General Discussion

Martin68

(28,305 posts)

49. I've done a lot of research on the topic. I believe the preponderance of the evidence suggests Japan

Tue Mar 29, 2022, 05:49 PM

Mar 2022

was stalling in negotiations and had no intention of surrendering. There was a fanatic belief that Japan should never surrender, and that it was honorable to die for the Emperor. An invasion of the Japanese mainland would have resulted in horrific fatalities. The invasion of Okinawa killed 12,500 Americans and 110,000 Japanese. I lived in Japan for 20 years and explored some of the miles of caves dug out along the coastline for the final defense of the Japanese homeland - by civilians as well as military personnel. The second bomb on Nagasaki persuaded the Emperor to surrender against the advice of his military chiefs. I've talked to Americans who were slated to participate in the planned invasion of the Japanese mainland. They are very appreciative of the use of the bombs. Remember, the death toll among Japanese would have been even higher than the US.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

55 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

This Is What It's Like to Witness a Nuclear Explosion [View all] L. Coyote Mar 2022 OP

Seems lots of people want war, yagotme Mar 2022 #1

I am going to disagree with you. Dan Mar 2022 #9

Unfortunately drmeow Mar 2022 #36

I remember that, during the run up to the Iraq invasion, wnylib Mar 2022 #44

My Memory Of That Event... ProfessorGAC Mar 2022 #52

Sanity is not the issue. yagotme Mar 2022 #54

Absolutely true, but nuclear war is only unthinkable if both sides know the other side is willing to Martin68 Mar 2022 #18

A hydrogen bomb makes what we dropped Mr.Bill Mar 2022 #2

They made a mathmatical error on the potential yield for the first Castle Bravo test at Bikini pecosbob Mar 2022 #7

Both my father and uncle worked on Minuteman missiles in the sixties pecosbob Mar 2022 #3

Incidents with non-nuclear Minuteman missiles? Or perhaps you are referring to the extremely close Martin68 Mar 2022 #19

More like maintenance problems and issues...near-repeats of the Titan explosion in Chico in 1962 pecosbob Mar 2022 #24

I witnessed one such test as a kid Bobstandard Mar 2022 #4

it was Barium kiri Mar 2022 #25

Its the color of the end of the world Bobstandard Mar 2022 #34

I often wonder what radiation from wnylib Mar 2022 #45

Guy I worked with was in the army in the 50's. Bunches of soldiers were sent to Utah and ordered 3Hotdogs Mar 2022 #5

3Hotdogs, I'm not sure I understand what a red X-ray means. His body changed color? Was burned? Martin68 Mar 2022 #20

Just like in the cartoons, the ultra-bright light shines right through your flesh pecosbob Mar 2022 #26

It was how he saw his own body. 3Hotdogs Mar 2022 #33

My father went through the fallout from an atomic explosion in the South Pacific when he was Dial H For Hero Mar 2022 #6

My BIL was a radar navigator on a SAC B52. His crew's plan was to drop their load on the target in mobeau69 Mar 2022 #8

My father-in-law was used as a guinea pig in nuclear weapons testing... hunter Mar 2022 #10

Their eyewitness accounts is pretty horrific Dukkha Mar 2022 #13

What kind of psychopaths set up these experiments? hunter Mar 2022 #17

Psychopaths who needed to know the effects of radiation and a nuclear bomb. The fact is, no one Martin68 Mar 2022 #21

Nagasaki was the experiment. That was the "bomb of the future" and the psychopaths... hunter Mar 2022 #48

I've done a lot of research on the topic. I believe the preponderance of the evidence suggests Japan Martin68 Mar 2022 #49

Neither the U.S. invasion forces nor the Japanese knew those bombs were coming. hunter Mar 2022 #53

Yes, history is messy and difficult to categorize as good vs evil or black and white. Martin68 Mar 2022 #55

There were also studies that used disabled children thucythucy Mar 2022 #35

Some talked, especially online Warpy Mar 2022 #30

In the story I heard everyone volunteered except the poor cameraman pecosbob Mar 2022 #27

Young men "volunteer" for a lot of stuff in the military. hunter Mar 2022 #32

Sounds like he got significantly irradiated Shermann Mar 2022 #11

How would you know if at the time you were irradiated with UV, gamma or X-rays? Martin68 Mar 2022 #23

After further review, he probably didn't get that much. Shermann Mar 2022 #47

"Now I am become death, the destroyer of worlds." quoted by Oppenheimer as he niyad Mar 2022 #12

We'll never know it's coming bucolic_frolic Mar 2022 #14

I hope not Warpy Mar 2022 #16

My exact plan. MuseRider Mar 2022 #50

Just bend over and kiss your ass goodbye. It's called "taking the position." I did it with my Martin68 Mar 2022 #22

Yeah, MuseRider Mar 2022 #51

This is what it could be like: Polybius Mar 2022 #38

Will theft and plunder begin before the strike, or after? bucolic_frolic Mar 2022 #41

After Polybius Mar 2022 #43

Where is the best place to be during an atomic explosion? spike jones Mar 2022 #15

In a nuclear war the best place to be is at ground zero. marie999 Mar 2022 #40

Can't remember all of the Nuclear Holocaust documentaries/movies I saw in the the 60's to 70's, but marked50 Mar 2022 #28

I remember people building nuclear bomb shelters and keeping them supplied so they could live ... L. Coyote Mar 2022 #29

I remember the Bomb Shelter thing too. marked50 Mar 2022 #31

Why didn't we end the USSR when it was hinted that they were working on a nuke? Polybius Mar 2022 #37

Because that would be an act of war! L. Coyote Mar 2022 #39

But a good act of war Polybius Mar 2022 #42

Russia had just kicked Hitler's ass and smashed his face into the icy mud. hunter Mar 2022 #46