Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

HariSeldon

(541 posts)
19. I appreciate the sentiment, but...
Thu Nov 25, 2021, 03:26 PM
Nov 2021

...as a systems thinker, I'd have to say that "essentialness" is not a Boolean condition, but measured by how long the average person can go without the provided service before experiencing lasting negative consequences, where lower values indicate higher "essentialness." This puts EMTs, firefighters, and emergency care medical workers at the highest level of essentialness, but then police, utility workers, other medical providers, followed by retail food workers, food transport providers, automotive fuel providers (retail and supply chain), etc.

In a short term situation, especially one planned in advance, only the "less than a few hours" level of essential workers should be needed. But there are essential services we, as a society, depend on that cannot be suspended for months at a time which did not need to operate today.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Servers/cooks at restaurants open today. Heartstrings Nov 2021 #1
Not just the truck stop restaurants, FoxNewsSucks Nov 2021 #6
Exactly! Heartstrings Nov 2021 #10
Hospital call center employee. House of Roberts Nov 2021 #2
Happy Thanksgiving to all the volunteers... MiHale Nov 2021 #3
Hotline call center or just me Tetrachloride Nov 2021 #4
The people tasked with cooking a huge dinner for a whole bunch of family and/or friends BComplex Nov 2021 #5
All the people working in gas stations, grocery stores and CVS-type stores FoxNewsSucks Nov 2021 #7
Payroll clerk. twodogsbarking Nov 2021 #8
My E.M.T. 3Hotdogs Nov 2021 #9
Those Rebl2 Nov 2021 #11
Most military and naval personnel n/t sarge43 Nov 2021 #12
Newspaper reporters Wicked Blue Nov 2021 #13
Retail workers who have to work Black Friday during the era of maskholes and Karens jmbar2 Nov 2021 #14
Grocery workers Sherman A1 Nov 2021 #15
I thanked the self-checkout clerk and offered her sympathies for working today. denbot Nov 2021 #27
IT Workers keeping the servers and routers running so we can converse here in Virtual world. Tommymac Nov 2021 #16
thank you Skittles Nov 2021 #21
Me too Tommymac Nov 2021 #26
Vet techs and veterinarians. Bantamfancier Nov 2021 #17
Happy Thanksgiving Essential Workers MustLoveBeagles Nov 2021 #18
I appreciate the sentiment, but... HariSeldon Nov 2021 #19
I'm working today Skittles Nov 2021 #20
I'm Nonessential ProfessorGAC Nov 2021 #22
I will be working all night Skittles Nov 2021 #24
We Got Both Days Off ProfessorGAC Nov 2021 #28
And they should be paid accordingly. If you're essential, you should be paid SIGNIFICANTLY more... wackadoo wabbit Nov 2021 #23
Me, former long haul trucker, now night dispatch for the same company. denbot Nov 2021 #25
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»The perfect definition of...»Reply #19