiveness had declined much less. Research published in the past few months also signals that Moderna’s shot beats out Pfizer’s in terms of both antibody count and hospitalizations prevented, while a National Institutes of Health study released earlier this month found that Moderna’s booster shot lifted participants’ antibody levels a bit more than Pfizer’s, and that both mRNA boosters were miles ahead of J&J’s.

In light of all these data, it’s tempting to rank the vaccines by brand name: Moderna is better than Pfizer is better than J&J. But the same numbers hint at a different pattern: Maybe what matters most is not which vaccine you get, but how much of it.

Consider how the vaccines differ in their dosing. J&J, the least effective in the studies, has only one shot in its primary series; the mRNA vaccines have two. So anyone who got J&J (and hasn’t yet gotten a booster) received half as many doses total. Comparing Pfizer with Moderna, you see another dose difference: Each shot of Pfizer contains 30 micrograms of mRNA, while each one of Moderna contains 100. (Doses for children could also differ in size: Pfizer has proposed 10-microgram shots, while Moderna is going with 50.) Just how much of the difference in the shots’ performance can be summed up by saying “More vaccine is better”?...

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

My doctor has the same guidelines as well. gldstwmn Oct 2021 #1
I later looked up the CDC guidelines... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #3
I read that Oct 14 is the date the CDC updated their list. BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #6
Ah, thanks! I was disappointed to learn about... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #12
I learned of it yesterday, right here on DU! BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #19
I missed it! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #27
I noticed not all places are going by those guidelines but fortunately my doctor is. gldstwmn Oct 2021 #15
My doctor's staff told me... BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #21
It's so odd how standards vary by provider. gldstwmn Oct 2021 #60
These differences are keeping BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #71
I found out yesterday that I qualify for a booster BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #2
Thanks for providing the CDC link! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #5
No problem. I read that 85% of US adults BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #8
Send her a box of blintzes EYESORE 9001 Oct 2021 #28
Or I could drive her crazy since BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #29
Yeah, blintzes don't travel well anyway EYESORE 9001 Oct 2021 #32
This message was self-deleted by its author BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #30
There is a pharmacy at the front of my grocery store. zuul Oct 2021 #4
Yeah, there's probably some areas in short supply. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #10
It's easier to ask hamsterjill Oct 2021 #7
Maybe it's time to stop the charade and let anybody get it. lagomorph777 Oct 2021 #11
That would make more sense. hamsterjill Oct 2021 #13
I agree. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #14
I asked both my primary care doctor's office BigmanPigman Oct 2021 #16
See and people say we discriminate against the obese! Drunken Irishman Oct 2021 #9
Well, now the OP is overweight AND magnetic! ret5hd Oct 2021 #17
Lol! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #18
duzy KentuckyWoman Oct 2021 #58
The only caveat is that you shouldn't get it sooner than six months Ocelot II Oct 2021 #20
Yep, it'll be over six months for me. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #24
Except if you got J&J hamsterjill Oct 2021 #26
I qualify based on job but would also do so based on weight dsc Oct 2021 #22
A 5'11 male qualifies as overweight if he's at 182 lbs greenjar_01 Oct 2021 #23
It's not very accurate for wide-framed people... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #25
5'11 and 182 is not overweight even in narrow-framed people greenjar_01 Oct 2021 #31
That was certainly my impression after seeing... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #33
Those were my exact measurements when I was at my fittest in my forties Ron Obvious Oct 2021 #52
It's ludicrous greenjar_01 Oct 2021 #53
How right you are ripcord Oct 2021 #59
Crazy! So I just checked Lebron James' BMI... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #61
In the 90s a friend's health insurance threatened to cancel him ripcord Oct 2021 #62
BMI really needs to be dropped by the CDC... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #63
I got my J&J booster today madville Oct 2021 #34
Good to know they're not being overbearing about it! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #36
Everybody who got J&J is qualified for a booster, so they shouldn't even be asking how someone LisaL Oct 2021 #40
Good point! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #42
Seems like even the pharmacists are confused. LisaL Oct 2021 #44
That's how I got mine today (Moderna). All I had to let them know is that I got the J&J vax and smirkymonkey Oct 2021 #64
Everybody who got J&J vaccine is qualified for a booster. LisaL Oct 2021 #38
I had read about that but wasn't sure if it was official and trickled down yet madville Oct 2021 #45
It's official. LisaL Oct 2021 #46
Maybe the extra dosage? Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #47
Yeah I thought about it madville Oct 2021 #51
I got the Moderna booster. Beacool Oct 2021 #48
I'm happy for you! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #49
Thanks... Beacool Oct 2021 #50
CVS in Kansas didn't ask for any criteria. Nt USALiberal Oct 2021 #35
Good to know! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #37
Just the 6 month gap. Nt USALiberal Oct 2021 #39
Yep, I figured that rule would still be strictly followed. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #41
Great!! Maybe get your yearly flu shot too! Nt USALiberal Oct 2021 #68
Yes, I scheduled that too. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #69
It's 2 months for J&J. LisaL Oct 2021 #43
obesity is an underlying condition, as defined by the CDC steve2470 Oct 2021 #54
Thanks! Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #55
I qualified by being OLD KentuckyWoman Oct 2021 #56
That's my intention too. Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #57
Yep, Me Too Deep State Witch Oct 2021 #65
If only everyone could be overweight, we might... Buckeye_Democrat Oct 2021 #67
Yep, Me Too Deep State Witch Oct 2021 #66
That's how I qualified. phylny Oct 2021 #70
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I qualify for a booster s...»Reply #47