Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
Showing Original Post only (View all)Tim Wise: Of Broken Clocks, Presidential Candidates, and the Confusion of Certain White Liberals [View all]
Tim Wise's latest essay: an attempt, however sarcastic and acerbic to address the phenomenon of liberals and progressives supporting Ron Paul.
Yessir, legal weed and an end to the TSA: enough to make some supposed leftists ignore everything else Ron Paul has ever said, and ignore the fundamental incompatibility of Ayn Randian thinking with anything remotely resembling a progressive or even humane worldview. And this is so, even though he wouldnt actually have the authority to end the TSA as president, a slight glitch that is conveniently ignored by those who are desperate to once again be able to take large bottles of shaving gel onto airplanes in the name of liberty.
I want those of you who are seriously singing Pauls praises, while calling yourself progressive or left to ask what it signifies not about Ron Paul, but about you that you can look the rest of us in the eye, your political colleagues and allies, and say, in effect, Well, he might be a little racist, but
How do you think that sounds to black people, without whom no remotely progressive candidate stands a chance of winning shit in this country at a national level? How does it sound to them a group that has been more loyal to progressive and left politics than any group in this country when you praise a man who opposes probably the single most important piece of legislation ever passed in this country, and whose position on the right of businesses to discriminate, places him on the side of the segregated lunchcounter owners? And how do you think they take it that you praise this man, or possibly even support him for president, all so as to teach the black guy currently in the office a lesson for failing to live up to your expectations?
How do you think it sounds to them, right now, this week, as we prepare to mark the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday, that you claim to be progressive, and yet you are praising or even encouraging support for a man who voted against that holiday, who opposes almost every aspect of Kings public policy agenda, and the crowning achievements of the movement he helped lead?
...
In short, if youre still disappointed in Barack Obama, its only because you never understood whose job it was to produce change in the first place. But dont take out your own failings in this regard on the rest of us, by giving ideological cover and assorted journalistic love taps to a guy who believes the poor should rely on the charitable impulses of doctors to provide for their medical needs, including, one presumes, chemotherapy; or that America was meant to be a robustly Christian nation, but is being currently undermined by secularists; or who puts the term gay rights in quotation marks when he writes it, and believes states should be free to criminalize homosexual intercourse, and who is such a homophobe that he wont even use the bathroom in a gay mans house; or who has all but said that he would like to take America back to the early 1800s, in terms of the scope of government: a truly glorious time to be sure, if you were white, male and owned property.
I want those of you who are seriously singing Pauls praises, while calling yourself progressive or left to ask what it signifies not about Ron Paul, but about you that you can look the rest of us in the eye, your political colleagues and allies, and say, in effect, Well, he might be a little racist, but
How do you think that sounds to black people, without whom no remotely progressive candidate stands a chance of winning shit in this country at a national level? How does it sound to them a group that has been more loyal to progressive and left politics than any group in this country when you praise a man who opposes probably the single most important piece of legislation ever passed in this country, and whose position on the right of businesses to discriminate, places him on the side of the segregated lunchcounter owners? And how do you think they take it that you praise this man, or possibly even support him for president, all so as to teach the black guy currently in the office a lesson for failing to live up to your expectations?
How do you think it sounds to them, right now, this week, as we prepare to mark the Martin Luther King Jr. holiday, that you claim to be progressive, and yet you are praising or even encouraging support for a man who voted against that holiday, who opposes almost every aspect of Kings public policy agenda, and the crowning achievements of the movement he helped lead?
...
In short, if youre still disappointed in Barack Obama, its only because you never understood whose job it was to produce change in the first place. But dont take out your own failings in this regard on the rest of us, by giving ideological cover and assorted journalistic love taps to a guy who believes the poor should rely on the charitable impulses of doctors to provide for their medical needs, including, one presumes, chemotherapy; or that America was meant to be a robustly Christian nation, but is being currently undermined by secularists; or who puts the term gay rights in quotation marks when he writes it, and believes states should be free to criminalize homosexual intercourse, and who is such a homophobe that he wont even use the bathroom in a gay mans house; or who has all but said that he would like to take America back to the early 1800s, in terms of the scope of government: a truly glorious time to be sure, if you were white, male and owned property.
Much much more at link: http://www.timwise.org/2012/01/of-broken-clocks-presidential-candidates-and-the-confusion-of-certain-white-liberals/
158 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Tim Wise: Of Broken Clocks, Presidential Candidates, and the Confusion of Certain White Liberals [View all]
PeaceNikki
Jan 2012
OP
The essay? Are you familiar with his work? Did you read the whole piece or just the snip I posted?
PeaceNikki
Jan 2012
#2
can someone provide a list of liberals and progressives who are allegedly supporting paul?
frylock
Jan 2012
#3
Time Wise deserves a lifetime service award from every black organization (imho)
Number23
Jan 2012
#9
First of all, the notion that "some liberals" are "fawning" over Paul is simply a stalking horse
MadHound
Jan 2012
#21
Nobody on DU wants to post written articles by these assholes. Did you lose your Google CD-ROM?
PeaceNikki
Jan 2012
#23
Well, how about you PM the names of white liberals of minimal influence that are supporting Paul.
Luminous Animal
Jan 2012
#27
actually, people are using paul as a stalking horse to trash obama. first it was DK, then elizabeth
dionysus
Jan 2012
#33
You will never get an answer. And yet that NonAnswer is celebrated on DU as "facts".
Luminous Animal
Jan 2012
#95
Someone even took the time to collect dissident posts. It's a long ass list...
Luminous Animal
Jan 2012
#96
If by "it" you mean disgust at simple-minded people that want to argue and disagree
Number23
Jan 2012
#76
If you read the damned article, you'd get the very thing you are trying your absolute HARDEST
Number23
Jan 2012
#73
here's the answer. there is no answer. why? because these supporters don't exist..
frylock
Jan 2012
#88
The self-identified liberals and possibly Democrats who voted for Ron Paul in NH?
joshcryer
Jan 2012
#148
Not sure what you are speaking of? I don't like Paul, and my point is that anyone
Bluenorthwest
Jan 2012
#114
Exactly. It is so much more fulfilling apparently for some to run up and down
Number23
Jan 2012
#135
What the fuck is the deal with the no accountability and no responsibility for elected officials
TheKentuckian
Jan 2012
#98
Oh, I looked all through Good Reads before posting this article there this AM
Bolo Boffin
Jan 2012
#112
Everyone who is not actively worshipping Obama is implicitly supporting Ron Paul
kenny blankenship
Jan 2012
#155